This study explored the antimicrobial effects of ketoprofen, piroxicam, and celecoxib alone or combined with calcium hydroxide (CH) against two strains of Enterococcus faecalis (E. faecalis) and assessed the influence of such combinations on the pH of CH. Minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of the three tested NSAIDs were determined. Tested pastes were placed into wells punched in seeded agar plates and the bacterial inhibition zones were measured. Antibiofilm activity was assessed against 3 weeks of biofilm induced in bovine dentine blocks. The pH of the pastes was measured at four-time intervals. MIC values were 3.12, 25, and 25mg/ml for ketoprofen, piroxicam, and celecoxib, respectively, and were similar for both bacterial strains except for celecoxib, which showed 8% growth at the highest tested concentration against vancomycin-resistant E. faecalis. Ketoprofen had the largest mean inhibition zone that was comparable to CH. None of the six tested pastes exhibited antibiofilm activity of a significant level in comparison to CH. A noticeable increase in the antibiofilm activity was found when 20% NSAIDs were added to CH while maintaining an alkaline pH. Ketoprofen was found to be the most effective among the tested NSAIDs. Although its effect was comparable to CH, adding ketoprofen at a ratio of 20% resulted in 50% higher antimicrobial action than CH alone. Accordingly, incorporating NSAIDs in inter-appointment dressing has the potential to utilize their anti-inflammatory, local analgesic, and antibacterial actions, which overcome the limitations of CH and improve the outcome of root canal treatment.