Subclinical hypocalcemia, a reduction in blood calcium concentrations without apparent clinical signs of milk fever, occurs in 25 to 50% of early-postpartum dairy cows. Research has shown that these cows are at an increased risk of additional early-lactation diseases, including left displaced abomasum (LDA), compared with their normocalcemic counterparts. However, no work has assessed the association of total calcium (tCa) concentration at the time of LDA correction with subsequent milk yield and survival within the herd. Pending future development of an economical and accurate on-farm test for hypocalcemia, the ability to assess LDA prognosis after surgical correction based on precorrection blood tCa concentration is of interest to practitioners. Therefore, our objective was to determine the association of blood tCa concentration at the time of LDA surgical correction with milk yield and herd removal in the 60 d after correction. Nine bovine practitioners, located in New York State, were involved in sample collection from 17 herds for this prospective cohort study. Immediately following LDA diagnosis and before surgical correction, blood samples were collected from 152 dairy cows within the first 30 d in milk for serum tCa determination. The association of tCa with milk yield (n = 110) and herd removal (n = 127) in the first 60 d after LDA surgical correction was analyzed using repeated-measures ANOVA and a generalized linear mixed model, respectively, controlling for parity and days in milk at LDA surgical correction and the random effect of herd or practitioner. We found no evidence to support an association of tCa at time of LDA diagnosis with subsequent milk yield, and when cows were grouped by median tCa into low and high groups (tCa ≤2.1 and >2.1 mmol/L, respectively), subsequent milk production was similar (39.4 ± 1.6 and 40.1 ± 1.4 kg/d for low and high, respectively). Furthermore, we found no evidence to support an association of tCa at time of LDA diagnosis with the odds of herd removal (odds ratio = 0.6; 95% confidence interval = 0.4–1.7). Therefore, our study provided no clear evidence to support the association of tCa at time of LDA diagnosis and correction with either milk yield or herd removal during the 8 wk after correction. However, it did demonstrate low to extremely low tCa concentration in cows with LDA. Whether calcium supplementation would improve health and production outcomes in these cows is unclear and worth investigating further.