The tracer diffusion coefficient (D12) is a critical transport property essential for research, design and optimization of industrial processes. However, experimental determination of D12 is often challenging, time-consuming, and frequently exhibits significant variability across different systems and conditions. In this study, a comprehensive assessment of D12 for benzene, phenol, chlorobenzene, anisole, and the three isomers of dichlorobenzene in supercritical carbon dioxide (▪) is presented. The available experimental data was meticulously compiled and analyzed, comparing different data points from various authors to assess consistency and accuracy. The experimental values were then compared with predictions from classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations carried out in this work, in which three distinct ▪ force fields (EPM2, TraPPE, and Zhu et al.) and the OPLS-AA force field for the solute molecules were tested in combination with NVT and NPT ensembles. Among the evaluated combinations of force field and ensemble, the Zhu et al./NPT pair demonstrated excellent agreement with experimental data, achieving an overall deviation of only 5.63 %.Additionally, the performance of alternative approaches for estimating D12, including phenomenological and semi-empirical models—Wilke-Chang, Lai-Tan, Tracer Liu-Silva-Macedo and He-Yu equations—and machine learning (ML) algorithms was evaluated, highlighting their comparative accuracy while accounting for their inherent limitations. Overall, the ML model proved highly effective, with a deviation of only 2.42 % when applied to compounds within the training dataset. However, for compounds outside this dataset, the reliability, flexibility and accuracy of MD simulations, as demonstrated in this study, strongly suggest their application for D12 estimation in ▪/benzene-derivative systems, with possible additional valuable insights from the analysis of MD trajectories.
Read full abstract