Pencil Beam Research Articles

Setting the Stage: Feasibility and Baseline Characteristics in the PARTIQoL Trial Comparing Proton Therapy Versus Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy for Localized Prostate Cancer

Men with localized prostate cancer may receive either photon-based intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) or proton beam therapy (PBT). The PARTIQoL trial (NCT01617161) demonstrates the feasibility of performing a large, multicenter phase 3 randomized trial comparing IMRT with PBT for localized prostate cancer. Here, we report baseline features of patients enrolled on this trial and present strategies to improve feasibility of other similar trials. Patients with low- or intermediate-risk prostate cancer were randomly assigned to either PBT or IMRT with stratification by institution, age, use of rectal spacer, and fractionation schedule (conventional fractionation: 79.2 Gy in 44 fractions vs moderate hypofractionation: 70.0 Gy in 28 fractions). The primary endpoint is a change from baseline bowel health using the Expanded Prostate Index Composite score 24 months after radiation therapy. Secondary objectives include treatment-related differences in urinary and erectile functions, adverse events, and efficacy endpoints. Between July 2012 and November 2021, 450 patients were successfully accrued. Patients were randomly assigned to either PBT (N = 226) or to IMRT (N = 224); 13 were ineligible or withdrew before treatment. The median age of 437 analyzed patients was 68 years (range, 46-89 years). A total of 41% of patients had low-risk and 59% had intermediate-risk disease. In total, 49% of patients were treated with conventional fractionation and 51% with moderately hypofractionation. 48% of patients used a rectal spacer. For patients receiving PBT, pencil beam scanning was used in 48%. PBT and IMRT arms were balanced for baseline variables. Despite significant challenges, the PARTIQoL trial demonstrated that, with targeted recruitment approaches, multicenter collaboration, payer engagement, and protocol updates to incorporate contemporary techniques, it is feasible to perform a large phase 3 randomized clinical trial to assess whether PBT improves outcomes. We will separately report primary results and continue to monitor participants for longer follow-up and secondary endpoints.

Whole Abdominal Pencil Beam Scanned Proton FLASH Increases Acute Lethality

PurposeUltra-high dose-rate FLASH radiotherapy (RT) has emerged as a modality which promises to reduce normal tissue toxicity while maintaining tumor control. Previous studies of gastrointestinal toxicity using passively scattered FLASH proton therapy (PRT) have, however, yielded mixed results, suggesting that the requirements for gastrointestinal sparing by FLASH are an open question. Furthermore, the more clinically relevant pencil beam scanned (PBS) FLASH PRT has not yet been assessed in this context, despite differences in the spatiotemporal dose-rate distributions compared to passively scattered PRT. Here, we provide the first report on the effects of PBS FLASH PRT on acute gastrointestinal injury in mice after whole abdominal irradiation. Methods and MaterialsWhole abdominal irradiation was performed on C57BL/6J mice using the entrance channel of the Bragg curve of a 250 MeV PBS proton beam at field-averaged dose-rates of 0.6 Gy/s for conventional (CONV) and 80-100 Gy/s for FLASH PRT. A 2D strip ionization chamber array was used to measure the dose and dose rate for each mouse. Survival was assessed at 14 Gy. Intestines were harvested and processed as Swiss rolls for analysis using a novel artificial intelligence (AI)-based crypt assay to quantify crypt regeneration 4 days post-irradiation. ResultsSurvival was significantly reduced following 14 Gy FLASH PRT compared to CONV (P<0.001). Our AI-based crypt assays demonstrated no significant difference in intestinal crypts/cm or crypt depth between groups 4 days post-irradiation. Furthermore, we found no significant difference in EdU+ cells/crypt or Olfactomedin4+ intestinal stem cells with FLASH relative to CONV PRT. ConclusionsOverall, our data demonstrate significantly impaired survival following abdominal PBS FLASH PRT without apparent differences in intestinal histology 4 days post-irradiation.

Online Adaptive Proton Therapy Facilitated by Artificial Intelligence–Based Autosegmentation in Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy

PurposeOnline adaptive proton therapy (oAPT) is essential to address interfractional anatomical changes in patients receiving pencil beam scanning proton therapy (PBSPT). Artificial intelligence (AI)-based auto-segmentation can increase the efficiency and accuracy. Linear energy transfer (LET)-based biological effect evaluation can potentially mitigate possible adverse events caused by high LET. New spot arrangement based on the verification CT (vCT) can further improve the re-plan quality. We propose an oAPT workflow that incorporates all these functionalities and validate its clinical implementation feasibility with prostate patients. Methods and MaterialsAI-based auto-segmentation tool AccuContourTM (Manteia, Xiamen, China) was seamlessly integrated into oAPT. Initial spot arrangement tool on the vCT for re-optimization was implemented using raytracing. An LET-based biological effect evaluation tool was developed to assess the overlap region of high dose and high LET in selected OARs. Eleven prostate cancer patients were retrospectively selected to verify the efficacy and efficiency of the proposed oAPT workflow. The time cost of each component in the workflow was recorded for analysis. ResultsThe verification plan showed significant degradation of the CTV coverage and rectum and bladder sparing due to the interfractional anatomical changes. Re-optimization on the vCT resulted in great improvement of the plan quality. No overlap regions of high dose and high LET distributions were observed in bladder or rectum in re-plans. 3D Gamma analyses in PSQA confirmed the accuracy of the re-plan doses before delivery (Gamma passing rate = 99.57 ± 0.46%), and after delivery (98.59 ± 1.29%). The robustness of the re-plans passed all clinical requirements. The average time for the complete execution of the workflow was 9.12 ± 0.85 minutes, excluding manual intervention time. ConclusionThe AI-facilitated oAPT workflow was demonstrated to be both efficient and effective by generating a re-plan that significantly improved the plan quality in prostate cancer treated with PBSPT.

1030: The impact of motion on onboard MRI-guided pencil beam scanned proton therapy treatments

1030: The impact of motion on onboard MRI-guided pencil beam scanned proton therapy treatments

511: Enhanced IMPT dose fall-off by optimised integration of Bragg peaks and transmission pencil beams

511: Enhanced IMPT dose fall-off by optimised integration of Bragg peaks and transmission pencil beams

3068: How Precisely to Deliver Pencil Beam Scanned Proton FLASH? Robustness of Dose Rate to AAPM TG224

3068: How Precisely to Deliver Pencil Beam Scanned Proton FLASH? Robustness of Dose Rate to AAPM TG224

Proton pencil beam scanning radiotherapy in the postoperative treatment of p16 positive squamous cell tonsillar cancer – evaluation of toxicity and effectivity

PurposePatients with p16 positive tonsillar cancer (p16 + TC) have an excellent prognosis and long-life expectancy. Deintensification of therapy is a prevalent topic of discussion. Proton radiotherapy is one way to reduce radiation exposure and thus reduce acute and late toxicity. The aim is to evaluate treatment outcomes and toxicity of postoperative treatment with intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT).MethodsBetween September 2013 and November 2021, 47 patients with p16 + TC were treated postoperatively with IMPT. Median age was 54.9 (38.2–74.9) years, 31 were males and 16 were females. All patients had squamous cell carcinoma and underwent surgery as a primary treatment. Median dose of radiotherapy was 66 GyE in 33 fractions. Bilateral neck irradiation was used in 39 patients and unilateral in 8. Concomitant chemotherapy was applied in 24 patients.ResultsMedian follow-up time was 4.2 (0.15–9.64) years. Five-year overall survival, relapse free survival and local control were 95.7%, 97.8% and 100%. The most common acute toxicities were dermatitis and mucositis, with grade 2 + in 61.7% and 70.2% of patients. No acute percutaneous gastrostomy insertion was necessary and intravenous rehydration was used in 12.8% of patients. The most common late toxicity was grade 1 xerostomia in 70.2% of patients and grade 2 in 10.6% of patients. Subcutaneous fibrosis of grades 2 and 3 occurred in 17.0% and 2.1% of patients, respectively. One patient developed late severe dysphagia and became PEG-dependent.ConclusionIMPT for the postoperative treatment of p16 + TC is feasible with excellent efficiency and acceptable acute and late toxicity.

Reducing Radiation Dermatitis for PBS Proton Therapy Breast Cancer Patients Using SpotDelete

PurposeThe purpose of this work was to reduce the severity of radiation dermatitis for breast cancer patients receiving pencil beam scanning proton therapy. The hypothesis was that eliminating proton spots (SpotDelete) in the 0.5 cm skin rind would reduce the potentially higher relative biological effectiveness (RBE) known to occur at the Bragg Peak. Patients and MethodsOur center has been using an in-house developed Python script in RayStation since 2021 to remove spots from the skin rind of breast patients. In this work, we retrospectively reviewed the on-treatment visit data from a cohort of breast patients treated with hypofractionation (16 fractions) before this technique (MinDepth) and after (SpotDelete) to acquire the physician-reported radiation dermatitis scores. We evaluated the delivered treatment plans, calculating the linear energy transfer (LET) and applying 3 variable RBE models, Carabe-Fernandez, Wedenberg, and McNamara. An α/β of 10 was assumed for the skin. ResultsIn the MinDepth cohort (n = 28), grade 1, 2, and 3 dermatitis accounted for 57%, 36%, and 7% of the cases, respectively. For SpotDelete (n = 27), the incidence rate of grade 1 and 2 acute radiation dermatitis was 67% and 37%, respectively. There were 0 instances of grade 3 dermatitis observed in the SpotDelete cohort. The onset of radiation dermatitis in the SpotDelete cohort was delayed compared to MinDepth, occurring 1 week later in the course of treatment. There was no significant difference in LET or in any of the variable RBE models when analyzing the 0.5 cm skin rind between the cohorts. ConclusionDespite the lack of correlation in LET or RBE, SpotDelete has been shown to reduce the severity and onset of radiation dermatitis. Possibly, more research into the α/β for skin and RBE models based on skin cell lines could provide insight into the efficacy of the SpotDelete technique.

PTCOG international survey of practice patterns and trends in utilization of proton therapy for breast cancer

Purpose/objectivesThe indications, techniques, and extent to which proton beam therapy (PBT) is employed for breast cancer are unknown. We seek to determine PBT utilization for breast cancer. Materials/methodsThe Particle Therapy Co-Operative Group (PTCOG) Breast Subcommittee developed an IRB-approved 29-question survey and sent it to breast cancer radiation oncologists at all active PBT centers worldwide in June 2023. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize responses, and comparisons by continent were performed using Fisher’s exact tests. ResultsOf 79 surveys distributed, 28 recipients submitted responses (35 % response rate) representing fifteen U.S., 8 European, and 5 Asian centers (continent response rate 50 %, 38 %, and 18 %, respectively). Overall, 93 % reported treating breast cancer patients with PBT; 13 (50 %) have treated ≥100 breast cancer patients at their center since opening. Most (89 %) have pencil beam scanning technology. Nearly half (46 %) use moderate hypofractionation (15–20 fractions) for regional nodal irradiation and 42 % conventional fractionation (25–30 fractions). More European centers prefer hypofractionation (88 %) vs. Asian (50 %) and U.S. (21 %) centers (p = 0.003). Common patient selection methods were practitioner determination/patient preference (n = 16) and comparative plan evaluation (n = 15). U.S. centers reported the most experience with breast PBT, with 71 % having treated ≥100 breast cancer patients vs. 38 % in Europe and none in Asia (p = 0.001). Of respondent centers, 39 % enrolled ≥75 % of breast PBT patients on a research study. ConclusionUtilization, patient selection methods, and dose-fractionation approaches for breast cancer PBT vary worldwide. These survey data serve as a benchmark from which successor surveys can provide insight on practice pattern evolution.

Investigation of linear energy transfer (LET)-dependence behavior and dosimetric response of a flat-panel detector in pencil beam scanning proton therapy

PurposeThis study aims to elucidate the dependence of the flat-panel detector’s response on the linear energy transfer (LET) and evaluate the practical viability of employing flat-panel detectors in proton dosimetry applications through LET-dependent correction factors. MethodsThe study assessed the flat-panel detector’s response across varying depths using solid water and distinct 100, 150, and 200 MeV proton beams by comparing the flat-panel readings against reference doses measured with an ionization chamber. A Monte Carlo code was used to derive LET values, and an LET-dependent response correction factor was determined based on the ratio of the uncorrected flat-panel dose to the ionization chamber dose. The implications of this under-response correction were validated by applying it to a measurement involving a spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP), followed by a comparative analysis against doses calculated using the Monte Carlo code and MatriXX ONE measurement. ResultsThe association between LET and the flat-panel detector’s under-response displayed a positive correlation that intensified with increasing LET values. Notably, with a 10 keV/µm LET value, the detector’s under-response reached 50 %, while the measurement points in the SOBP demonstrated under-response greater than 20 %. However, post-correction, the adjusted flat-panel profile closely aligned with the Monte Carlo profile, yielding a 2-dimensional 3 %/3mm gamma passing rate of 100 % at various verification depths. ConclusionThis study successfully defined the link between LET and the responsiveness of flat-panel detectors for proton dosimetric measurements and established a foundational framework for integrating flat-panel detectors in clinical proton dosimetry applications.

Time structures of proton pencil beam scanning delivery on a microsecond scale measured with a pixelated semiconductor detector Timepix3.

The time structures of proton spot delivery in proton pencil beam scanning (PBS) radiation therapy are essential in many clinical applications. This study aims to characterize the time structures of proton PBS delivered by both synchrotron and synchrocyclotron accelerators using a non-invasive technique based on scattered particle tracking. A pixelated semiconductor detector, AdvaPIX-Timepix3, with a temporal resolution of 1.56ns, was employed to measure time of arrival of secondary particles generated by a proton beam. The detector was placed laterally to the high-flux area of the beam in order to allow for single particle detection and not interfere with the treatment. The detector recorded counts of radiation events, their deposited energy and the timestamp associated with the single events. Individual recorded events and their temporal characteristics were used to analyze beam time structures, including energy layer switch time, magnet switch time, spot switch time, and the scanning speeds in the x and y directions. All the measurements were repeated 30 times on three dates, reducing statistical uncertainty. The uncertainty of the measured energy layer switch times, magnet switch time, and the spot switch time were all within 1% of average values. The scanning speeds uncertainties were within 1.5% and are more precise than previously reported results. The measurements also revealed continuous sub-milliseconds proton spills at a low dose rate for the synchrotron accelerator and radiofrequency pulses at 7µs and 1ms repetition time for the synchrocyclotron accelerator. The AdvaPIX-Timepix3 detector can be used to directly measure and monitor time structures on microseconds scale of the PBS proton beam delivery. This method yielded results with high precision and is completely independent of the machine log files.

Proton Pencil Beam Scanning Facilitates the Safe Treatment of Extended Radiation Targets for Hodgkin Lymphoma: A Report from the Proton Collaborative Group Registry.

Because proton beam therapy (PBT) can lower the dose of radiation to the heart, lungs, and breast, it is an established radiation modality for patients with Hodgkin lymphoma (HL). Pencil beam scanning (PBS) PBT facilitates the treatment of more extensive targets. This may be especially of value for lymphoma patients who require RT to both mediastinal and axillary targets, defined here as extended target RT (ETRT), given the target distribution and need to minimize the lung, heart, and breast dose. Using the Proton Collaborative Group registry, we identified patients with HL treated with PBT to both their mediastinum and axilla, for which DICOM-RT was available. All patients were treated with PBS. To evaluate the dosimetric impact of PBS, we compared delivered PBS plans with VMAT butterfly photon plans optimized to have the same target volume coverage, when feasible. Between 2016 and 2021, twelve patients (median 26 years) received PBS ETRT (median 30.6 Gy (RBE)). Despite the large superior/inferior (SI, median 22.2 cm) and left/right (LR, median 22.8 cm) extent of the ETRT targets, all patients were treated with one isocenter except for two patients (both with SI and LR > 30 cm). Most commonly, anterior beams, with or without posterior beams, were used. Compared to photons, PBS had greater target coverage, better conformity, and lower dose heterogeneity while achieving lower doses to the lungs and heart, but not to the breast. No acute grade 3+ toxicities were reported, including pneumonitis. Proton ETRT in this small cohort was safely delivered with PBS and was associated with an improved sparing of the heart and lungs compared to VMAT.

Wideband LP to CP Converter Using a Reflectarray Based on Modulated Admittance Surfaces Capable of Wide‐Range Beam‐Scanning for Ku/K Band Applications

AbstractThis study provides the design and demonstration of a Ku/K band horn‐fed linear polarization (LP) to circular polarization (CP) converter using a reflectarray antenna based on the holographic technique and the generalized law of total reflection without any iterative algorithms. The proposed hologram performs wide‐range frequency beam scanning with minimum gain losses and cross‐polarization levels. It comprises 2,500 diagonal slotted octagonal subwavelength metasurfaces with a periodicity of 0.266λ0 = 4 mm at 20 GHz as the center frequency. Two equations are defined to compute Y11 of the proposed unit cell regarding its dimensions for TE(0,0) and TM(0,0) Floquet modes. They significantly simplify the coding procedure and reduce the computational time for synthesizing the hologram. The antenna is simulated using the CST software from 14 to 25 GHz. As a confirmation, a prototype is manufactured and measured at 16, 18, 20, 22, and 24 GHz to verify its performance. The simulated and measured results are well‐matched. The presented hologram achieves 40% 1.8‐dB axial ratio (AR) bandwidth (16–25 GHz), 40% 3.3‐dB gain bandwidth (16–24 GHz), and above 30% 2‐dB gain bandwidth (16–22 GHz). Moreover, the antenna can perform beam scanning from 42° to 24° by changing the frequency from 16 to 24 GHz with peak gain values greater than 20.33 dBi. The LHCP pencil beams are at least 24° off‐broadside, so the proposed hologram avoids the feed blockage. These achievements make the hologram one of the best candidates for satellite communications, radar applications, short‐range communication, and point‐to‐point communication.

Modelling of RBE differences in selected points within similar spread-out Bragg-peaks (SOBP) placed at superficial and deep water phantom locations in passively scattered beams but not in scanned pencil beams: A hypothesis

PurposeTo model relative biological effectiveness (RBE) differences found in two studies which used spread-out Bragg-peaks (SOBP) placed at (a) superficial depth and (b) at the maximum range depth. For pencil beam scanning (PBS), RBE at similar points within the SOBP did not change between the two extreme SOBP placement depths; in passively scattered beams (PSB), high RBE values (typically 1.2–1.3) were found within superficially- placed SOBP but reduced to lower values (1–1.07) at similar points within the extreme-depth positioned SOBP. The dose, LET (linear energy transfer) distributions along each SOBP were closely comparable regardless of placement depth, but significant changes in dose rate occurred with depth in the PSB beam. MethodsThe equations used allow α and β changes with falling dose rate (the converse to FLASH studies) in PSB, resulting in reduced α/β ratios, compatible with a reduction in micro-volumetric energy transfer (the product of Fluence and LET), with commensurate reductions in RBE. The experimental depth-distances, positions within SOBP, observed dose-rates and radiosensitivity ratios were used to estimate the changes in RBE. ResultsRBE values within a 5 % tolerance limit of the experimental results for PSB were found at the deepest SOBP placement. No RBE changes were predicted for PBS beams, as in the published results. ConclusionsEnhanced proton therapy toxicity might occur with PBS when compared with PSB for deeply positioned SOBP due to the maintenance of higher RBE. Scanned pencil beam users need to be vigilant about RBE and further research is indicated.

Two-dimensional oxygen-diffusion modelling for FLASH proton therapy with pencil beam scanning—Impact of diffusive tissue properties, dose, dose rate and scan patterns

Objective. Oxygen depletion is generally believed to play an important role in the FLASH effect—a differential reduction of the radiosensitivity of healthy tissues, relative to that of the tumour under ultra-high dose-rate (UHDR) irradiation conditions. In proton therapy (PT) with pencil-beam scanning (PBS), the deposition of dose, and, hence, the degree of (radiolytic) oxygen depletion varies both spatially and temporally. Therefore, the resulting oxygen concentration and the healthy-tissue sparing effect through radiation-induced hypoxia varies both spatially and temporally as well. Approach. We propose and numerically solve a physical oxygen diffusion model to study these effects and their dependence on tissue parameters and the scan pattern in pencil-beam delivery. Since current clinical FLASH PT (FLASH-PT) is based on 250 MeV shoot-through (transmission) beams, for which dose and dose rate (DR) hardly vary with depth compared to the variation transverse to the beam axis, we focus on the two-dimensional case. We numerically integrate the model to obtain the oxygen concentration in each voxel as a function of time and extract voxel-based and spatially and temporarily integrated metrics for oxygen (FLASH) enhanced dose. Furthermore, we evaluate the impact on oxygen enhancement of standard pencil-beam delivery patterns and patterns that were optimised on dose-rate. Our model can contribute to the identification of tissue properties and pencil-beam delivery parameters that are critical for FLASH-PT and it may be used for the optimisation of FLASH-PT treatment plans and their delivery. Main results. (i) the diffusive properties of oxygen are critical for the steady state concentration and therefore the FLASH effect, even more so in two dimensions when compared to one dimension. (ii) The FLASH effect through oxygen depletion depends primarily on dose and less on other parameters. (iii) At a fixed fraction dose there is a slight dependence on DR. (iv) Scan patterns optimised on DR slightly increase the oxygen induced FLASH effect. Significance. To our best knowledge, this is the first study assessing the impact of scan-pattern optimization (SPO) in FLASH-PT with PBS on a biological FLASH model. While the observed impact of SPO is relatively small, a larger effect is expected for larger target volumes. A better understanding of the FLASH effect and the role of oxygen (depletion) therein is essential for the further development of FLASH-PT with PBS, and SPO.

Proton dose deposition matrix prediction using multi-source feature driven deep learning approach

Proton dose deposition results are influenced by various factors, such as irradiation angle, beamlet energy and other parameters. The calculation of the proton dose deposition matrix (DDM) can be highly complex but is crucial in intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT). In this work, we present a novel deep learning (DL) approach using multi-source features for proton DDM prediction. The DL5 proton DDM prediction method involves five input features containing beamlet geometry, dosimetry and treatment machine information like patient CT data, beamlet energy, distance from voxel to beamlet axis, distance from voxel to body surface, and pencil beam (PB) dose. The dose calculated by Monte Carlo (MC) method was used as the ground truth dose label. A total of 40 000 features, corresponding to 8000 beamlets, were obtained from head patient datasets and used for the training data. Additionally, seventeen head patients not included in the training process were utilized as testing cases. The DL5 method demonstrates high proton beamlet dose prediction accuracy, with an average determination coefficient R 2 of 0.93 when compared to the MC dose. Accurate beamlet dose estimation can be achieved in as little as 1.5 milliseconds for an individual proton beamlet. For IMPT plan dose comparisons to the dose calculated by the MC method, the DL5 method exhibited gamma pass rates of γ(2 mm, 2%) and γ(3 mm, 3%) ranging from 98.15% to 99.89% and 98.80% to 99.98%, respectively, across all 17 testing cases. On average, the DL5 method increased the gamma pass rates to γ(2 mm, 2%) from 82.97% to 99.23% and to γ(3 mm, 3%) from 85.27% to 99.75% when compared with the PB method. The proposed DL5 model enables rapid and precise dose calculation in IMPT plan, which has the potential to significantly enhance the efficiency and quality of proton radiation therapy.

Design of a combined X–Y scanning magnet with high field uniformity for pencil beam scanning proton therapy

In proton therapy, scanning magnets play a crucial role in the treatment equipment. Specifically, in pencil beam scanning, these magnets are responsible for deflecting the proton beam, thereby enabling the illumination of the tumor’s precise location. To reduce the size of the scanning system, a combined X–Y scanning magnet is used instead of separate scanning magnets, which can reduce the overall size of the gantry. The design in this paper combines a window-shaped yoke and three sets of elephant-ear-shaped coils, and one of the coils generates a horizontal magnetic field while the other two coils generate a vertical magnetic field. By adjusting the distance between the coils and the shape of the coils at both ends, the magnetic integral field exhibits higher uniformity compared to other combined scanning magnets. The simulation results show that the integrated field achieves a uniformity of 0.84% in the horizontal direction and 0.60% in the vertical direction. Particle tracking simulation and steady-state thermal analysis were also conducted. After cutting a certain number of slits with the same size at the ends of the magnetic yoke, the magnet can meet the requirements of a suitable working temperature. This magnet design has the capability to effectively decrease the space utilized by the scanning system, consequently reducing the rotational radius of the frame and minimizing the equipment required.

Investigation of intra-fractionated range guided adaptive proton therapy (RGAPT): II. Range-shift compensated on-line treatment adaptation and verification

We previously proposed range-guided adaptive proton therapy (RGAPT) that uses mid-range treatment beams as probing beams and intra-fractionated range measurements for online adaptation. In this work, we demonstrated experimental verification and reported the dosimetric accuracy for RGAPT. A STEEV phantom was used for the experiments, and a 3 × 3 × 3 cm3 cube inside the phantom was assigned to be the treatment target. We simulated three online range shift scenarios: reference, overshoot, and undershoot, by placing upstream Lucite sheets, 4, 0, and 8 that corresponded to changes of 0, 6.8, and −6.8 mm, respectively, in water-equivalent path length. The reference treatment plan was to deliver single-field uniform target doses in pencil beam scanning mode and generated on the Eclipse treatment planning system. Different numbers of mid-range layers, including single, three, and five layers, were selected as probing beams to evaluate beam range (BR) measurement accuracy in positron emission tomography (PET). Online plans were modified to adapt to BR shifts and compensate for probing beam doses. In contrast, non-adaptive plans were also delivered and compared to adaptive plans by film measurements. The mid-range probing beams of three (5.55MU) and five layers (8.71MU) yielded accurate range shift measurements in 60 s of PET acquisition with uncertainty of 0.5 mm while the single-layer probing (1.65MU) was not sufficient for measurements. The adaptive plans achieved an average gamma (2%/2 mm) passing rate of 95%. In contrast, the non-adaptive plans only had an average passing rate of 69%. RGAPT planning and delivery are feasible and verified by the experiments. The probing beam delivery, range measurements, and adaptive planning and delivery added a small increase in treatment delivery workflow time but resulted in substantial dose improvement. The three-layer mid-range probing was most suitable considering the balance of high range measurement accuracy and the low number of probing beam layers.

Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy as Single Vocal Cord Irradiation for Early-Stage Glottic Cancer

PurposeSingle vocal cord irradiation (SVCI) is a promising technique to maintain excellent oncologic control and potentially improve upon toxicities for treatment of early-stage glottic squamous cell carcinomas. We sought to investigate whether pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy could improve upon the already favorable dose gradients demonstrated with volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) SVCI. Patients and MethodsA 64-year-old gentleman was treated in our department with 6X-flattening filter-free VMAT SVCI to 58.08 Gy in 16 fractions for a T1a well-differentiated squamous cell carcinoma of the left true vocal cord and tolerated it well with good local control. Comparative PBS plans were created in Raystation for the Varian ProBeam with clinical target volume (CTVs) generated to mimic the prescription target volume extent of the VMAT planning target volumes when accounting for PBS plan robustness (±3 mm translational shifts, 3.5% density perturbation). A 3-field single-field optimization plan was selected as dosimetrically preferable. Dosimetric variables were compared. ResultsSeveral organs at risk doses improved with PBS, including the maximum and mean dose to ipsilateral carotids, maximum and mean dose to contralateral carotid, maximum dose to the spinal cord, maximum and mean dose to inferior constrictor/cricopharyngeus, maximum and mean dose to the uninvolved vocal cord, and mean dose to the thyroid gland. There are tradeoffs in skin dose depending on location relative to the target—with the highest and lowest isodoses extending more into the skin with the VMAT plan but with the moderate isodose lines covering a wider area with the PBS plan, but we deemed it tolerable regardless. ConclusionSVCI is a promising strategy for maintaining the oncologic effectiveness of whole-larynx photon radiation while potentially improving upon the historic toxicity profile. The favorable dose distribution with PBS with respect to organs at risk dosimetry for PBS may allow for further improvements upon VMAT SVCI strategies. Clinical implementation of PBS SVCI may be considered.

Patient-specific quality assurance of dynamically-collimated proton therapy treatment plans.

The dynamic collimation system (DCS) provides energy layer-specific collimation for pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy using two pairs of orthogonal nickel trimmer blades. While excellent measurement-to-calculation agreement has been demonstrated for simple cube-shaped DCS-trimmed dose distributions, no comparison of measurement and dose calculation has been made for patient-specific treatment plans. To validate a patient-specific quality assurance (PSQA) process for DCS-trimmed PBS treatment plans and evaluate the agreement between measured and calculated dose distributions. Three intracranial patient cases were considered. Standard uncollimated PBS and DCS-collimated treatment plans were generated for each patient using the Astroid treatment planning system (TPS). Plans were recalculated in a water phantom and delivered at the Miami Cancer Institute (MCI) using an Ion Beam Applications (IBA) dedicated nozzle system and prototype DCS. Planar dose measurements were acquired at two depths within low-gradient regions of the target volume using an IBA MatriXX ion chamber array. Measured and calculated dose distributions were compared using 2D gamma analysis with 3%/3mm criteria and low dose threshold of 10% of the maximum dose. Median gamma pass rates across all plans and measurement depths were 99.0% (PBS) and 98.3% (DCS), with a minimum gamma pass rate of 88.5% (PBS) and 91.2% (DCS). The PSQA process has been validated and experimentally verified for DCS-collimated PBS. Dosimetric agreement between the measured and calculated doses was demonstrated to be similar for DCS-collimated PBS to that achievable with noncollimated PBS.