Limited nitrogen supply can prevent the completion of alcoholic fermentation. Supplementation through peptides as an alternative, natural source of nitrogen for yeast offers an interesting solution for this issue. In this work, the S. cerevisiae peptide transporters of the Opt and Fot families were studied. We demonstrated that Fot and Opt2 have a broader peptide length preference than previously reported, enabling yeasts to acquire sufficient nitrogen from peptides without requiring additional ammonia or amino acids to complete fermentation. On the contrary, Opt1 was unable to consume any peptide in the given conditions, whereas it has been described elsewhere as the main peptide transporter for peptides longer than three amino acid residues in experiments in laboratory conditions. This controversy signifies the need in applied sciences for approaching experimental conditions to those prevalent in the industry for its more accurate characterization. Altogether, this work provides further evidence of the importance of peptides as a nitrogen source for yeast and their consequent positive impact on fermentation kinetics.