This case study documents the management of a 17-year-old male patient who encountered an uncommon complication during orthodontic treatment: the accidental lodgment of an orthodontic bracket into the extraction site of tooth 34. This event resulted in localized gingival inflammation and vertical bone loss between the adjacent teeth 33 and 35, complicating the orthodontic process. Immediate periodontal intervention was employed, involving a combination of flap surgery, meticulous debridement, and the local application of antibiotics. The timely response led to successful removal of the foreign body, resolution of the inflammation, and restoration of bone levels. The patient’s orthodontic treatment was subsequently continued. A follow-up period of two years demonstrated complete bone recovery without further complications. This study case demonstrates the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration in managing unexpected challenges during orthodontic care and highlights the potential for successful outcomes through prompt and appropriate periodontal management during orthodontic therapy.