Our purpose was to determine if docusate monotherapy is effective in preventing opioid-induced constipation in patients receiving opioids following orthopedic surgery. Our single-center, retrospective, cohort study evaluated 212 orthopedic patients who received opioids between May 1, 2018, and December 31, 2018. All patients were aged 18 years and older, hospitalized for more than 48 hours, and received docusate for primary prevention of constipation post-operatively. The primary outcome was the proportion of patients taking opioid medications who experienced docusate failure, defined as patients who did not have a bowel movement within 5 days of starting docusate after surgery or those patients who required the use of additional laxative agents to produce a bowel movement. After excluding patients which did not meet the inclusion criteria, 79.9% (n = 159/199) experienced docusate treatment failure. Of these patients, 42.8% (68/159) failed to have a bowel movement or had a bowel movement greater than 5 days post-surgery. The remaining 57.2% (91/159) of patients required an additional laxative to produce a bowel movement. Docusate monotherapy was not effective in preventing constipation in patients receiving opioids following elective orthopedic surgery. Based on these findings, we propose utilization of stimulant bowel products with proven efficacy as primary therapy after surgery to prevent constipation. Future multi-centered, randomized controlled trials are necessary to evaluate the differences in efficacy and safety between common bowel regimens in treating opioid-induced constipation in patients who undergo elective orthopedic surgery.