-We used four reasonably large samples (83-213) of Mallard (Anas platyrhynchos) and Blue-winged Teal (A. discors) nests on an interstate highway right-of-way in southcentral North Dakota to evaluate potential biases in hatch-rate estimates. Twelve consecutive, weekly searches for nests were conducted with a cable-chain drag in 1976 and 1977. Nests were revisited at weekly intervals. Four methods were used to estimate hatch rates for the four data sets: the Traditional Method, the Mayfield Method, and two modifications of the Mayfield Method that are sometimes appropriate when daily mortality rates of nests are not constant. Hatch rates and the average age of nests at discovery declined as the interval between searches decreased, suggesting that mortality rates were not constant in our samples. An analysis of variance indicated that daily mortality rates varied with the age of nests in all four samples. Mortality was generally highest during the early laying period, moderately high during the late laying period, and lowest during incubation. We speculate that this relationship of mortality to nest age might be due to the presence of hens at nests or to differences in the vulnerability of nest sites to predation. A modification of the Mayfield Method that accounts for age-related variation in nest mortality was most appropriate for our samples. We suggest methods for conducting nesting studies and estimating nest success for species possessing similar nesting habits. Received 21 January 1981, accepted 1 July 1981. INVESTIGATORS have attempted to determine the nesting success of birds for many purposes and have used diverse methods as they studied species with different breeding strategies in a wide range of habitats. One characteristic common to most studies is the method used to calculate hatch rates: the percentage of nests in an observed sample in which at least one egg hatched (referred to as the Traditional Method in this paper). Several investigators (Lack 1954: 74, Coulson 1956, Hammond and Forward 1956, Peakall 1960) recognized that hatch rates calculated in this way were biased. Hammond and Forward (1956) warned, Neglect of consideration for the length of time nests are under observation as compared to the total period they are exposed to predation would lead to a recorded success higher than that actually occurring. Eggs found in older nests are more likely to hatch than those found in younger nests, because they have already survived a period of risk to which the latter have yet to be exposed. By following this reasoning to the ultimate, it is clear that only samples of nests found on the day they are initiated will yield an unbiased hatch rate. The bias will increase with the average age of nests at discovery. Mayfield (1961) proposed a method that accounts for bias related to the age of nests at discovery by introducing into the calculations the period of time nests are under observation. Mayfield's Method will greatly reduce the bias inherent in the hatch rate calculated by the Traditional Method if daily mortality rates are reasonably constant for all nests in the sampled population. Some progress has also been made in analyzing nesting data for which daily mortality rates are not constant. Mayfield (1961, 1975) and Johnson (1979) described a method of calculating nest success when daily mortality varies among laying, incubation, and nestling stages. Johnson (1979) also proposed a method to use when the daily mortality of nests varies between population components such as yearling and older nesters. These methods will be described later in this paper. The researchers who developed these methods often depended upon hypothetical population models or pooled samples from studies conducted over a period of years and sometimes in different areas. Our study is an attempt to evaluate these methods by applying them to four reasonably large samples of nests 77 The Auk 99: 77-87. January 1982 This content downloaded from 207.46.13.189 on Thu, 04 Aug 2016 04:31:18 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 78 KLETT AND JOHNSON [Auk, Vol. 99 of two species, Mallard (Anas platyrhynchos) and Blue-winged Teal (A. discors), that were observed during 2 yr on a single study area. The specific purposes of this paper are (1) to evaluate the variation in daily mortality rates in four samples of nests, (2) to determine the importance of variation in estimating hatch rates by the methods listed above, (3) to discuss the appropriate methodologies for evaluating our data, and (4) to recommend methods to researchers studying species with similar characteristics.
Read full abstract