AbstractEliminating cobalt from high‐nickel layered oxide cathodes lowers the cost of lithium‐ion batteries for electric vehicles. However, cobalt‐free cathodes with high Mn4+ and Ni2+ contents are prone to Li/Ni mixing after synthesis, potentially compromising battery energy density, rate capability, and cycling stability. Without cobalt facilitating cation ordering in the layered structure, the degree of Li/Ni mixing in cobalt‐free cathodes depends heavily on the calcination conditions. In this study, a systematic exploration of calcination temperatures and LiOH ratio for LiNi0.9Mn0.1O2 (NM‐90) provides detailed insights into the optimal synthesis conditions for high‐capacity cobalt‐free cathodes with extended cycle life. Surprisingly, high Li/Ni mixing does not necessarily lead to poor cycling stability whereas low Li/Ni mixing does not guarantee a long cycle life. More importantly, although excessive calcination temperature can further decrease Li/Ni mixing, it does not necessarily enhance capacity. Instead, the pernicious effects from the H2 → H3 phase transition are amplified due to a pronounced two‐phase reaction. An extensive suite of chemical and structural characterization methods uncovers a correlation between elevated calcination temperature, phase transformation, cation ordering, and capacity fading behavior: “overcooking” high‐nickel, cobalt‐free cathodes induce structural arrangement toward that of LiNiO2, with exacerbated lattice distortion and surface instability accelerating capacity fade.