Aim: The irrigation method is effective on the dentinal tubule penetration (DTP) of endodontic pastes, which is important for treatment outcome. The purpose of this study was to compare the effect of different irrigation techniques on the DTP of bioceramic endodontic paste with CLSM. Materials and Methods: A total of 52 mandibular premolar root canals were shaped with the ProTaper Next files and were divided randomly into four experimental groups ( n = 13) according to the final irrigation method with 17% EDTA and 5.25% NaOCl as follows: Group 1: Conventional needle irrigation (CNI), Group 2: sonic activation (SA), Group 3: passive ultrasonic activation (PUA), Group 4: XP-endo Finisher (XPF). After final irrigation, root canals were obturated with a bioceramic sealer labeled with the fluorescent dye. The roots were sectioned horizontally at three different levels, and 1 ± 0.1 mm thick sections were obtained to examine under CLSM. The penetration area (PA), maximum tubule penetration (MTP), and the percentage of penetration (PP) values were statistically evaluated with the two-way repeated measurements ANOVA test. The Tukey (HSD) test was carried out for intergroup comparisons ( p < .01). The relationship between the MTP, PP, and PA at each root level was evaluated using Pearson’s correlation test. Results: In the middle sections, the penetration area of the sealer was higher in the SA group (7.120 ± 1.470) compared to the other groups ( p < .01). Penetration area was higher in the XPF group (11.830 ± 1.370) in the coronal section compared to CNI (7.034 ± 0.926) ( p < .01). No significant difference was observed between the MTP and PP values of the experimental groups ( p > .01). DTP of sealer was statistically similar for each irrigation method in the apical section. The coronal regions showed higher DTP values compared with the apical regions. There was a linear relationship between the PA and MTP values at all root levels of experimental groups ( p < .05). The linear relationship between the PA and PP was not significant in the XP group ( p > .05). Conclusion: The penetration area of SA was larger than others in the middle section, and XPF was superior to CNI in the coronal section. DTP of the sealer in the apical regions was lower than in the coronal regions.
Read full abstract