Pea Aphid Complex Research Articles

A Link Between Communities of Protective Endosymbionts and Parasitoids of the Pea Aphid Revealed in Unmanipulated Agricultural Systems

In the last decade, the influence of microbial symbionts on ecological and physiological traits of their hosts has been increasingly recognized. However, most of these effects have been revealed under laboratory conditions, which oversimplifies the complexity of the factors involved in the dynamics of symbiotic associations in nature. The pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum, forms a complex of plant-adapted biotypes, which strongly differ in the prevalence of their facultative endosymbionts. Some of the facultative endosymbionts of A. pisum have been shown to confer protection against natural enemies, among which Hamiltonella defensa is known to protect its host from parasitoid wasps. Here, we tested under natural conditions whether the endosymbiont communities of different A. pisum biotypes had a protective effect on their hosts and whether endosymbiotic associations and parasitoid communities associated with the pea aphid complex were linked. A space-time monitoring of symbiotic associations, parasitoid pressure and parasitoid communities was carried out in three A. pisum biotypes respectively specialized on Medicago sativa (alfalfa), Pisum sativum (pea), and Trifolium sp. (clover) throughout the whole cropping season. While symbiotic associations, and to a lesser extent, parasitoid communities were stable over time and structured mainly by the A. pisum biotypes, the parasitoid pressure strongly varied during the season and differed among the three biotypes. This suggests a limited influence of parasitoid pressure on the dynamics of facultative endosymbionts at a seasonal scale. However, we found a positive correlation between the α and β diversities of the endosymbiont and parasitoid communities, indicating interactions between these two guilds. Also, we revealed a negative correlation between the prevalence of H. defensa and Fukatsuia symbiotica in co-infection and the intensity of parasitoid pressure in the alfalfa biotype, confirming in field conditions the protective effect of this symbiotic combination.

Low Spontaneous Mutation Rate and Pleistocene Radiation of Pea Aphids

Accurate estimates of divergence times are essential to understand the evolutionary history of species. It allows linking evolutionary histories of the diverging lineages with past geological, climatic, and other changes in environment and shed light on the processes involved in speciation. The pea aphid radiation includes multiple host races adapted to different legume host plants. It is thought that diversification in this system occurred very recently, over the past 8,000-16,000 years. This young age estimate was used to link diversification in pea aphids to the onset of human agriculture, and led to the establishment of the pea aphid radiation as a model system in the study of speciation with gene flow. Here, we re-examine the age of the pea aphid radiation, by combining a mutation accumulation experiment with a genome-wide estimate of divergence between distantly related pea aphid host races. We estimate the spontaneous mutation rate for pea aphids as 2.7×10-10 per haploid genome per parthenogenic generation. Using this estimate of mutation rate and the genome-wide genetic differentiation observed between pea aphid host races, we show that the pea aphid radiation is much more ancient than assumed previously, predating Neolithic agriculture by several hundreds of thousands of years. Our results rule out human agriculture as the driver of diversification of the pea aphid radiation, and call for re-assessment of the role of allopatric isolation during Pleistocene climatic oscillations in divergence of the pea aphid complex.

Micromorphology of the model species pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum (Hemiptera, Aphididae) with special emphasis on the sensilla structure

The pea aphid complex [Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris 1776)] (Hemiptera, Aphididae), listed among the 14 aphid species of the greatest economic importance, is a globally distributed key pest of pulse crops. Since the pea aphid is a well-studied model organism, an enormous amount of literature has been published about this species. However, comprehensive morphological analyses using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), focused on all body parts of adult viviparous and sexual generations of A. pisum, are lacking. Thus, we present the first detailed morphological description of all body parts of adult wingless and winged viviparous females (parthenogenetic generation) as well as oviparous females, winged and wingless males (sexual generation), representing the most common A. pisum pea biotype. In particular, the sensilla of the body surface, antennae, mouthparts, legs and male genitalia are mapped by the high-resolution scanning electron microscope. The morphological diversity of sensilla is discussed in the context of their function and the biology of aphids.

Host plant effects on the outcomes of defensive symbioses in the pea aphid complex

There is increasing evidence that microbial symbionts play pivotal roles in protecting their hosts. Most studies on defensive symbioses have analyzed interaction effects of host-symbiont genotypes on fitness value of defense but very few have considered how local environment could influence symbiont-mediated phenotypes. Our study assessed the effects of environmental variation on the intensity and cost of protection against adverse organisms in lineages of the pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum differing by their composition in secondary symbionts. This aphid is frequently infected by Hamiltonella defensa, singly or in co-infection with Fukatsuia symbiotica, and both bacterial symbionts generally confer a resistance against parasitoids but also induce fitness costs to their hosts. The pea aphid forms a complex of plant-adapted biotypes, each specialized on one or a few legume species (i.e., native host). These biotypes can all feed on broad bean, considered as a “universal” host plant. Since plants constitute the primary environment of aphids in providing both habitat and resources, we tested if symbiont-mediated protection was influenced by whether plant-specialized aphids fed on their native or universal hosts. For this purpose, parasitism resistance as well as constitutive and induced fitness costs of 21 pea aphid lineages differing in biotype and symbiotic complement were measured on both native and universal host plants. We showed that host plant could exert some influence on the outcomes of symbiotic defenses: while the host plant species had very little effect on the protection level against parasitoids, we showed that both costs of symbiotic association and costs induced by parasitism challenge varied in a plant-dependent manner.

Multi-scale characterization of symbiont diversity in the pea aphid complex through metagenomic approaches

BackgroundMost metazoans are involved in durable relationships with microbes which can take several forms, from mutualism to parasitism. The advances of NGS technologies and bioinformatics tools have opened opportunities to shed light on the diversity of microbial communities and to give some insights into the functions they perform in a broad array of hosts. The pea aphid is a model system for the study of insect-bacteria symbiosis. It is organized in a complex of biotypes, each adapted to specific host plants. It harbors both an obligatory symbiont supplying key nutrients and several facultative symbionts bringing additional functions to the host, such as protection against biotic and abiotic stresses. However, little is known on how the symbiont genomic diversity is structured at different scales: across host biotypes, among individuals of the same biotype, or within individual aphids, which limits our understanding on how these multi-partner symbioses evolve and interact.ResultsWe present a framework well adapted to the study of genomic diversity and evolutionary dynamics of the pea aphid holobiont from metagenomic read sets, based on mapping to reference genomes and whole genome variant calling. Our results revealed that the pea aphid microbiota is dominated by a few heritable bacterial symbionts reported in earlier works, with no discovery of new microbial associates. However, we detected a large and heterogeneous genotypic diversity associated with the different symbionts of the pea aphid. Partitioning analysis showed that this fine resolution diversity is distributed across the three considered scales. Phylogenetic analyses highlighted frequent horizontal transfers of facultative symbionts between host lineages, indicative of flexible associations between the pea aphid and its microbiota. However, the evolutionary dynamics of symbiotic associations strongly varied depending on the symbiont, reflecting different histories and possible constraints. In addition, at the intra-host scale, we showed that different symbiont strains may coexist inside the same aphid host.ConclusionsWe present a methodological framework for the detailed analysis of NGS data from microbial communities of moderate complexity and gave major insights into the extent of diversity in pea aphid-symbiont associations and the range of evolutionary trajectories they could take.

Identifying genomic hotspots of differentiation and candidate genes involved in the adaptive divergence of pea aphid host races.

Identifying the genomic bases of adaptation to novel environments is a long-term objective in evolutionary biology. Because genetic differentiation is expected to increase between locally adapted populations at the genes targeted by selection, scanning the genome for elevated levels of differentiation is a first step towards deciphering the genomic architecture underlying adaptive divergence. The pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum is a model of choice to address this question, as it forms a large complex of plant-specialized races and cryptic species, resulting from recent adaptive radiation. Here, we characterized genomewide polymorphisms in three pea aphid races specialized on alfalfa, clover and pea crops, respectively, which we sequenced in pools (poolseq). Using a model-based approach that explicitly accounts for selection, we identified 392 genomic hotspots of differentiation spanning 47.3Mb and 2,484 genes (respectively, 9.12% of the genome size and 8.10% of its genes). Most of these highly differentiated regions were located on the autosomes, and overall differentiation was weaker on the X chromosome. Within these hotspots, high levels of absolute divergence between races suggest that these regions experienced less gene flow than the rest of the genome, most likely by contributing to reproductive isolation. Moreover, population-specific analyses showed evidence of selection in every host race, depending on the hotspot considered. These hotspots were significantly enriched for candidate gene categories that control host-plant selection and use. These genes encode 48 salivary proteins, 14 gustatory receptors, 10 odorant receptors, five P450 cytochromes and one chemosensory protein, which represent promising candidates for the genetic basis of host-plant specialization and ecological isolation in the pea aphid complex. Altogether, our findings open new research directions towards functional studies, for validating the role of these genes on adaptive phenotypes.

Diversity in symbiont consortia in the pea aphid complex is associated with large phenotypic variation in the insect host

Virtually all eukaryotes host microbial symbionts that influence their phenotype in many ways. In a host population, individuals may differ in their symbiotic complement in terms of symbiont species and strains. Hence, the combined expression of symbiont and host genotypes may generate a range of phenotypic diversity on which selection can operate and influence host population ecology and evolution. Here, we used the pea aphid to examine how the infection with various symbiotic complements contributes to phenotypic diversity of this insect species. The pea aphid hosts an obligate symbiont (Buchnera aphidicola) and several secondary symbionts among which is Hamiltonella defensa. This secondary symbiont confers a protection against parasitoids but can also reduce the host’s longevity and fecundity. These phenotypic effects of H. defensa infection have been described for a small fraction of the pea aphid complex which encompasses multiple plant-specialized biotypes. In this study, we examined phenotypic differences in four pea aphid biotypes where H. defensa occurs at high frequency and sometimes associated with other secondary symbionts. For each biotype, we measured the fecundity, lifespan and level of parasitoid protection in several aphid lineages differing in their symbiotic complement. Our results showed little variation in longevity and fecundity among lineages but strong differences in their protection level. These differences in protective levels largely resulted from the strain type of H. defensa and the symbiotic consortium in the host. This study highlights the important role of symbiotic complement in the emergence of phenotypic divergence among host populations of the same species.

Optimization of Agroinfiltration in Pisum sativum Provides a New Tool for Studying the Salivary Protein Functions in the Pea Aphid Complex

Aphids are piercing-sucking insect pests and feed on phloem sap. During feeding, aphids inject a battery of salivary proteins into host plant. Some of these proteins function like effectors of microbial pathogens and influence the outcome of plant–aphid interactions. The pea aphid (Acyrthosiphon pisum) is the model aphid and encompasses multiple biotypes each specialized to one or a few legume species, providing an opportunity to investigate the underlying mechanisms of the compatibility between plants and aphid biotypes. We aim to identify the aphid factors that determine the compatibility with host plants, hence involved in the host plant specialization process, and hypothesize that salivary proteins are one of those factors. Agrobacterium-mediated transient gene expression is a powerful tool to perform functional analyses of effector (salivary) proteins in plants. However, the tool was not established for the legume species that A. pisum feeds on. Thus, we decided to optimize the method for legume plants to facilitate the functional analyses of A. pisum salivary proteins. We screened a range of cultivars of pea (Pisum sativum) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa). None of the M. sativa cultivars was suitable for agroinfiltration under the tested conditions; however, we established a protocol for efficient transient gene expression in two cultivars of P. sativum, ZP1109 and ZP1130, using A. tumefaciens AGL-1 strain and the pEAQ-HT-DEST1 vector. We confirmed that the genes are expressed from 3 to 10 days post-infiltration and that aphid lines of the pea adapted biotype fed and reproduced on these two cultivars while lines of alfalfa and clover biotypes did not. Thus, the pea biotype recognizes these two cultivars as typical pea plants. By using a combination of ZP1109 and an A. pisum line, we defined an agroinfiltration procedure to examine the effect of in planta expression of selected salivary proteins on A. pisum fitness and demonstrated that transient expression of one candidate salivary gene increased the fecundity of the aphids. This result confirms that the agroinfiltration can be used to perform functional analyses of salivary proteins in P. sativum and consequently to study the molecular mechanisms underlying host specialization in the pea aphid complex.

Enemy-free space promotes maintenance of host races in an aphid species.

The enormous biodiversity of herbivorous insects may arise from ecological speciation via continuous host-plant switches. Whether such switches are successful depends on the trade-off between different selection pressures that act on herbivores. Decreased herbivore performance due to suboptimal nutrition might be compensated for by a reduced natural enemy pressure. As a consequence, an "enemy-free space" on a certain plant might facilitate host-plant switches and maintain biotypes. To test this hypothesis, we used the pea aphid (Acyrthosiphon pisum) complex, which consists of at least 11 genetically distinct host races that are native to specific legume host plants but can all develop on the universal host plant Vicia faba. Three A. pisum host races native to Trifolium pratense, Pisum sativum, and Medicago sativa were investigated in experiments on their respective host plants and on the universal host plant V. faba. We found that hoverflies preferred to oviposit on P. sativum and the universal host V. faba. Since feeding by hoverfly larvae suppressed aphid population growth on these host plants, the native hosts M. sativa and T. pratense provided enemy-free space for the respective A. pisum races. Mobile predators, such as ants and ladybird beetles, preferred Pisum race aphids on V. faba over P. sativum. Thus, all three of the native host plants studied supply enemy-free space for A. pisum compared to the universal host V. faba. Reducing encounters between aphid races on V. faba would reduce gene flow among them and could contribute to maintaining the host races.

Genetic characterisation of new host‐specialised biotypes and novel associations with bacterial symbionts in the pea aphid complex

Abstract The pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum Harris, constitutes a complex of sympatric populations that are specialised to distinct species of Fabaceae. So far, 12 such populations have been characterised genetically as genetic clusters associated with one or few legumes species. These clusters form a continuum of genetic divergence linking host‐associated races, which show moderate hybridization, to nascent species. They are also known to be associated with different species of endosymbiotic bacteria, which have environmentally dependent effects on aphid fitness. Here, we report on the genetic characterisation of new host‐associated populations in this species complex. We sampled pea aphids in eastern France on Genista tinctoria, G. sagittalis, Onobrychis viciifolia, and Hippocrepis comosa. Bayesian clustering methods based on genotypes obtained at 25 microsatellite loci showed that each sampled plant species hosted a specific pea aphid population. Comparison with previously characterised biotypes showed that the population associated with Hippocrepis comosa was no different from that on Securigera varia. Migrant aphids from other host plants and hybrids were found at various frequencies on the newly sampled plant species. They were particularly frequent on Onobrychis viciifolia, occasional between the two Genista‐associated populations, and rare on Hippocrepis comosa. PCR‐based screening of bacterial species revealed new associations between aphid biotypes and facultative endosymbionts, chiefly the combination of Serratia symbiotica and Hamiltonella defensa within most individuals collected on Genista. The newly identified biotypes, which add up to a total of 15 within the pea aphid complex, offer new material to study the mechanisms and genetic bases of host‐specialisation and ecological speciation in this model aphid.

Bacterial communities associated with host-adapted populations of pea aphids revealed by deep sequencing of 16S ribosomal DNA.

Associations between microbes and animals are ubiquitous and hosts may benefit from harbouring microbial communities through improved resource exploitation or resistance to environmental stress. The pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum, is the host of heritable bacterial symbionts, including the obligate endosymbiont Buchnera aphidicola and several facultative symbionts. While obligate symbionts supply aphids with key nutrients, facultative symbionts influence their hosts in many ways such as protection against natural enemies, heat tolerance, color change and reproduction alteration. The pea aphid also encompasses multiple plant-specialized biotypes, each adapted to one or a few legume species. Facultative symbiont communities differ strongly between biotypes, although bacterial involvement in plant specialization is uncertain. Here, we analyse the diversity of bacterial communities associated with nine biotypes of the pea aphid complex using amplicon pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA genes. Combined clustering and phylogenetic analyses of 16S sequences allowed identifying 21 bacterial OTUs (Operational Taxonomic Unit). More than 98% of the sequencing reads were assigned to known pea aphid symbionts. The presence of Wolbachia was confirmed in A. pisum while Erwinia and Pantoea, two gut associates, were detected in multiple samples. The diversity of bacterial communities harboured by pea aphid biotypes was very low, ranging from 3 to 11 OTUs across samples. Bacterial communities differed more between than within biotypes but this difference did not correlate with the genetic divergence between biotypes. Altogether, these results confirm that the aphid microbiota is dominated by a few heritable symbionts and that plant specialization is an important structuring factor of bacterial communities associated with the pea aphid complex. However, since we examined the microbiota of aphid samples kept a few generations in controlled conditions, it may be that bacterial diversity was underestimated due to the possible loss of environmental or transient taxa.

Genome scans reveal candidate regions involved in the adaptation to host plant in the pea aphid complex

A major goal in evolutionary biology is to uncover the genetic basis of adaptation. Divergent selection exerted on ecological traits may result in adaptive population differentiation and reproductive isolation and affect differentially the level of genetic divergence along the genome. Genome-wide scan of large sets of individuals from multiple populations is a powerful approach to identify loci or genomic regions under ecologically divergent selection. Here, we focused on the pea aphid, a species complex of divergent host races, to explore the organization of the genomic divergence associated with host plant adaptation and ecological speciation. We analysed 390 microsatellite markers located at variable distances from predicted genes in replicate samples of sympatric populations of the pea aphid collected on alfalfa, red clover and pea, which correspond to three common host-adapted races reported in this species complex. Using a method that accounts for the hierarchical structure of our data set, we found a set of 11 outlier loci that show higher genetic differentiation between host races than expected under the null hypothesis of neutral evolution. Two of the outliers are close to olfactory receptor genes and three other nearby genes encoding salivary proteins. The remaining outliers are located in regions with genes of unknown functions, or which functions are unlikely to be involved in interactions with the host plant. This study reveals genetic signatures of divergent selection across the genome and provides an inventory of candidate genes responsible for plant specialization in the pea aphid, thereby setting the stage for future functional studies.

The pea aphid complex as a model of ecological speciation

1. Host‐specialised races of plant‐feeding insects are particularly informative models in the study of ecological speciation, that is, the evolution of reproductive isolation through divergent natural selection. However, within the enormous diversity of phytophagous insects, the mechanisms of ecological divergence have been elucidated in few host race systems.2. Here we review the literature covering speciation through host‐plant specialisation in a well‐studied model, the pea aphid complex, Acyrthosiphon pisum, which encompasses numerous biotypes that parasitise different legume host species worldwide.3. Published results are consistent with ecologically promoted reproductive isolation. Divergent host‐induced selection is pronounced across biotypes, and reflects genetic trade‐offs preventing the optimal use of multiple host plants. While these genetic trade‐offs may partly explain the unfitness of hybrids between biotypes, hybridisation occurring on plants is also limited by genetically‐based host preference, and by selection against migrants that chose unfavourable hosts. The continuum of genetic divergence displayed by 11 races and species of the pea aphid complex suggests that host races constitute an intermediate step in the speciation process, and that host specialisation may indeed lead to complete speciation. Uncertainties remain on the contribution of non‐ecological reproductive barriers to biotype divergence and on the physiological and molecular bases of host specialisation.

Post-Pleistocene radiation of the pea aphid complex revealed by rapidly evolving endosymbionts

Adaptation to different resources has the potential to cause rapid species diversification, but few studies have been able to quantify the time scale of recent adaptive radiations. The pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum, a model of speciation for host-specialized parasites, consists of several biotypes (races or species) living on distinct legume hosts. To document this radiation, we used rapidly evolving sequences from Buchnera, the maternally transmitted bacterial endosymbiont of aphids. Analyses of Buchnera pseudogene sequences revealed that 11 host-associated biotypes sort mostly into distinct matrilines despite low sequence divergence. A calibration based on divergence times of 7 sequenced genomes of Buchnera allowed us to date the last maternal ancestor of these biotypes between 8,000 and 16,000 years, with a burst of diversification at an estimated 3,600-9,500 years. The recency of this diversification, which is supported by microsatellite data, implies that the pea aphid complex ranks among the most rapid adaptive radiations yet documented. This diversification coincides with post-Pleistocene warming and with the domestication and anthropogenic range expansion of several of the legume hosts of pea aphids. Thus, we hypothesize that the new availability or abundance of resources triggered a cascade of divergence events in this newly formed complex.

A continuum of genetic divergence from sympatric host races to species in the pea aphid complex.

Sympatric populations of insects adapted to different host plants, i.e., host races, are good models to investigate how natural selection can promote speciation in the face of ongoing gene flow. However, host races are documented in very few model systems and their gradual evolution into good species, as assumed under a Darwinian view of species formation, lacks strong empirical support. We aim at resolving this uncertainty by investigating host specialization and gene flow among populations of the pea aphid complex, Acyrthosiphon pisum. Genetic markers and tests of host plant specificity indicate the existence of at least 11 well-distinguished sympatric populations associated with different host plants in Western Europe. Population assignment tests show variable migration and hybridization rates among sympatric populations, delineating 8 host races and 3 possible species. Notably, hybridization correlates negatively with genetic differentiation, forming a continuum of population divergence toward virtually complete speciation. The pea aphid complex thus illustrates how ecological divergence can be sustained among many hybridizing populations and how insect host races blend into species by gradual reduction of gene flow.