Reviewed by: Andrew Jackson Donelson: Jacksonian and Unionist by Richard Douglas Spence Anthony A. Repucci Andrew Jackson Donelson: Jacksonian and Unionist. Richard Douglas Spence. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press, 2017. ISBN 978-0-8265-2163-7, 448 pp., cloth, $39.95. Occasionally, individuals working in the shadows are the unsung drivers of history. Andrew Jackson Donelson is a fine biography of one of the unsung figures of the Jackson era. Richard Douglas Spence, a plant physiologist, has written a thoroughly researched, and updated biography of Andrew Jackson Donelson, the nephew and ward of President Andrew Jackson. Donelson's diverse career as a presidential advisor, diplomat, and politician placed him in the center of the critical events of the Jackson era. Spence argues that Donelson worked tirelessly to promote Jackson's vision of democracy and Union, while seeking to bridge the divisions of partisan and regional tensions that threatened to divide the country. Donelson's career "intersected many of the great events and personalities of the period … one of those [End Page 306] obscure but central figures who always seem to be at the background of history, often as a valued contributor or assistant to people in more prominent positions" (281). The book traces the major events chronologically and thematically. The first half covers the Andrew Jackson and Martin Van Buren presidencies, while the second half focuses on Donelson's career as a diplomat and politician. Early in Jackson's first term, Secretary of War John Henry Eaton's marriage to Margaret O'Neale Timberlake, the widow of a naval officer, created a perfect storm of controversy that tested the limits of Donelson's loyalty to his uncle. Washing-ton society suspected Margaret Timberlake of infidelity to her late husband. The controversy spilled over into Jackson's cabinet and family as the wives of cabinet officials and Donelson's wife, Emily, refused to receive Mrs. Eaton socially. Spence argues that Jackson's tendency to personalize political disputes fractured his cabinet and strained his relationship with Donelson. Jackson internalized the attacks on Mrs. Eaton's virtue, believing the "petticoat war" was part of a conspiracy John C. Calhoun orchestrated to undermine his presidency. Spence contends that the Eaton controversy consumed a great deal of presidential energy during Jackson's first term; altered the political dynamic of the era; marked the rise to prominence of Van Buren, who supported Eaton; and destroyed the presidential aspirations of Calhoun. Spence asserts that the petticoat war became "entangled with several major issues of Jackson's first term, and after that to a greater or lesser degree, influenced the course of contemporary national politics" (62). Following the consequent cabinet purge that resolved the controversy, Jackson relied on a network of informal advisors, his "kitchen cabinet," and Donelson performed the more mundane duties of presidential secretary, drafting letters and documents. Consequently, Donelson played a peripheral role in the major events of the Jackson presidency acting as a confidant and loyal supporter but "did little to shape Jacksonian philosophy" (65). His role as Jackson's secretary won him the respect of the period's significant political figures. His skills of discretion and tact were well suited to working behind the scenes with members of the administration and Congress. He played an active role in the disputes that split the democratic coalition in Tennessee and elevated John Bell and James K. Polk to prominence. Donelson successfully parried efforts to discredit the administration while at the same time engineering support for James K. Polk as speaker of the House, ensuring the continuation of Jacksonian policies. In 1844, President John Tyler appointed Donelson chargé d'affaires to the Republic of Texas, where he successfully superintended the treaty of annexation. Recognizing his diplomatic accomplishments, President James K. Polk named Donelson minister plenipotentiary of the United States to Prussia. The climax of Donelson's political career was his ill-fated candidacy as Millard Fillmore's American [End Page 307] Party vice presidential running mate in the election of 1856. Donelson's devotion to the Union and Jackson's legacy as its champion faced its severest test during the secession crisis of 1860–61. Torn by his devotion to the Union and loyalty to his...