The convergence of several Galerkin-Petrov methods is established, including polynomial collocation and analytic element collocation methods, for Toeplitz operators on the Bergman space of the unit disk. In particular, it is shown that such methods converge if the basis and test functions (or the collocation points) own certain circular symmetry, whereas unfortunate choice of the basis and test parameters produces nonconvergent Galerkin–Petrov methods.