Phase-separated Membraneless Organelles Research Articles

Intricate roles of spacers and stickers of Arg-rich C9ORF72 dipeptide repeat proteins; from toxicity to targeting to membraneless organelles

C9ORF72, one of the most common genes implicated in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia, induces neurodegeneration through various pathways. The most notable is interference through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). LLPS is a biophysical phenomenon involved in many fundamental biological processes, such as the formation of membraneless organelles (MLOs), transcription, and nucleocytoplasmic transport. The Arg-rich dipeptide repeat proteins (R-DPRs) produced from the aberrant C9ORF72 gene are highly charged and are incorporated into the phase-separated MLOs, inhibiting their functions. However, the detailed molecular mechanism remains to be elucidated. Recently, we analyzed the structure-function relationship of R-DPRs and clarified the mechanism by which the sticker Arg and the spacer Pro/Gly regulate cytotoxicity and subcellular localization. Natural R-DPRs contribute to the localization of specific MLOs. In this review, we discuss the roles of the sticker and spacer of R-DPRs in the LLPS and how they regulate subcellular localization, protein-protein interaction, and neurotoxicity.

Pharmacological perturbation of the phase-separating protein SMNDC1

SMNDC1 is a Tudor domain protein that recognizes di-methylated arginines and controls gene expression as an essential splicing factor. Here, we study the specific contributions of the SMNDC1 Tudor domain to protein-protein interactions, subcellular localization, and molecular function. To perturb the protein function in cells, we develop small molecule inhibitors targeting the dimethylarginine binding pocket of the SMNDC1 Tudor domain. We find that SMNDC1 localizes to phase-separated membraneless organelles that partially overlap with nuclear speckles. This condensation behavior is driven by the unstructured C-terminal region of SMNDC1, depends on RNA interaction and can be recapitulated in vitro. Inhibitors of the protein’s Tudor domain drastically alter protein-protein interactions and subcellular localization, causing splicing changes for SMNDC1-dependent genes. These compounds will enable further pharmacological studies on the role of SMNDC1 in the regulation of nuclear condensates, gene regulation and cell identity.

Landscape of semi-extractable RNAs across five human cell lines.

Phase-separated membraneless organelles often contain RNAs that exhibit unusual semi-extractability using the conventional RNA extraction method, and can be efficiently retrieved by needle shearing or heating during RNA extraction. Semi-extractable RNAs are promising resources for understanding RNA-centric phase separation. However, limited assessments have been performed to systematically identify and characterize semi-extractable RNAs. In this study, 1074 semi-extractable RNAs, including ASAP1, DANT2, EXT1, FTX, IGF1R, LIMS1, NEAT1, PHF21A, PVT1, SCMH1, STRG.3024.1, TBL1X, TCF7L2, TVP23C-CDRT4, UBE2E2, ZCCHC7, ZFAND3 and ZSWIM6, which exhibited consistent semi-extractability were identified across five human cell lines. By integrating publicly available datasets, we found that semi-extractable RNAs tend to be distributed in the nuclear compartments but are dissociated from the chromatin. Long and repeat-containing semi-extractable RNAs act as hubs to provide global RNA-RNA interactions. Semi-extractable RNAs were divided into four groups based on their k-mer content. The NEAT1 group preferred to interact with paraspeckle proteins, such as FUS and NONO, implying that RNAs in this group are potential candidates of architectural RNAs that constitute nuclear bodies.

Stress granule formation inhibits stress-induced apoptosis by selectively sequestering executioner caspases

Cytoplasmic stress granules (SGs) are phase-separated membrane-less organelles that form in response to various stress stimuli. SGs are mainly composed of non-canonical stalled 48S preinitiation complexes. In addition, many other proteins also accumulate into SGs, but the list is still incomplete. SG assembly suppresses apoptosis and promotes cell survival under stress. Furthermore, hyperformation of SGs is frequently observed in various human cancers and accelerates tumor development and progression by reducing stress-induced damage of cancer cells. Therefore, they are of clinical importance. However, the precise mechanism underlying SG-mediated inhibition of apoptosis remains ill-defined. Here, using a proximity-labeling proteomic approach, we comprehensively analyzed SG-resident proteins and identified the executioner caspases, caspase-3 and -7, as SG components. We demonstrate that accumulation of caspase-3/7 into SGs is mediated by evolutionarily conserved amino acid residues within their large catalytic domains and inhibits caspase activities and consequent apoptosis induced by various stresses. Expression of an SG-localization-deficient caspase-3 mutant in cells largely counteracted the anti-apoptotic effect of SGs, whereas enforced relocalization of the caspase-3 mutant to SGs restored it. Thus, SG-mediated sequestration of executioner caspases is a mechanism underlying the broad cytoprotective function of SGs. Furthermore, using a mouse xenograft tumor model, we show that this mechanism prevents cancer cells from apoptosis in tumor tissues, thereby promoting cancer progression. Our results reveal the functional crosstalk between SG-mediated cell survival and caspase-mediated cell death signaling pathways and delineate a molecular mechanism that dictates cell-fate decisions under stress and promotes tumorigenesis.

Droplets, tails and loops: The role of intrinsic disorder in R-loop biology.

R-loops are non-canonical triple-stranded RNA:DNA hybrid structures that perform critical biological functions. However, dysregulated R-loops can also cause cancer and neurological disorders. Previous high-throughput studies have identified over a thousand proteins involved in recognizing, preventing and resolving R-loops, with many of them containing both folded nucleic acid-binding/processing domains and Intrinsically Disordered Regions (IDRs). Nonetheless, the precise molecular mechanisms by which these proteins regulate R-loop function remain elusive. While investigating the Fragile-X Syndrome Protein (FMRP), we unexpectedly discovered that the C-Terminal IDR of FMRP, which promotes Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation (LLPS) of FMRP, is the predominant R-loop binding site, with the N-terminal domains recognizing the trailing ssRNA overhang. In addition, we have recently shown that FMRP can suppress persistent R-loops that form during transcription, a process that is also enhanced by LLPS via the assembly of membraneless transcription factories. These exciting findings prompted us to undertake a combined in-cellulo/in-silico/in-vitro approach to investigate the mechanisms of R-loop recognition, signaling, and resolution. We observed that, like FMRP, the majority of proteins in the R-loop interactome contains long IDRs that are highly enriched in low complexity sequences with biased amino acid composition. Furthermore, our analysis shows that several proteins in the R-loop interactome are either predicted to or have been experimentally demonstrated to undergo LLPS or are known to be associated with phase separated membraneless organelles. Finally, we have recently demonstrated in vitro that the IDRs of different proteins selected from the R-loop interactome can also directly recognize R-loops and undergo LLPS. Our overall results present a thought-provoking hypothesis that IDRs in the R-loop interactome provide a functional link between R-loop recognition via direct binding and downstream signaling through the assembly of LLPS-mediated membraneless R-loop foci.

Direct imaging of intracellular RNA, DNA, and liquid–liquid phase separated membraneless organelles with Raman microspectroscopy

Methodologies for direct intracellular imaging of RNA and DNA are necessary for the advancement of bioimaging. Here we show direct label-free imaging of RNA and DNA in single cells by isolating their accurate Raman spectra. Raman images of DNA from interphase cells show intact nucleus, while those from mitotic cells reveal condensed chromosome. The condensed chromosome images are accurate enough to assign the stage of mitotic cell division (e.g., metaphase). Raman spectral features indicate B-DNA double helical conformational form in all the cell lines investigated here. The Raman images of RNAs, on the other hand, reveal liquid-liquid phase separated (LLPS) membraneless organelles in interphase cells, which disappears during mitosis. Further, the Raman spectrum of proteins from the intracellular LLPS organelles indicates slight enrichment of amyloid-like secondary structural features. Vibrational imaging of intracellular DNA and RNA simultaneously would open myriad of opportunities for examining functional biochemical aspects of cells and organelles.

Single-droplet surface-enhanced Raman scattering decodes the molecular determinants of liquid-liquid phase separation

Biomolecular condensates formed via liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) are involved in a myriad of critical cellular functions and debilitating neurodegenerative diseases. Elucidating the role of intrinsic disorder and conformational heterogeneity of intrinsically disordered proteins/regions (IDPs/IDRs) in these phase-separated membrane-less organelles is crucial to understanding the mechanism of formation and regulation of biomolecular condensates. Here we introduce a unique single-droplet surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) methodology that utilizes surface-engineered, plasmonic, metal nanoparticles to unveil the inner workings of mesoscopic liquid droplets of Fused in Sarcoma (FUS) in the absence and presence of RNA. These highly sensitive measurements offer unprecedented sensitivity to capture the crucial interactions, conformational heterogeneity, and structural distributions within the condensed phase in a droplet-by-droplet manner. Such an ultra-sensitive single-droplet vibrational methodology can serve as a potent tool to decipher the key molecular drivers of biological phase transitions of a wide range of biomolecular condensates involved in physiology and disease.

Human Metapneumovirus Phosphoprotein Independently Drives Phase Separation and Recruits Nucleoprotein to Liquid-Like Bodies.

ABSTRACTHuman metapneumovirus (HMPV) inclusion bodies (IBs) are dynamic structures required for efficient viral replication and transcription. The minimum components needed to form IB-like structures in cells are the nucleoprotein (N) and the tetrameric phosphoprotein (P). HMPV P binds to the following two versions of the N protein in infected cells: N-terminal P residues interact with monomeric N (N0) to maintain a pool of protein to encapsidate new RNA and C-terminal P residues interact with oligomeric, RNA-bound N (N-RNA). Recent work on other negative-strand viruses has suggested that IBs are, at least in part, liquid-like phase-separated membraneless organelles. Here, HMPV IBs in infected or transfected cells were shown to possess liquid organelle properties, such as fusion and fission. Recombinant versions of HMPV N and P proteins were purified to analyze the interactions required to drive phase separation in vitro. Purified HMPV P was shown to form liquid droplets in isolation. This observation is distinct from other viral systems that also form IBs. Partial removal of nucleic acid from purified P altered phase-separation dynamics, suggesting that nucleic acid interactions play a role in IB formation. HMPV P also recruits monomeric N (N0-P) and N-RNA to droplets in vitro. These findings suggest that HMPV P may also act as a scaffold protein to mediate multivalent interactions with monomeric and oligomeric N, as well as RNA, to promote phase separation of IBs. Together, these findings highlight an additional layer of regulation in HMPV replication by the viral P and N proteins.

A Tale of Loops and Tails: The Role of Intrinsically Disordered Protein Regions in R-Loop Recognition and Phase Separation.

R-loops are non-canonical, three-stranded nucleic acid structures composed of a DNA:RNA hybrid, a displaced single-stranded (ss)DNA, and a trailing ssRNA overhang. R-loops perform critical biological functions under both normal and disease conditions. To elucidate their cellular functions, we need to understand the mechanisms underlying R-loop formation, recognition, signaling, and resolution. Previous high-throughput screens identified multiple proteins that bind R-loops, with many of these proteins containing folded nucleic acid processing and binding domains that prevent (e.g., topoisomerases), resolve (e.g., helicases, nucleases), or recognize (e.g., KH, RRMs) R-loops. However, a significant number of these R-loop interacting Enzyme and Reader proteins also contain long stretches of intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs). The precise molecular and structural mechanisms by which the folded domains and IDRs synergize to recognize and process R-loops or modulate R-loop-mediated signaling have not been fully explored. While studying one such modular R-loop Reader, the Fragile X Protein (FMRP), we unexpectedly discovered that the C-terminal IDR (C-IDR) of FMRP is the predominant R-loop binding site, with the three N-terminal KH domains recognizing the trailing ssRNA overhang. Interestingly, the C-IDR of FMRP has recently been shown to undergo spontaneous Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation (LLPS) assembly by itself or in complex with another non-canonical nucleic acid structure, RNA G-quadruplex. Furthermore, we have recently shown that FMRP can suppress persistent R-loops that form during transcription, a process that is also enhanced by LLPS via the assembly of membraneless transcription factories. These exciting findings prompted us to explore the role of IDRs in R-loop processing and signaling proteins through a comprehensive bioinformatics and computational biology study. Here, we evaluated IDR prevalence, sequence composition and LLPS propensity for the known R-loop interactome. We observed that, like FMRP, the majority of the R-loop interactome, especially Readers, contains long IDRs that are highly enriched in low complexity sequences with biased amino acid composition, suggesting that these IDRs could directly interact with R-loops, rather than being “mere flexible linkers” connecting the “functional folded enzyme or binding domains”. Furthermore, our analysis shows that several proteins in the R-loop interactome are either predicted to or have been experimentally demonstrated to undergo LLPS or are known to be associated with phase separated membraneless organelles. Thus, our overall results present a thought-provoking hypothesis that IDRs in the R-loop interactome can provide a functional link between R-loop recognition via direct binding and downstream signaling through the assembly of LLPS-mediated membrane-less R-loop foci. The absence or dysregulation of the function of IDR-enriched R-loop interactors can potentially lead to severe genomic defects, such as the widespread R-loop-mediated DNA double strand breaks that we recently observed in Fragile X patient-derived cells.

Murine GFP-Mx1 forms nuclear condensates and associates with cytoplasmic intermediate filaments: Novel antiviral activity against VSV

Type I and III interferons induce expression of the “myxovirus resistance proteins” MxA in human cells and its ortholog Mx1 in murine cells. Human MxA forms cytoplasmic structures, whereas murine Mx1 forms nuclear bodies. Whereas both HuMxA and MuMx1 are antiviral toward influenza A virus (FLUAV) (an orthomyxovirus), only HuMxA is considered antiviral toward vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) (a rhabdovirus). We previously reported that the cytoplasmic human GFP-MxA structures were phase-separated membraneless organelles (“biomolecular condensates”). In the present study, we investigated whether nuclear murine Mx1 structures might also represent phase-separated biomolecular condensates. The transient expression of murine GFP-Mx1 in human Huh7 hepatoma, human Mich-2H6 melanoma, and murine NIH 3T3 cells led to the appearance of Mx1 nuclear bodies. These GFP-MuMx1 nuclear bodies were rapidly disassembled by exposing cells to 1,6-hexanediol (5%, w/v), or to hypotonic buffer (40–50 mosm), consistent with properties of membraneless phase-separated condensates. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) assays revealed that the GFP-MuMx1 nuclear bodies upon photobleaching showed a slow partial recovery (mobile fraction: ∼18%) suggestive of a gel-like consistency. Surprisingly, expression of GFP-MuMx1 in Huh7 cells also led to the appearance of GFP-MuMx1 in 20–30% of transfected cells in a novel cytoplasmic giantin-based intermediate filament meshwork and in cytoplasmic bodies. Remarkably, Huh7 cells with cytoplasmic murine GFP-MuMx1 filaments, but not those with only nuclear bodies, showed antiviral activity toward VSV. Thus, GFP-MuMx1 nuclear bodies comprised phase-separated condensates. Unexpectedly, GFP-MuMx1 in Huh7 cells also associated with cytoplasmic giantin-based intermediate filaments, and such cells showed antiviral activity toward VSV.

Modes of phase separation affecting chromatin regulation.

It has become evident that chromatin in cell nuclei is organized at multiple scales. Significant effort has been devoted to understanding the connection between the nuclear environment and the diverse biological processes taking place therein. A fundamental question is how cells manage to orchestrate these reactions, both spatially and temporally. Recent insights into phase-separated membraneless organelles may be the key for answering this. Of the two models that have been proposed for phase-separated entities, one largely depends on chromatin–protein interactions and the other on multivalent protein–protein and/or protein–RNA ones. Each has its own characteristics, but both would be able to, at least in part, explain chromatin and transcriptional organization. Here, we attempt to give an overview of these two models and their studied examples to date, before discussing the forces that could govern phase separation and prevent it from arising unrestrainedly.

More than just a phase: the search for membraneless organelles in the bacterial cytoplasm.

The bacterial cytoplasm, once thought to be a relatively undifferentiated reaction medium, has now been recognized to have extensive microstructure. This microstructure includes bacterial microcompartments, inclusion bodies, granules, and even some membrane-bound vesicles. Several recent papers suggest that bacteria may also organize their cytoplasm using an additional mechanism: phase-separated membraneless organelles, a strategy commonly used by eukaryotes. Phase-separated membraneless organelles such as Cajal bodies, the nucleolus, and stress granules allow proteins to become concentrated in sub-compartments of eukaryotic cells without being surrounded by a barrier to diffusion. In this review, we summarize the known structural organization of the bacterial cytoplasm and discuss the recent evidence that phase-separated membraneless organelles might also play a role in bacterial systems. We specifically focus on bacterial ribonucleoprotein complexes and two different protein components of the bacterial nucleoid that may have the ability to form subcellular partitions within bacteria cells.

Architectural RNAs for Membraneless Nuclear Body Formation

Long noncoding RNAs (lncRNAs) are fundamental regulators of various cellular processes. A subset of lncRNAs, termed architectural RNAs (arcRNAs), function in the formation and maintenance of phase-separated membraneless organelles in multiple eukaryotic species. These membraneless organelles represent an important type of compartmentalization in the crowded cellular environment and have several distinct features. The NEAT1_2 lncRNA is a well-characterized arcRNA that functions as an essential scaffold of paraspeckle nuclear bodies. Here, we describe the biogenesis of paraspeckles on arcRNAs through phase separation, focusing on the specific functions of multiple NEAT1_2 RNA domains and their partner RNA-binding proteins. Finally, we present an updated model of paraspeckle formation and discuss future perspectives of research into arcRNA-instructed architectures of phase-separated nuclear bodies.

Enzymatic complexes across scales.

An unprecedented opportunity to integrate ~100 years of meticulous in vitro biomolecular research is currently provided in the light of recent advances in methods to visualize closer-to-native architectures of biomolecular machines, and metabolic enzymes in particular. Traditional views of enzymes, namely biomolecular machines, only partially explain their role, organization and kinetics in the cellular milieu. Enzymes self- or hetero-associate, form fibers, may bind to membranes or cytoskeletal elements, have regulatory roles, associate into higher order assemblies (metabolons) or even actively participate in phase-separated membraneless organelles, and all the above in a transient, temporal and spatial manner in response to environmental changes or structural/functional changes of their assemblies. Here, we focus on traditional and emerging concepts in cellular biochemistry and discuss new opportunities in bridging structural, molecular and cellular analyses for metabolic pathways, accumulated over the years, highlighting functional aspects of enzymatic complexes discussed across different levels of spatial resolution.

Disordered Substrates of the 20S Proteasome Link Degradation with Phase Separation.

The 20S proteasome is known to degrade intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) via an ubiquitin-independent, disorder-driven mechanism. Unless protected within protein complexes or macromolecular assemblies, certain IDPs can undergo degradation mediated directly by the 20S core particle. In this issue of Proteomics, Myers etal. utilize a proteomics approach to identify ∼500 IDP substrates of the 20S proteasome. Bioinformatics analyses of these substrates demonstrate a large fraction of highly disordered RNA-binding proteins, enriched in low-complexity, prion-like domains. A number of these proteins are also known to form phase-separated membraneless organelles in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and other protein neuropathies. The Myers etal. study highlights potentially interesting connections between IDP degradation and the regulatory dynamics of phase-separated intracellular assemblies. Their work should stimulate further research into the mechanistic details of how the 20S proteasome controls cellular abundances of RNA-binding proteins and thereby regulates RNA-related biological functions within both physiological and pathological phase-separated assemblies.