OX40 Signaling Research Articles

OX40 costimulation can abrogate Foxp3+ regulatory T cell‐mediated suppression of antitumor immunity

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) play an important role in maintaining immunological tolerance that is one of the main obstacles to overcome for improving antitumor immunity. Recently, the Treg has been shown to constitutively express OX40 (CD134), which is a member of the TNF-receptor family that is transiently expressed on effector T cells after TCR triggering, and through which the signal enhances effector T-cell proliferation and memory T-cell development. However, little is known about the role of OX40 costimulation to Tregs in tumor immunology. Here we show that OX40 signaling modulates the function of naturally occurring Tregs in vitro and in vivo. Foxp3 expression on Tregs was reduced by OX40 costimulation, but not by IL-2 stimulation. Tregs suppressed the proliferation of naïve CD4(+) CD25(-) T cells after TCR triggering, in contrast, OX40 costimulated Tregs that reduced Foxp3 expression reversed the suppressive function. In addition, Tregs inhibited the proliferation of TCR-stimulated (primed) CD4(+) T cells and naïve CD8(+) T cells after TCR-mediated activation, however, Tregs with OX40 costimulation lost their suppressive function. Interestingly, Tregs minimally suppressed the proliferation or the cytokine secretion of Ag-specific CD8(+) T cells after Ag-restimulation. Furthermore, Tregs suppressive function to the antitumor effect was reversed by OX40 costimulation in vivo. Our data indicate that, in addition to controlling effector T-cell function, OX40 costimulation directly controls Treg-mediated suppression in tumor immunity.

OX40 costimulatory signals potentiate the memory commitment of effector CD8+ T cells.

A T cell costimulatory molecule, OX40, contributes to T cell expansion, survival, and cytokine production. Although several roles for OX40 in CD8(+) T cell responses to tumors and viral infection have been shown, the precise function of these signals in the generation of memory CD8(+) T cells remains to be elucidated. To address this, we examined the generation and maintenance of memory CD8(+) T cells during infection with Listeria monocytogenes in the presence and absence of OX40 signaling. We used the expression of killer cell lectin-like receptor G1 (KLRG1), a recently reported marker, to distinguish between short-lived effector and memory precursor effector T cells (MPECs). Although OX40 was dispensable for the generation of effector T cells in general, the lack of OX40 signals significantly reduced the number and proportion of KLRG1(low) MPECs, and, subsequently, markedly impaired the generation of memory CD8(+) T cells. Moreover, memory T cells that were generated in the absence of OX40 signals in a host animal did not show self-renewal in a second host, suggesting that OX40 is important for the maintenance of memory T cells. Additional experiments making use of an inhibitory mAb against the OX40 ligand demonstrated that OX40 signals are essential during priming, not only for the survival of KLRG1(low) MPECs, but also for their self-renewing ability, both of which contribute to the homeostasis of memory CD8(+) T cells.

Umbilical cord blood regulatory T-cell expansion and functional effects of tumor necrosis factor receptor family members OX40 and 4-1BB expressed on artificial antigen-presenting cells

AbstractPreviously, we showed that human umbilical cord blood (UCB) regulatory T cells (Tregs) could be expanded approximately 100-fold using anti-CD3/28 monoclonal antibody (mAb)–coated beads to provide T-cell receptor and costimulatory signals. Because Treg numbers from a single UCB unit are limited, we explored the use of cell-based artificial antigen-presenting cells (aAPCs) preloaded with anti-CD3/28 mAbs to achieve higher levels of Treg expansion. Compared with beads, aAPCs had similar expansion properties while significantly increasing transforming growth factor β (TGF-β) secretion and the potency of Treg suppressor function. aAPCs modified to coexpress OX40L or 4-1BBL expanded UCB Tregs to a significantly greater extent than bead- or nonmodified aAPC cultures, reaching mean expansion levels exceeding 1250-fold. Despite the high expansion and in contrast to studies using other Treg sources, neither OX40 nor 4-1BB signaling of UCB Tregs reduced in vitro suppression. UCB Tregs expanded with 4-1BBL expressing aAPCs had decreased levels of proapoptotic bim. UCB Tregs expanded with nonmodified or modified aAPCs versus beads resulted in higher survival associated with increased Treg persistence in a xeno-geneic graft-versus-host disease lethality model. These data offer a novel approach for UCB Treg expansion using aAPCs, including those coexpressing OX40L or 4-1BBL.

OX40 Controls Islet Allograft Tolerance in CD154 Deficient Mice by Regulating FOXP3+ Tregs

The role of OX40 in the islet allograft tolerance, especially in the absence of CD154 costimulation, remains poorly defined. In the present study, we used CD154 deficient mice to critically examine the role of OX40 in the activation of T effector cells and Foxp3+ Tregs and the effect of blocking OX40 on the induction of islet allograft tolerance. We found that blocking OX40 costimulation in CD154 deficient mice induced donor specific tolerance but stimulating OX40 resulted in prompt islet allograft rejection. We also found that OX40 differentially regulates T effector cells and Foxp3+ Tregs, OX40 signaling mediates proliferation of CD154 deficient T effector cells but blocks the induction and suppressor functions of Foxp3+ Tregs. Our data suggest that the role of OX40 in the induction of islet allograft tolerance involves modifying not only the T effector cells but also the Foxp3+ Tregs in CD154 deficient mice.

Activation of NF-κB1 by OX40 Contributes to Antigen-Driven T Cell Expansion and Survival

The costimulatory molecule OX40 (CD134) is required in many instances for effective T cell-mediated immunity, controlling proliferation, and survival of T cells after encountering specific Ag. We previously found that the functional targets of OX40 are survivin and aurora B that regulate proliferation and Bcl-2 antiapoptotic family members that regulate survival. However, the intracellular pathways from OX40 that mediate these effects are unclear. In this study, we show that OX40 signaling can target the canonical NF-kappaB (NF-kappaB1) pathway in peripheral Ag-responding CD4 T cells. Phosphorylation of IkappaBalpha, nuclear translocation of NF-kappaB1/p50 and RelA, and NF-kappaB1 activity, are impaired in OX40-deficient T cells. Retroviral transduction of active IkappaB kinase that constitutively activates NF-kappaB1 rescues the poor expansion and survival of OX40-deficient T cells, directly correlating with increased expression and activity of survivin, aurora B, and Bcl-2 family members. Moreover, active IkappaB kinase expression alone is sufficient to restore the defective expansion and survival of OX40-deficient T cells in vivo when responding to Ag. Thus, OX40 signals regulate T cell number and viability through the NF-kappaB1 pathway that controls expression and activity of intracellular targets for proliferation and survival.

Blockade of OX40 Signals Enhance Survival of Xenoislet Grafts in Spontaneously Diabetic NOD Mice

Role of OX40 blockade was investigated in islet xenograft model in chemically diabetic C57B1/6 and spontaneously diabetic NOD mice. The effect of OX40/OX40L blockade on effector function of diabetogenic T cells was studied in an adoptive transfer model. 2000 IEQ of porcine islets were transplanted under the kidney capsule of diabetic C57B1/6 or NOD mice and were treated i.p. with control Ig, anti-OX40L, or CTLA4Ig. Graft survival was assessed using blood glucose (BG) measurement. Cells from diabetic NOD spleens and pancreatic lymphnodes were injected i.v. into NOD.scid mice. Recipients were treated i.p. with anti-OX40L, CTLA4Ig alone, or in combination; control mice received Ig. Diabetes incidence was assessed using BG measurement. Anti-OX40L treatment delayed xenoislet rejection significantly in chemically diabetic animals, although CTLA4Ig delayed rejection even further. Neither treatment completely prevented rejection. In spontaneously diabetic NOD mice, rejection of xenoislet graft was delayed by anti-OX40L treatment but not by CTLA4Ig. Anti-OX40L alone and in combination with CTLA4Ig significantly delayed diabetes transfer by activated diabetogenic T cells, compared with control and CTLA4Ig treatment. Preliminary mechanistic studies suggest that anti-OX40L treatment preserves Treg numbers, unlike CTLA4Ig that diminishes Tregs. Our studies show that OX40 blockade offers better xenoislet graft survival than CTLA4Ig in spontaneous autoimmune NOD model, suggesting that preactivated T cells use alternate costimulatory pathways, independent of CD28. Results from adoptive transfer studies further support the role of OX40 signaling in effector function of diabetogenic T cells. These data suggest that OX40/OX40L may offer novel therapeutic target for xenoislet graft protection in type 1 diabetic patients.

IL-12 Is Required for Anti-OX40-Mediated CD4 T Cell Survival

Engagement of OX40 greatly improves CD4 T cell function and survival. Previously, we showed that both OX40 engagement and CTLA-4 blockade led to enhanced CD4 T cell expansion, but only OX40 signaling increased survival. To identify pathways associated with OX40-mediated survival, the gene expression of Ag-activated CD4 T cells isolated from mice treated with anti-OX40 and -CTLA-4 was compared. This comparison revealed a potential role for IL-12 through increased expression of the IL-12R-signaling subunit (IL-12Rbeta2) on T cells activated 3 days previously with Ag and anti-OX40. The temporal expression of IL-12Rbeta2 on OX40-stimulated CD4 T cells was tightly regulated and peaked approximately 4-6 days after initial activation/expansion, but before the beginning of T cell contraction. IL-12 signaling, during this window of IL-12Rbeta2 expression, was required for enhanced T cell survival and survival was associated with STAT4-specific signaling. The findings from these observations were exploited in several different mouse tumor models where we found that the combination of anti-OX40 and IL-12 showed synergistic therapeutic efficacy. These results may lead to the elucidation of the molecular pathways involved with CD4 T cell survival that contribute to improved memory, and understanding of these pathways could lead to greater efficacy of immune stimulatory Abs in tumor-bearing individuals.

OX40 and TLR4 Signals Suppress Airway Tolerance by Altering the Balance Between Foxp3+ Treg and Th2 cells

The costimulatory molecule OX40 has been shown to play an important role in Th2-driven lung inflammation, and to modulate generation and activity of inducible regulatory T cells (Treg) which suppress pathogenic Th2 cells, implying that OX40 signaling might lead to airway disease by disrupting the balance between antigen-induced Treg and Th2 cells.

Novel roles of OX40 in the allograft response

In the past few years, much effort has been focused on the identification of new pathways, new mechanisms, and new therapeutic targets in transplant models. Understanding of T-cell costimulatory molecules remains one of the highly contested areas of research. In this review, we will focus specifically on OX40, and summarize the latest developments on the role of OX40 in transplant models. OX40 regulates multiple aspects of the T-cell response; it delivers a potent costimulatory signal to T effector cells and plays a key role in their survival and proliferation. OX40 also supports the transition of activated T effector cells to memory T cells. Importantly, OX40 signaling inhibits the suppressor functions of forkhead box P3 T regulatory cells and also blocks the induction of new forkhead box P3 T regulatory cells from activated T effector cells. These new findings may have major clinical implications in the induction of transplant tolerance. The current belief is that tolerance to organ transplants involves the apoptotic deletion of T effector cells and the expansion of graft-protective T regulatory cells. Given our recent understanding of OX40, we believe that targeting the OX40 costimulation is therapeutically important in the induction of transplant tolerance.

OX40 signaling directly triggers the antitumor effects of NKT cells

Pathways involving the costimulatory molecule OX40 and OX40 ligand (OX40L) enhance tumor rejection. It was presumed that this effect was mediated by changes in DCs and/or T cells. In this issue of the JCI, Zaini et al. report that, in mice, intratumoral injection of DCs genetically modified to express OX40L suppressed the growth of a preexisting melanoma by directly triggering an antitumor NKT cell response (see the related article beginning on page 3330). This work suggests that the intratumoral NKT cell population may be harnessed for cancer immunotherapy and that OX40 costimulation may be used as a unique trigger of the antitumor activity of these cells.

Cutting Edge: OX40 Inhibits TGF-β- and Antigen-Driven Conversion of Naive CD4 T Cells into CD25+Foxp3+ T cells

Naive CD4 T cells can develop into regulatory T cells by acquiring the transcription factor Foxp3. Combined signals from the TCR, CD28, IL-2R, and TGF-beta R promote Foxp3 expression in activated naive CD25(-) CD4 T cells. Here we show that OX40 (CD134) signaling inhibits TGF-beta-driven Foxp3 mRNA and suppresses the conversion of naive Ag-specific transgenic CD4 T cells into CD25(+)Foxp3(+) T cells. These data identify OX40 as a negative regulator of Foxp3 and suggest that OX40 can concomitantly promote effector T cell generation while antagonizing the differentiation of adaptive Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells.

Cooperation between CD4 and CD8 T cells for anti‐tumor activity is enhanced by OX40 signals

The relative contribution of OX40 (CD134) to priming of CD8 T cells in complex systems where CD4 and CD8 cells respond and cooperate together is not clear. We previously found that OX40 expressed on tumor-reactive CD8 T cells controls their initial persistence when adoptively transferred in vivo and is required for delayed tumor growth. We now show that exogenous stimulation of OX40 with agonist antibody augments its ability to suppress the growth of new as well as established tumors, correlating with marked expansion of adoptively transferred CD8 T cells. Concomitantly, anti-OX40 strongly enhanced the number of tumor antigen-reactive CD4 T cells. Moreover, the augmented accumulation of CD8 T cells was prevented in animals lacking MHC class II or depleted of CD4 cells and did not occur in OX40-deficient animals receiving wild-type CD8 cells, demonstrating that non-CD8 cells are the major target of OX40 signals. These results suggest that while OX40 signaling to a CD8 T cell can control its expansion, OX40 expressed on non-CD8 cells strongly influences CD8 priming and in vivo activity. OX40 therefore represents an important signal for allowing effective cooperation between CD4 and CD8 cells and for promoting cell interplay and tumor rejection where CD8 activity is limiting.

The Crystal Structure of the Costimulatory OX40-OX40L Complex

OX40 is a T cell costimulator activated by OX40L. Blockade of the OX40L-OX40 interaction has ameliorative effects in animal models of T cell pathologies. In order to better understand the interaction between OX40 and OX40L, we have determined the crystal structure of murine OX40L and of the human OX40-OX40L complex at 1.45 and 2.4 A, respectively. These structures show that OX40L is an unusually small member of the tumor necrosis factor superfamily (TNFSF). The arrangement of the OX40L protomers forming the functional trimer is atypical and differs from that of other members by a 15 degrees rotation of each protomer with respect to the trimer axis, resulting in an open assembly. Site-directed changes of the interfacial residues of OX40L suggest this interface lacks a single "hot spot" and that instead, binding energy is dispersed over at least two distinct areas. These structures demonstrate the structural plasticity of TNFSF members and their interactions with receptors.

Endothelial cell co-stimulation through OX40 augments and prolongs T cell cytokine synthesis by stabilization of cytokine mRNA

Human endothelial cells (ECs) constitutively express OX40L and co-stimulate memory CD4(+) T cell proliferation that is dependent upon OX40-OX40L interaction. In vivo, OX40 prolongs T cell survival; however, an unanswered question is whether it can also prolong synthesis of proliferation-sustaining cytokines such as IL-2. Here we show that EC co-stimulation results in the secretion of T cell IL-2, IL-3 and IFN-gamma and that in the absence of OX40 signals synthesis largely ceases by 12-18 h, but is prolonged up to 60 h in the presence of OX40 signaling. Blocking OX40-mediated cytokine expression at later times suppresses T cell proliferation and this can be overcome by addition of exogenous IL-2. We find that OX40 signaling has discrete effects on T cell activation as it does not affect expression of IL-10, CD25, CD69 or soluble IL-2R. Also, OX40 does not appear to alter IL-2 transcription, but rather acts to stabilize a subset of cytokine mRNAs, increasing their half-lives by 3-6-fold. We further show that OX40L induces activation of p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) and phosphotidyl-inositol-3-kinase (PI3K) in T cells, and using specific inhibitors, we find that increased mRNA half-life is dependent upon both these pathways but is independent of c-jun-N-terminal kinase (JNK). Thus, EC co-stimulation through OX40 leads to prolonged T cell cytokine synthesis and enhanced proliferation.

Costimulation of CD8 T cell responses by OX40.

The persistence of functional CD8 T cell responses is dependent on checkpoints established during priming. Although naive CD8 cells can proliferate with a short period of stimulation, CD4 help, inflammation, and/or high peptide affinity are necessary for the survival of CTL and for effective priming. Using OX40-deficient CD8 cells specific for a defined Ag, and agonist and antagonist OX40 reagents, we show that OX40/OX40 ligand interactions can determine the extent of expansion of CD8 T cells during responses to conventional protein Ag and can provide sufficient signals to confer CTL-mediated protection against tumor growth. OX40 signaling primarily functions to maintain CTL survival during the initial rounds of cell division after Ag encounter. Thus, OX40 is one of the costimulatory molecules that can contribute signals to regulate the accumulation of Ag-reactive CD8 cells during immune responses.

Distinct roles for the OX40-OX40 ligand interaction in regulatory and nonregulatory T cells.

The OX40 (CD134) molecule is induced primarily during T cell activation and, as we show in this study, is also expressed on CD25+CD4+ regulatory T (Treg) cells. A necessary role for OX40 in the development and homeostasis of Treg cells can be inferred from the reduced numbers of the cells present in the spleens of OX40-deficient mice, and their elevated numbers in the spleens of mice that overexpress the OX40 ligand (OX40L). The homeostatic proliferation of Treg cells following transfer into lymphopenic mice was also found to be potentiated by the OX40-OX40L interaction. Suppression of T cell responses by Treg cells was significantly impaired in the absence of OX40, indicating that, in addition to its homeostatic functions, OX40 contributes to efficient Treg-mediated suppression. However, despite this, we found that CD25-CD4+ T cells became insensitive to Treg-mediated suppression when they were exposed to OX40L-expressing cells, or when they were treated with an agonistic OX40-specific mAb. OX40 signaling could also abrogate the disease-preventing activity of Treg cells in an experimental model of inflammatory bowel disease. Thus, although the data reveal important roles for OX40 signaling in Treg cell development, homeostasis, and suppressive activity, they also show that OX40 signals can oppose Treg-mediated suppression when they are delivered directly to Ag-engaged naive T cells.

OX40-mediated memory T cell generation is TNF receptor-associated factor 2 dependent.

Tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated factor 2 (TRAF2), an adapter protein that associates with the cytoplasmic tail of OX40, may play a critical role in OX40-mediated signal transduction. To investigate the in vivo role of TRAF2 in OX40-mediated generation of Ag-specific memory T cells, we bred OVA-specific TCR transgenic mice to TRAF2 dominant-negative (TRAF2 DN) mice. Following Ag stimulation and OX40 engagement of TRAF2 DN T cells in vivo, the number of long-lived OVA-specific T cells and effector T cell function was dramatically reduced when compared with wild-type T cells. We also demonstrate that CTLA-4 is down-regulated following OX40 engagement in vivo and the OX40-specific TRAF2 DN defect was partially overcome by CTLA-4 blockade in vivo. The data provide evidence that TRAF2 is linked to OX40-mediated memory T cell expansion and survival, and point to the down-regulation of CTLA-4 as a possible control element to enhance early T cell expansion through OX40 signaling.

OX40 signaling renders adult T-cell leukemia cells resistant to Fas-induced apoptosis.

We reported previously that OX40, a member of the tumor necrosis factor receptor family, is expressed constitutively on fresh leukemia/lymphoma cells isolated from patients with adult T-cell leukemia (ATL). In this study, we tested whether OX40 signaling affects the Fas-mediated apoptosis of fresh ATL cells isolated from 7 patients (3 acute type, 3 chronic type, and 1 smoldering type). In all these patients, the coculture of ATL cells with MMCE/OX40 ligand gp34, a stable human gp34 transfectant of a mouse epithelial cell line, resulted in a decrease in the percentage of apoptotic cells after treatment with anti-Fas monoclonal antibody, compared to coculture with MMCE/mock controls. Similar findings were obtained in OX40(+)- human T-cell leukemia virus type I-transformed T-cell lines. To elucidate the molecular mechanism of this phenomenon, we used Kit225/OX40, a stable OX40 transfectant of an IL-2-dependent T-cell line, and its deletion mutant, Kit225/del-OX40, in which the intracytoplasmic domain of OX40 had been deleted. Coculture with MMCE/gp34 inhibited the apoptosis of Kit225/OX40, but Kit225/del-OX40 apoptosis was hardly affected. These results suggest that ATL cells may escape Fas-mediated destruction of the immune system through OX40 signaling.

Both Amino- and Carboxyl-Terminal Domains of TRAF3 Negatively Regulate NF-κB Activation Induced by OX40 Signaling

OX40 is a member of the tumor necrosis factor receptor (TNF-R) superfamily. We observed that overexpression of OX40 activated NF-κB, which was inhibited by dominant negative forms of TRAF2, NF-κB-inducing kinase (NIK), and IkappaB kinase (IKK) α. This indicates that OX40 signaling leads to NF-κB activation through the same cascade as TNF-R2. We then investigated the negative regulatory function of TRAF3 on OX40-induced NF-κB activation. TRAF3 blocked OX40-, TRAF2-induced NF-κB activation, but not NIK- and IKKα-induced NF-κB activation, indicating that TRAF3 blocks the pathway between TRAF2 and NIK. C-terminal deletion mutants as well as the N-terminal deletion mutant of TRAF3 inhibited NF-κB activation induced by OX40 or TRAF2. Since TRAF3 bound to OX40 through the C-terminal TRAF domain, the C-terminal domain is likely to work as a dominant negative mutant to compete the recruitment of TRAF2 to the receptor, which transmits the signal from OX40 to the downstream, NIK kinase. On the other hand, the N-terminal domain of TRAF3 seems to affect the downstream of TRAF2 binding. Thus, it is suggested that TRAF3 actively inhibits NF-κB activation induced by OX40.

Ox-40 Ligand: A Potent Costimulatory Molecule for Sustaining Primary CD4 T Cell Responses

Ox-40 and Ox-40 ligand (Ox-40L) are thought to be involved in T cell-APC interactions. However, their exact role in T cell responses is undefined. Using fibroblast transfectants expressing Ox-40L and/or B7-1, and CD4 cells from TCR transgenic mice, we investigated the effect of Ox-40 signaling on primary responses to the Ag pigeon cytochrome c. Ox-40 expression on naive CD4 cells peaked 2 to 3 days after activation, and was lost by 4 to 5 days. APCs with Ox-40L promoted partial activation of naive T cells with some IL-2 secretion, but were unable to enhance proliferation, unlike those with B7-1. APCs coexpressing Ox-40L with B7-1 induced large quantities of IL-2 and promoted proliferative responses that persisted for several days. Effector cells taken 5 days after naive T cell activation reexpressed Ox-40 within 4 h and responded strongly to APCs expressing Ox-40L, whereas B7-1 had little effect. Synergy was also seen between Ox-40L and B7-1, with primarily IL-2 being elevated, although IL-4 and IL-5 were also up-regulated. The most striking action was on effector T cell proliferation, which continued at high levels for up to 4 days, with little proliferation evident at this time in the absence of Ox-40 signals. These data suggest that Ox-40/Ox-40L interactions act after initial activation events to prolong clonal expansion and enhance effector cytokine secretion, and may be involved in promoting long-lived primary CD4 responses.