Introduction: Ventilation is essential for the elimination of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) from the body during CPR. However, variation in ventilation rate (VR) is an acknowledged confounder for the interpretation of EtCO 2 . VRs that are not according to guidelines alter measured EtCO 2 levels and make the decision of termination of resuscitation (TOR) based on EtCO 2 unreliable. Aim: To retrospectively analyze the effect of ventilation rate on levels of EtCO 2 for patients that do not achieve ROSC during prehospital resuscitation. Methods: Capnograms obtained from monitor-defibrillator recordings of non-ROSC adult OHCA cases, attended by TVF&R (OR, USA), were manually inspected to identify individual ventilations. Episodes were partitioned into consecutive 1-min segments, each characterized by its mean EtCO 2 and VR. We corrected the mean EtCO 2 values by adjusting the VRs to the recommended standard for patients with advanced airways (10 vpm), and obtained new EtCO 2,s values multiplying by the standardization factor 1.64 (1 - 0.91 VR ) published previously. Results: One-minute segments ( n = 3,791) from 244 cases were studied, for a total number of 27,312 ventilations. Of these, 206 cases had a duration equal or greater than 20-min, and 9.7% met the TOR criterium of EtCO 2 < 10 mmHg at 20-min. Median (IQR) VR, measured EtCO 2 and corrected EtCO 2,s were 8.1 (6.2-10.6) vpm, 27.7 (17.9-39.8) and 24.1 (16.0-33.7) mmHg, respectively, all at the 20-min mark. Median EtCO 2,s was at all times lower than measured EtCO 2 , with differences from 10 to 20 min ranging from 3.3 to 5.1 mmHg. Conclusion: TOR guidelines lack consensus, but the threshold of EtCO 2 < 10 mmHg at the 20-minute mark of resuscitation, as predictive of non-survivability, needs re-examination. Modern CPR introduces several confounders that produce higher measured EtCO 2 , including low VRs that are common but can be corrected. Based on a ventilation rate of 10 vpm, a new threshold should be considered as part of a multimodal approach in TOR guidelines.
Read full abstract