Background The modern cardiac intensive care unit (CICU) cares for increasingly complex patients with multiorgan system dysfunction, often including respiratory failure. Preliminary data suggests that having an automatic critical care consultation for patients on mechanical ventilation may improve outcomes. Whether this dedicated consultation also improves outcomes in a closed CICU staffed by heart failure physicians is unknown. Methods We performed a single-center retrospective study of consecutive patients who were admitted to the CICU between 2010-2017 and required mechanical ventilation for more than 24 hours. In 2014, the CICU became closed and staffed primarily by a heart failure physician. At that time, a policy of automatic critical care consultation for all mechanically ventilated patients was also implemented. We collected data on demographics and hospital-course for patients admitted before and after these changes in order to compare mortality and ventilation/intubation outcomes. We controlled for baseline comorbidities using multiple linear and logistic regression analyses. Results There were 581 patients included in the study; 159 admitted before 2014 and 422 after 2014. The most common reason for intubation in both groups was hypoxic respiratory failure (57.3% vs 48.8%, p=0.20) followed by need for airway protection (26.4% vs. 37.5%, p=0.08). Those admitted after 2014 had a significant reduction in 30-day mortality (OR 0.49, p=0.007), 1-year mortality (OR 0.502, p=0.02) and a reduction in re-intubations (OR 0.395, p=0.0008). They were also much more likely to have received critical care consultation (76.2% vs 31.4% before 2014, P<0.00001). Overall, patients who received consultations were more likely to remain on mechanical ventilation longer in the CICU (1.8 more days, p=0.003) and to require more re-intubations (OR 4.06, p=0.0005). Even among patients admitted after 2014, critical care consultation in the CICU had no added effect on mortality or ventilator outcomes and was again associated with an excess of 1.6 days of mechanical ventilation (p = 0.03). Conclusion Cardiac patients requiring mechanical ventilation had significantly improved mortality and airway outcomes when cared for by a dedicated heart failure specialist. Automatic critical care consultation added no additional improvement in mortality and was associated with longer durations of mechanical ventilation and more re-intubations. Further prospective studies in ventilated patients in CICUs will be needed to continue to improve care for this population. The modern cardiac intensive care unit (CICU) cares for increasingly complex patients with multiorgan system dysfunction, often including respiratory failure. Preliminary data suggests that having an automatic critical care consultation for patients on mechanical ventilation may improve outcomes. Whether this dedicated consultation also improves outcomes in a closed CICU staffed by heart failure physicians is unknown. We performed a single-center retrospective study of consecutive patients who were admitted to the CICU between 2010-2017 and required mechanical ventilation for more than 24 hours. In 2014, the CICU became closed and staffed primarily by a heart failure physician. At that time, a policy of automatic critical care consultation for all mechanically ventilated patients was also implemented. We collected data on demographics and hospital-course for patients admitted before and after these changes in order to compare mortality and ventilation/intubation outcomes. We controlled for baseline comorbidities using multiple linear and logistic regression analyses. There were 581 patients included in the study; 159 admitted before 2014 and 422 after 2014. The most common reason for intubation in both groups was hypoxic respiratory failure (57.3% vs 48.8%, p=0.20) followed by need for airway protection (26.4% vs. 37.5%, p=0.08). Those admitted after 2014 had a significant reduction in 30-day mortality (OR 0.49, p=0.007), 1-year mortality (OR 0.502, p=0.02) and a reduction in re-intubations (OR 0.395, p=0.0008). They were also much more likely to have received critical care consultation (76.2% vs 31.4% before 2014, P<0.00001). Overall, patients who received consultations were more likely to remain on mechanical ventilation longer in the CICU (1.8 more days, p=0.003) and to require more re-intubations (OR 4.06, p=0.0005). Even among patients admitted after 2014, critical care consultation in the CICU had no added effect on mortality or ventilator outcomes and was again associated with an excess of 1.6 days of mechanical ventilation (p = 0.03). Cardiac patients requiring mechanical ventilation had significantly improved mortality and airway outcomes when cared for by a dedicated heart failure specialist. Automatic critical care consultation added no additional improvement in mortality and was associated with longer durations of mechanical ventilation and more re-intubations. Further prospective studies in ventilated patients in CICUs will be needed to continue to improve care for this population.