• Hybrid bromegrass-legume mixtures produced 54% more biomass than Russian wildrye-legume mixtures at Lanigan site, while biomass did not differ between mixtures at Swift Current site. • Legume contribution to total biomass was greater at Swift Current than at Lanigan site, and alfalfa contributed more to biomass than sainfoing at Lanigan site. • Crude protein tended to be greater for RWR mixtures than HBG mixtures at Lanigan site. • Beef steer gain was similar for all binary mixtures at Swift Current site, however steer gain was greater at Lanigan site for sainfoin mixtures, suggesting inclusion of legume in pasture was beneficial. • Results demonstrate that all four binary mixtures appear to be suitable for late summer and fall grazing. ABSTRACT A 3-year study (2016, 2017, and 2018) was conducted to compare the effects of alfalfa (ALF; cv. Yellowhead) (Medicago falcata L.) or sainfoin (SF; cv. AAC Mountainview) (Onobrychis viciifolia Scop.) in mixtures with either Russian wildrye (RWR; cv. Tom) (Psathyrostachys junceus [Fisch.]) or hybrid bromegrass (HBG; cv. Success) (Bromus riparius Rehm × B . inermis Leyss) on herbage dry matter yield (DMY) and nutritive value, and beef yearlings performance at two sites: Swift Current (Brown soil zone) and Lanigan (Thin Black soil zone), Saskatchewan, Canada. In 2015, in each site, sixteen 0.7-ha (in Lanigan) or 0.8-ha (in Swift Current) paddocks were established with replicated ( n = 4) ALF-HBG, ALF-RWR, SF-HBG, or SF-RWR binary mixtures. Each year in August, yearling steers (16 ± 1 month and BW = 391 ± 1.7 kg and 350 ± 0.04 kg for Swift Current and Lanigan sites, respectively) were allocated to paddocks for an average 30-d grazing trial to utilize 40–60% of available herbage. The DMY (3629 ± 154 kg/ha) did not differ ( P > 0.05) among mixtures at Swift Current. The HBG included (ALF-HBG and SF-HBG) mixtures produced 54% more ( P < 0.01) DMY than RWR included (ALF-RWR and SF-RWR) mixtures (4542 vs. 2943 kg/ha, SEM = 303) at Lanigan. Legume contribution to DMY was greater at Swift Current than at Lanigan (33.1% ± 2.1% vs. 14.0 ± 1.7%), and ALF contributed more to DMY than SF at Lanigan (18.0 vs. 10.1%). Crude protein tended ( P = 0.10) to be greater for RWR mixtures than HBG mixtures (93.5 vs. 83.4 g/kg DM for RWR and HBG mixtures, respectively) at Lanigan. The yearling steers had similar ( P = 0.25) ADG (0.78 ± 0.03 kg/d) for the treatments at Swift Current. However, at Lanigan, the animal ADG differed ( P < 0.01) with 0.88 and 0.90 kg/d for ALF-RWR and SF-RWR and 0.53 and 0.63 kg/d for ALF-HBG and SF-HBG mixtures, respectively. The HBG mixtures (ALF-HBG and SF-HBG) produced approximately 10 more grazing days (GD) (AUD/ha) than the RWR (ALF-RWR and SF-RWR) mixtures at both, Swift Current (95 vs. 88 AUD/ha, SEM = 9) and Lanigan (112 vs. 101 AUD/ha, SEM = 7) sites. Sainfoin-grass mixtures produced 8 and 3 GD less (AUD/ha) than ALF-grass mixtures at Swift Current and Lanigan, respectively. Overall, these results demonstrate that all 4 binary mixtures appear to be suitable for late summer and fall grazing to provide sufficient nutritive value and beef cattle steer performance in both soil zones of Saskatchewan, Canada.