Arsenic (As) contamination in wells is common throughout the northeastern United States. It is well documented that lead-arsenate (PbHAsO4 ) pesticides were widely used on fruit tree orchards from the 1890s to 1950s. This study evaluates the potential for As contamination of groundwater from former orchards in Connecticut, where there were over 47,000 orchards in 1935. A proximity analysis involving 189 orchards and 114 domestic wells was conducted to assess the spatial relationship between historic orchards and As in wells. Field studies were then conducted to characterize As and lead (Pb) distributions in soils and wells near historic orchards. The proximity analysis found that the wells with no detected As were further away from historic orchards and had fewer historic orchards within their vicinity when compared with wells that contained As. The field investigations found that elevated levels of As and Pb were widespread in soils from orchards established by 1951, with some As concentrations exceeding 200ppm. In some soils, As and Pb were leachable at concentrations exceeding USEPA drinking water standards in synthetic precipitation laboratory tests. It was also found that the wells nearest to the impacted soils tended to contain the highest As concentrations, while the wells located in areas that were forested prior to 1970 contained no As. Overall, this study found that As and Pb from legacy pesticide residues are still abundant in former orchard soils and that a strong spatial relationship exists between As-contaminated wells and historic orchards. Greater consideration should be given to historic orchard soils as a potential contributing nonpoint source of As to the groundwater in Connecticut, where domestic well contamination rates are high.