ABSTRACT This paper assesses the implementation of the Colombian Constitutional Court's 2016 Judgment T-622, which tackled human and environmental rights violations in the Atrato River basin due to extensive illegal mining, focusing on how it has enhanced community participation in environmental governance. The decision granted ‘biocultural’ rights to the river, its tributaries, and their human inhabitants. Findings indicate improved communication between riverine communities and Colombia's national government via the new Commission of River Guardians. However, significant gaps remain in integrating local communities into broader environmental governance seven years after the ruling, with current efforts mainly preparatory. Progress in executing the judgment, particularly in social benefits and reducing pollution, has been limited. This emphasises the urgency of addressing persistent chemical pollution in the river, as well as the equally persistent government neglect towards the river and its people. This paper argues for a restructuring of the legal framework for environmental governance in Colombia towards a participatory governance framework fitted for socioecological transitions, as the current structure hinders the full implementation of biocultural rights. Failing to implement the Atrato judicial decision risks deepening disillusionment with legal and political institutions among underserved riverine communities, posing a dual existential threat to ecosystems and democracy.
Read full abstract