In group decision making, decision makers can use pairwise comparisons to express their preferences. Reaching the consistency of decision makers and consensus of decision groups are two important processes for obtaining reliable decision-making results. Consistency and consensus optimization approach based on minimizing preference adjustment is one of the dominant approaches to obtaining ranking results by deriving priorities. In existing researches, maintaining consistency in preference adjustment during ordinal consensus optimization processes has been rarely noticed, and the choice of the consistency adjusted preferences from multiple optimal solutions has not been considered. To deal with these issues, this paper proposes a two-stage group ordinal consensus optimization ranking approach which considers multiple optimal consistency adjustment solutions to achieve individual preference consistency and group ordinal consensus. In the first stage, a minimum adjustment consistency optimization model is developed to obtain the minimum adjustment based on the concept of strong ordinal consistency. In the second stage, an ordinal consensus optimization ranking model is developed to obtain the optimal consistency and consensus adjustment solutions by minimizing the preference adjustments based on an improved consensus measure. Finally, a numerical example about lithium-ion battery recycling strategy selection is applied to illustrate the feasibility of the proposed approach. Moreover, the comparisons with other approaches are given to show the advantage and the sensitivity analysis is used to verify the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Read full abstract