There are differences in practice between the US, Europe, and other countries in screening for colorectal neoplasia (1) and investigation of other common lower gastrointestinal tract problems. Colonoscopy is often considered the gold standard for detection of colorectal neoplasia, and deaths from colorectal cancer can undoubtedly be reduced through removal of adenomatous polyps (2, 3). Colonoscopy is a scarce resource in many countries, however, and it may be limited to those with comprehensive health insurance. Consequently, there is much interest in using fecal tests to decide who will truly benefit from colonoscopy, particularly because the symptoms reported for colorectal diseases overlap considerably, making clinical decision-making about whom to refer difficult. In this issue of the Journal, Kok and colleagues (4) report a study on the diagnostic accuracy of point-of-care tests (POCTs)6 for fecal calprotectin and occult blood in primary care and assessing what they term “organic bowel disease.” A qualitative immunochemical fecal occult blood test was used. We have recommended (5) that tests that use antibodies to detect fecal hemoglobin be termed “fecal immunochemical tests for hemoglobin” and that the abbreviation “FIT” be used, because guaiac-based fecal occult blood tests (gFOBTs) and FITs are very different tests. As the authors mention, FITs are rapidly superseding traditional gFOBTs because of their many advantages, including that only a single sample is generally collected, the available collection devices encourage adoption of the test, the test is more specific for lower gastrointestinal bleeding, and dietary restriction is definitely not required. Indeed, the many disadvantages of gFOBTs with respect to sample collection and handling, analysis, and interpretation of results (6) have led to the general consensus that their use is obsolete because of the much better performance characteristics of FITs. We strongly advocate that professionals in laboratory medicine (PLMs) encourage current users of …
Read full abstract