Keith Humphreys' inclusion of ‘ultra-rapid opiate detoxification’[1], among discredited ‘miracle cures’ for addiction, needs several important qualifications. The basic theory (using opiate antagonists to make withdrawal shorter, more successful and less unpleasant) was validated in several randomized controlled trials (RCTs) by respected academics in the 1970s and 1980s, all using oral sedation as well as specific antiwithdrawal drugs such as clonidine, to reduce discomfort. Using general anaesthesia (GA) or intravenous sedation (IVS) was a logical development, especially for patients who were difficult to sedate orally. Loimer and his entirely academic colleagues in Vienna were the first to use anaesthesia and regarded the procedure as merely making planned opiate withdrawal easier and more certain. Antagonist-precipitated withdrawal is now combined invariably with initiating oral or implanted naltrexone (NTX). RCTs show that supervised NTX is an effective adjunct to abstinence-based programmes [2] (as supervised disulfiram is in alcoholism), and that NTX implants/depot-injections are more effective than oral NTX or placebo implants. A ‘rapid’ opiate detoxification (ROD) is simply one in which a full dose of NTX (or an implant) is given within 24 hours of starting [3] and can be performed under oral sedation, IVS or GA. ‘Ultra-rapid opiate detox’ (UROD) is no quicker than other rapid methods but was trademarked by the CITA company, who promoted UROD irresponsibly as a miracle cure [4]. They also criticized agonist maintenance. In Britain, ROD acquired a bad reputation when a UROD patient died in unsupervised and thus still mysterious circumstances in a CITA clinic. However, in several other centres, using a variety of rapid or accelerated techniques, hundreds or even thousands of patients have had ROD followed by depot NTX with little detoxification morbidity, no deaths and 3-year outcomes that can compare with agonist maintenance. The Stapleford Centre is a private clinic and provides both agonist- and antagonist-based treatments for opiate dependence. It does not currently conduct rapid detoxifications.
Read full abstract