Plants belonging to the genus Cotoneaster can be valuable sources of phytochemicals with potential therapeutic properties. The natural habitats of most of these species are situated in Asia, Africa and southern Europe. Introducing them into other climatic conditions could expose them to abiotic and biotic stresses, affecting their bioactive properties. The aim of this study was to assess and compare the performance of four non-native Cotoneaster species (C. roseus, C. hissaricus, C. hsingshangensis, C. nebrodensis) grown in eastern Poland in terms of leaf morphology, anatomy, and efficiency of the photosynthetic apparatus in relation to lipid peroxidation level, being an indicator of oxidative stress. Photosynthetic pigments concentration and chlorophyll a fluorescence parameters were used to evaluate the photosynthetic capacity. The morphological and anatomical analysis of leaves did not show any anomalies or stress symptoms. Cotoneaster roseus was characterized by the highest chlorophyll concentration, viability index (Rfd) and a moderate lipid peroxidation level. On the other hand, the lowest values of photochemical quenching (qP), maximum fluorescence (Fm), Rfd, and quantum yield of the photosystem II (QY) observed for C. nebrodensis might indicate an inferior efficiency of the photosynthetic apparatus in this species; however, it demonstrated the lowest lipid peroxidation level. Nevertheless, the content and proportion of the photosynthetic pigments as well as overall chlorophyll a fluorescence parameters and lipid peroxidation levels indicate a good physiological condition of all examined plants. The observed differences between the species may be rather species specific and genetically established and not indicate their sensitivity to non-native growth conditions. This is the first report about the physiological parameters of the four Cotoneaster species, proving they are well adapted to growth in the climatic conditions of central Europe providing thus a raw material with potential for pharmaceutical applications.