We demonstrate an unexpected anisotropy in perceived object non-rigidity, a little understood higher-level perceptual phenomenon, and explain this anisotropy by the population distribution of low-level neuronal properties in primary visual cortex. We measured the visual interpretation of two rigidly connected rotating circular rings. In videos where observers predominantly perceived rigidly connected horizontally rotating rings, they predominantly perceived a non-rigid configuration of independently wobbling rings if the video was rotated by 90°. Additionally, vertically rotating rings appeared narrower and longer compared to their physically identical horizontally rotating counterparts. We show that these perceived shape changes can be decoded from V1 outputs by incorporating documented anisotropies in orientation selectivity, i.e. greater numbers of cells and narrower tuning for the horizontal orientation than for the vertical. We then show that even when the shapes are matched, the increased non-rigidity persists in vertical rotations, suggesting a role for uneven distributions of direction-selective motion mechanisms. By incorporating cortical anisotropies into optic flow computations, we show that the kinematic gradients (Divergence, Curl, Deformation) for vertical rotations align more with gradients of derived velocity fields for physical non-rigidity, while those for horizontal rotations align closer to rigidity, indicating that cortical anisotropies contribute to the orientation dependence of the perception of non-rigidity. Our results reveal how high-level percepts can be directly shaped by low-level anisotropies. Cortical anisotropies have been claimed to promote efficient encoding of the statistical properties of natural images, but these surprising failures of shape constancy and object rigidity raise questions about their evolutionary significance.
Read full abstract