Abstract Background Oesophageal cancer is a leading cause of cancer-related death worldwide, with oesophagec-tomy being the primary treatment for curable disease. This study compares loco-regional and distal disease recurrence patterns between minimally invasive oesophagectomy (MIO) and left thoracoabdominal oesophagectomy (LTAO) using a matched dataset. The definition of loco-regional recurrence remains unclear in the literature. In this study, loco-regional recur-rence is categorised as recurrence in the oesophageal bed, anastomosis, or local nodes in the mediastinum and upper abdomen. Method Patients from 2014 to 2021 were identified and followed until 31/12/2023. Data on MIOs and LTAO were collected from a prospectively maintained database. Gastroesophageal junction and distal oesophagus adenocarcinomas were included, and all received neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Out of 302 eligible patients, 104 were successfully matched. The primary outcome was overall cancer recurrence. Categorical variables were compared using chi-square tests, and non-parametric contin-uous variables with Mann-Whitney U tests. Propensity score matching, accounted for baseline differences. Logistic regression generated propensity scores for age, gender, and tumour stage. Operative approach was the dependant variable. The groups were then selected using ‘nearest neighbour’ matching. Results The study compared 52 cases each of LTAO and MIO. Postoperative complications were similar, LTAO (58%) and MIO (52%) P=0.554. The R0 resection rate was higher in LTAO (90%) compared to MIO (81%) P=0.163. Recurrence was significantly higher in LTAO (42%) than MIO (23%) P=0.037. Local recurrence rates were 15% for LTAO and 8% for MIO P=0.22. Distant recurrence was 35% for LTAO and 21% for MIO P=0.111. Notably, peritoneal recurrence was significantly higher in LTAO (12%) P=0.012. There was no difference in median time to recurrence. Mortality rate was similar: 38% for LTAO and 35% for MIO P=0.684. Conclusion The study found that while postoperative complications and mortality rates were similar between LTAO and MIO, LTAO had a significantly higher overall recurrence rate and notably higher peritoneal recurrence. There was no significant difference in median time to recurrence between the two groups. These findings suggest that MIO may be associated with better long-term outcomes in terms of recurrence.
Read full abstract