Parafermion Research Articles

Characterization of solvable spin models via graph invariants

Exactly solvable models are essential in physics. For many-body spin-1/2systems, an important class of such models consists of those that can be mapped to free fermions hopping on a graph. We provide a complete characterization of models which can be solved this way. Specifically, we reduce the problem of recognizing such spin models to the graph-theoretic problem of recognizing line graphs, which has been solved optimally. A corollary of our result is a complete set of constant-sized commutation structures that constitute the obstructions to a free-fermion solution. We find that symmetries are tightly constrained in these models. Pauli symmetries correspond to either: (i) cycles on the fermion hopping graph, (ii) the fermion parity operator, or (iii) logically encoded qubits. Clifford symmetries within one of these symmetry sectors, with three exceptions, must be symmetries of the free-fermion model itself. We demonstrate how several exact free-fermion solutions from the literature fit into our formalism and give an explicit example of a new model previously unknown to be solvable by free fermions.

Decoherence dynamics of Majorana qubits under braiding operations

We study the decoherence dynamics of Majorana qubit braiding operations in a topological superconducting chain (TSC) system, in which the braiding is performed by controlling the electron-chemical potentials of the TSCs and the couplings between them. By solving rigorously the Majorana qubit dynamics, we show how the Majorana qubit coherence is generated through bogoliubon correlations formed by exchanging Majorana zero modes (MZMs) between two TSCs in braiding operations. Using the exact master equation, we demonstrate how MZMs and also the bogoliubon correlations dissipate due to charge fluctuations of the controlling gates at both the zero and finite temperatures. As a result, Majorana qubit coherence and the fermion parity conservation cannot be immune from local perturbations during braiding operations.

Certified Quantum Measurement of Majorana Fermions.

We present a quantum self-testing protocol to certify measurements of fermion parity involving Majorana fermion modes. We show that observing a set of ideal measurement statistics implies anti-commutativity of the implemented Majorana fermion parity operators, a necessary prerequisite for Majorana detection. Our protocol is robust to experimental errors. We obtain lower bounds on the fidelities of the state and measurement operators that are linear in the errors. We propose to analyze experimental outcomes in terms of a contextuality witness W, which satisfies 〈W〉 ≤ 3 for any classical probabilistic model of the data. A violation of the inequality witnesses quantum contextuality, and the closeness to the maximum ideal value 〈W〉 = 5 indicates the degree of confidence in the detection of Majorana fermions.

Symmetry resolved entanglement: exact results in 1D and beyond

In a quantum many-body system that possesses an additive conserved quantity, the entanglement entropy of a subsystem can be resolved into a sum of contributions from different sectors of the subsystem’s reduced density matrix, each sector corresponding to a possible value of the conserved quantity. Recent studies have discussed the basic properties of these symmetry-resolved contributions, and calculated them using conformal field theory and numerical methods. In this work we employ the generalized Fisher–Hartwig conjecture to obtain exact results for the characteristic function of the symmetry-resolved entanglement (‘flux-resolved entanglement’) for certain 1D spin chains, or, equivalently, the 1D fermionic tight binding and the Kitaev chain models. These results are true up to corrections of order where L is the subsystem size. We confirm that this calculation is in good agreement with numerical results. For the gapless tight binding chain we report an intriguing periodic structure of the characteristic functions, which nicely extends the structure predicted by conformal field theory. For the Kitaev chain in the topological phase we demonstrate the degeneracy between the even and odd fermion parity sectors of the entanglement spectrum due to virtual Majoranas at the entanglement cut. We also employ the Widom conjecture to obtain the leading behavior of the symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy in higher dimensions for an ungapped free Fermi gas in its ground state.

Higher anomalies, higher symmetries, and cobordisms II: Lorentz symmetry extension and enriched bosonic / fermionic quantum gauge theory

We systematically study Lorentz symmetry extensions in quantum field theories (QFTs) and their 't Hooft anomalies via cobordism. The total symmetry $G'$ can be expressed in terms of the extension of Lorentz symmetry $G_L$ by an internal global symmetry $G$ as $1 \to G \to G' \to G_L \to 1$. By enumerating all possible $G_L$ and symmetry extensions, other than the familiar SO/Spin/O/Pin$^{\pm}$ groups, we introduce a new EPin group (in contrast to DPin), and provide natural physical interpretations to exotic groups E($d$), EPin($d$), (SU(2)$\times$E(d))/$\mathbb{Z}_2$, (SU(2)$\times$EPin(d))/$\mathbb{Z}_2^{\pm}$, etc. By Adams spectral sequence, we systematically classify all possible $d$d Symmetry Protected Topological states (SPTs as invertible TQFTs) and $(d-1)$d 't Hooft anomalies of QFTs by co/bordism groups and invariants in $d\leq 5$. We further gauge the internal $G$, and study Lorentz symmetry-enriched Yang-Mills theory with discrete theta terms given by gauged SPTs. We not only enlist familiar bosonic Yang-Mills but also discover new fermionic Yang-Mills theories (when $G_L$ contains a graded fermion parity $\mathbb{Z}_2^F$), applicable to bosonic (e.g., Quantum Spin Liquids) or fermionic (e.g., electrons) condensed matter systems. For a pure gauge theory, there is a one form symmetry $I_{[1]}$ associated with the center of the gauge group $G$. We further study the anomalies of the emergent symmetry $I_{[1]}\times G_L$ by higher cobordism invariants as well as QFT analysis. We focus on the simply connected $G=$SU(2) and briefly comment on non-simply connected $G=$SO(3), U(1), other simple Lie groups, and Standard Model gauge groups (SU(3)$\times$SU(2)$\times$U(1))/$\mathbb{Z}_q$. We comment on SPTs protected by Lorentz symmetry, and the symmetry-extended trivialization for their boundary states.

Fermion parity switches of the ground state of Majorana billiards

Majorana billiards are finitely sized, arbitrarily shaped superconducting islands that host Majorana bound states. We study the fermion-parity switches of the ground state of Majorana billiards. In particular, we study the density and statistics of these fermion-parity switches as a function of applied magnetic field and chemical potential. We derive formulae that specify how the average density of fermion-parity switches depends on the geometrical shape the billiard. Moreover, we show how oscillations around this average value is determined by the classical periodic orbits of the billiard. Finally, we find that the statistics of the spacings of these fermion-parity switches are universal and are described by a random matrix ensemble, the choice of which depends on the antiunitary symmetries of the system in its normal state. We thus demonstrate that "one can hear (information about) the shape of a Majorana billiard" by investigating its "fermion-parity switch spectrum".

Anomalous Symmetry Protected Topological States in Interacting Fermion Systems.

The classification and construction of symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases have been intensively studied in interacting systems recently. To our surprise, in interacting fermion systems, there exists a new class of the so-called anomalous SPT (ASPT) states which are only well defined on the boundary of a trivial fermionic bulk system. We first demonstrate the essential idea by considering an anomalous topological superconductor with time-reversal symmetry T^{2}=1 in 2D. The physical reason for this is that the fermion parity might be changed locally by certain symmetry action, but it is conserved if we introduce a bulk. Then we discuss the layer structure and systematical construction of ASPT states in interacting fermion systems in 2D with a total symmetry G_{f}=G_{b}×Z_{2}^{f}. Finally, potential experimental realizations of ASPT states are also addressed.

Magnetoelectrically tunable Andreev bound state spectra and spin polarization in p -wave Josephson junctions

We demonstrate how the boundary-driven reconstruction of the superconducting order parameter can be employed to manipulate the zero-energy Majorana bound states (MBSs) occurring in a topological Josephson junction. We focus on an interface of two p-wave superconductors, which are described by a spin-vector order parameter $\bf{d}$. Apart from the sensitivity of $\bf{d}$ to external Zeeman/exchange fields, here, we show that the orientation of $\bf{d}$ throughout the junction can be controlled by electrically gating the weak link. The remarkable local character of this knob is a manifestation of the edge reconstruction of the order parameter, which takes place whenever different $\bf{d}$-vector configurations in each superconductor compete and are close in energy. As a consequence, the spin-dependent superconducting-phase difference across the junction is switchable from $0$ to $\pi$. Moreover, in the regime where multiple edge MBSs occur for each superconductor, the Andreev-bound-state (ABS) spectra can be twisted by the application of either a charge- or spin-phase difference across the interface, and give rise to a rich diversity of nonstandard ABS dispersions. Interestingly, some of these dispersions show band crossings protected by fermion parity, despite their $2\pi$-periodic character. These crossings additionally unlock the possibility of nontrivial topology in synthetic spaces, when considering networks of such 1D junctions. Lastly, the interface MBSs induce a distinct elecronic spin polarization near the junction, which possesses a characteristic spatial pattern that allows the detection of MBSs using spin-polarized scanning tunneling microscopy. These findings unveil novel paths to mechanisms for ABS engineering and single-out signatures relevant for the experimental detection and manipulation of MBSs.

Synthetic Weyl Points and Chiral Anomaly in Majorana Devices with Nonstandard Andreev-Bound-State Spectra.

We demonstrate how to design various nonstandard types of Andreev-bound-state (ABS) dispersions, via a composite construction relying on Majorana bound states (MBSs). Here, the MBSs appear at the interface of a Josephson junction consisting of two topological superconductors (TSCs). Each TSC harbors multiple MBSs per edge by virtue of a chiral or unitary symmetry. We find that, while the ABS dispersions are 2π periodic, they still contain multiple crossings which are protected by the conservation of fermion parity. A single junction with four interface MBSs and all MBS couplings fully controllable, or networks of such coupled junctions with partial coupling tunability, open the door for topological band structures with Weyl points or nodes in synthetic dimensions, which in turn allow for fermion-parity (FP) pumping with a cycle set by the ABS-dispersion details. In fact, in the case of nodes, the FP pumping is a manifestation of chiral anomaly in 2D synthetic spacetime. The possible experimental demonstration of ABS engineering in these devices further promises to unveil new paths for the detection of MBSs and higher-dimensional chiral anomaly.

Ground-State Fermion Parity and Caloric Properties of a Superconducting Nanowire

The ground-state structure and fermion parity have been determined for a semiconductor nano-wire with a strong Rashba spin–orbit interaction and proximity-induced superconductivity placed in an external magnetic field under periodic boundary conditions. Allowance for the open boundaries is shown to cause the topologically nontrivial parameter region to be partitioned into a set of subregions with a different ground-state fermionic parity. This peculiarity is related to the emergence of edge modes with nonmonotonically changing excitation energies in the system as its parameters change. At the quantum transition point, at which the ground-state fermionic parity changes, the edge-mode energy is zero. The magneto- and electrocaloric effects are shown to be effective characteristics that allow the series of quantum transitions in an open nanowire to be identified experimentally. These effects at low temperatures exhibit an anomalous behavior in the parameter region for which topologically stable Majorana modes are realized in long nanowires.

Higher-order topological superconductors as generators of quantum codes

We show that interactions can drive a class of higher order topological superconductors (HOTSC) into symmetry enriched topologically ordered phases exemplified by topological quantum error correcting codes. In two dimensions, interacting HOTSC realize various topologically ordered surface and color codes. In three dimensions, interactions can drive HOTSC protected by subsystem symmetries into recently discovered fracton phases. We explicitly relate fermion parity operators underlying the gapless excitations of the HOTSC to the Wilson algebra of symmetry enriched quantum codes. Arrays of crossed Majorana wires provide an experimental platform for realizing fracton matter and for probing the quantum phase transition between HOTSC and topologically ordered phase.

Chiral current-phase relation of topological Josephson junctions: A signature of the 4π -periodic Josephson effect

The $4\ensuremath{\pi}$-periodic Josephson effect is an indicator of Majorana zero modes and a ground-state degeneracy which are central to topological quantum computation. However, the observability of a $4\ensuremath{\pi}$-periodic Josephson current-phase relation (CPR) is hindered by the necessity to fix the fermionic parity. As an alternative to a $4\ensuremath{\pi}$-periodic CPR, this paper proposes a chiral CPR for the $4\ensuremath{\pi}$-periodic Josephson effect. This is a CPR of the form $J(\ensuremath{\phi})\ensuremath{\propto}C\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}|sin(\ensuremath{\phi}/2)|$, describing a unidirectional supercurrent with the chirality $C=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$. Its nonanalytic dependence on the Josephson phase difference $\ensuremath{\phi}$ translates into the $4\ensuremath{\pi}$-periodic CPR $J(\ensuremath{\phi})\ensuremath{\propto}sin(\ensuremath{\phi}/2)$. The proposal requires a spin-polarized topological Josephson junction which is modeled here as a short link between spin-split superconducting channels at the edge of a two-dimensional topological insulator. In this case, $C$ coincides with the Chern number of the occupied spin band of the topological insulator. This paper details three scenarios of achieving a chiral CPR: By only Zeeman-like splitting, by Zeeman splitting combined with bias currents, and by an external out-of-plane magnetic field.

Pfaffian Formula for Fermion Parity Fluctuations in a Superconductor and Application to Majorana Fusion Detection

AbstractKitaev's Pfaffian formula equates the ground‐state fermion parity of a closed system to the sign of the Pfaffian of the Hamiltonian in the Majorana basis. Using Klich's theory of counting statistics for paired fermions, the Pfaffian formula is generalized to account for quantum fluctuations in the fermion parity of an open subsystem. A statistical description in the framework of random‐matrix theory is used to answer the question when a vanishing fermion parity in a superconductor fusion experiment becomes a distinctive signature of an isolated Majorana zero‐mode.

Finite temperature effects on Majorana bound states in chiral $p$-wave superconductors

We study Majorana modes bound to vortex cores in a chiral \bm{p}𝐩-wave superconductor at temperatures non-negligible compared to the superconducting gap. Thermal occupation of Caroli de Gennes-Matricon (CdGM) states, below the full gap, causes the free energy difference between the two fermionic parity sectors to decay algebraically with increasing temperature. The power law acquires an additional factor of \bm{T^{-1}}𝐓−1 for each bound state thermally excited. The zero-temperature result is exponentially recovered well below the minigap (lowest-lying CdGM level). Our results suggest that temperatures larger than the minigap may not be disastrous for topological quantum computation. We discuss the prospect of precision measurements of pinning forces on vortices as a readout scheme for Majorana qubits.

Rapid Detection of Coherent Tunneling in an InAs Nanowire Quantum Dot through Dispersive Gate Sensing

Dispersive sensing is a powerful technique that enables scalable and high-fidelity readout of solid-state quantum bits. In particular, gate-based dispersive sensing has been proposed as the readout mechanism for future topological qubits, which can be measured by single electrons tunneling through zero-energy modes. The development of such a readout requires resolving the coherent charge tunneling amplitude from a quantum dot in a Majorana-zero-mode host system faithfully on short time scales. Here, we demonstrate rapid single-shot detection of a coherent single-electron tunneling amplitude between InAs nanowire quantum dots. We have realized a sensitive dispersive detection circuit by connecting a sub-GHz, lumped element microwave resonator to a high-lever arm gate on one of dots. The resulting large dot-resonator coupling leads to an observed dispersive shift that is of the order of the resonator linewidth at charge degeneracy. This shift enables us to differentiate between Coulomb blockade and resonance, corresponding to the scenarios expected for qubit state readout, with a signal to noise ratio exceeding 2 for an integration time of 1 microsecond. Our result paves the way for single shot measurements of fermion parity on microsecond timescales in topological qubits.

Stability of entanglement-spectrum crossing in quench dynamics of one-dimensional gapped free-fermion systems

In a recent work by Gong and Ueda (arXiv:1710.05289), the classification of (1+1)-dimensional quench dynamics for the ten Altland-Zirnbauer classes is achieved, and entanglement-spectrum crossings of the time-dependent states for the topological classes (AIII, DIII, CII, BDI, and D) are discovered as a consequence of the bulk-edge correspondence. We note that, their classification scheme relies on the limit that the energy spectrum of the post-quench Hamiltonian is flat, because any finite band dispersion leads to the break down of time-reversal and chiral symmetries for the parent Hamiltonian (which are used for the classification). We show that, because of the reduction of symmetry by finite energy dispersion, the gapless entanglement-spectrum crossing in the flat-band limit in classes AIII, DIII, and CII is unstable, and could be gapped without closing the bulk gap. The entanglement-spectrum crossing in classes BDI and D is still stable against energy dispersion. We show that the quench process for classes BDI and D can be understood as a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ fermion parity pump, and the entanglement-spectrum crossing for this case is protected by the conservation of fermion parity.

Proposal for Measuring the Parity Anomaly in a Topological Superconductor Ring.

A topological superconductor ring is uniquely characterized by a switch in the ground state fermion number parity upon insertion of one superconducting flux quantum-a direct consequence of the topological "parity anomaly." Despite the many other tantalizing signatures and applications of topological superconductors, this fundamental, defining property remains to be observed experimentally. Here we propose definitive detection of the fermion parity switch from the charging energy, temperature, and tunnel barrier dependence of the flux periodicity of two-terminal conductance of a floating superconductor ring. We extend the Ambegaokar-Eckern-Schön formalism for superconductors with a Coulomb charging energy to establish new explicit relationships between thermodynamic and transport properties of such a ring and the topological invariant of the superconductor. Crucially, we show that the topological contribution to the conductance oscillations can be isolated from Aharonov-Bohm oscillations of nontopological origin by their different dependence on the charging energy or barrier transparency.

Electrical detection of the Majorana fusion rule for chiral edge vortices in a topological superconductor

Majorana zero-modes bound to vortices in a topological superconductor have a non-Abelian exchange statistics expressed by a non-deterministic fusion rule: When two vortices merge they may or they may not produce an unpaired fermion with equal probability. Building on a recent proposal to inject edge vortices in a chiral mode by means of a Josephson junction, we show how the fusion rule manifests itself in an electrical measurement. A \bm {2\pi}2𝛑 phase shift at a pair of Josephson junctions creates a topological qubit in a state of even-even fermion parity, which is transformed by the chiral motion of the edge vortices into an equal-weight superposition of even-even and odd-odd fermion parity. Fusion of the edge vortices at a second pair of Josephson junctions results in a correlated charge transfer of zero or one electron per cycle, such that the current at each junction exhibits shot noise, but the difference of the currents is nearly noiseless.

Interacting invariants for Floquet phases of fermions in two dimensions

We construct a many-body quantized invariant that sharply distinguishes among two dimensional non-equilibrium driven phases of interacting fermions. This is an interacting generalization of a band-structure Floquet quasi-energy winding number, and describes chiral pumping of quantum information along the edge. In particular, our invariant sharply distinguishes between a trivial and anomalous Floquet Anderson insulator in the interacting, many-body localized setting. It also applies more generally to models where only fermion parity is conserved, where it differentiates between trivial models and ones that pump Kitaev Majorana chains to the boundary, such as ones recently introduced in the context of emergent fermions arising from eigenstate $\Z_2$ topological order. We evaluate our invariant for the edge of such a system with eigenstate $\Z_2$ topological order, and show that it is necessarily nonzero when the Floquet unitary exchanges electric and magnetic excitations, proving a connection between bulk anyonic symmetry and edge chirality.

Disentangling Interacting Symmetry-Protected Phases of Fermions in Two Dimensions

We construct fixed point lattice models for group supercohomology symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases of fermions in 2+1D. A key feature of our approach is to construct finite depth circuits of local unitaries that explicitly build the ground states from a tensor product state. We then recover the classification of fermionic SPT phases, including the group structure under stacking, from the algebraic composition rules of these circuits. Furthermore, we show that the circuits are symmetric, implying that the group supercohomology phases can be many body localized. Our strategy involves first building an auxiliary bosonic model, and then fermionizing it using the duality of Chen, Kapustin, and Radicevic. One benefit of this approach is that it clearly disentangles the role of the algebraic group supercohomology data, which is used to build the auxiliary bosonic model, from that of the spin structure, which is combinatorially encoded in the lattice and enters only in the fermionization step. In particular this allows us to study our models on 2d spatial manifolds of any topology and to define a lattice-level procedure for ungauging fermion parity.