Adoptive T cell transfer, including chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy, has been successfully applied to the treatment of multiple types of cancer, but the variation in response rates among patients remains an important issue. Recent studies have demonstrated that CAR T cells vary in function and persistence, depending on the specific T cell subpopulation that is engineered and the phenotype of the final T cell product. Specifically, a starting population of central memory T cells (Tcm) has been shown to improve persistence and efficacy of CAR T cell therapy. Tcm consist of both CD4+ and CD8+ pools, but little is known about the contribution of each subset for CAR T cell function. Notably, although CD8+ T cells have long been considered the primary cytotoxic effector population, CD4+ T cells have also been shown to mediate anti-tumor response against some solid tumors which is CD8-independent. It is thus critical to identify the optimal composition of CD4+ and CD8+ CAR T cells for mediating the maximal anti-tumor effect. Here, using both in vitro and in vivo glioblastoma (GBM) models, we examined the anti-tumor activity of IL13Rα2-specific CAR T cells engineered from purified CD4+ or CD8+ Tcm pools. Surprisingly, we discovered a superior antitumor response from CD4+ IL13Rα2-CAR T cells as compared to CD8+ CAR T cells. After co-culture with primary patient-derived GBM cells in vitro, CD4+ CAR T cells displayed more potent tumor killing as compared to CD8+ CAR T cells, especially when effector cell numbers were more limited. Consistently, CD4+ CAR T cells maintained better effector function in vitro when re-challenged with tumor. These CD4+ CAR T cells produced higher levels of cytokine as compared to CD8+ T cells, a difference that was further maintained after tumor re-challenge. We also assessed whether the CD4 versus CD8 composition of the IL13Rα2-CAR T cell product would impact therapeutic efficacy in vivo using primary patient-derived GBM lines orthotopically implanted in NSG mice. When injected intracranial into GBM-bearing mice, the CD4+ CAR T cells resulted in durable antitumor efficacy, mediating tumor-free survival for over 200 days in 7of 7 experimental animals, which was unaffected by mixing with 10% of CD8+ CAR T cells. While CD8+ CAR T cells, as well as 50%-50% or 10%-90% CD4-CD8 mixed populations, also mediated significant antitumor activity, the majority of mice recurred and showed a less durable therapeutic response. These results demonstrate that CD4+ CAR T cells can have potent effector function and suggest that, for at least IL13Rα2-CARs, CD4+ T cells mediated superior anti-tumor immune responses as compared to CD8+ T cells. These studies provide important insight to further elucidate the optimal composition of the CAR T cell product for the treatment of cancer.
Read full abstract