Oeni Cells Research Articles

Microbial Decontamination of Red Wine by Pulsed Electric Fields (PEF) after Alcoholic and Malolactic Fermentation: Effect on Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Oenococcus oeni, and Oenological Parameters during Storage.

New techniques are required to replace the use of sulfur dioxide (SO2) or of sterilizing filtration in wineries, due to those methods' drawbacks. Pulsed electric fields (PEF) is a technology capable of inactivating microorganisms at low temperatures in a continuous flow with no detrimental effect on food properties. In the present study, PEF technology was evaluated for purposes of microbial decontamination of red wines after alcoholic and malolactic fermentation, respectively. PEF combined with SO2 was evaluated in terms of microbial stability and physicochemical parameters over a period of four months. Furthermore, the effect of PEF on the sensory properties of red wine was compared with the sterilizing filtration method. Results showed that up to 4.0 Log10 cycles of S. cerevisiae and O. oeni could be eradicated by PEF and sublethal damages and a synergetic effect with SO2 were also observed, respectively. After 4 months, wine treated by PEF after alcoholic fermentation was free of viable yeasts; and less than 100 CFU/mL of O. oeni cells were viable in PEF-treated wine added with 20 ppm of SO2 after malolactic fermentation. No detrimental qualities were found, neither in terms of oenological parameters, nor in the sensory parameters of wines subjected to PEF after storage time.

The production of preconditioned freeze-dried Oenococcus oeni primes its metabolism to withstand environmental stresses encountered upon inoculation into wine

Oenococcus oeni is the most resistant lactic acid bacteria species to the environmental stresses encountered in wine, particularly the acidity, presence of ethanol and phenolic compounds. Indigenous strains develop spontaneously following the yeast-driven alcoholic fermentation and may perform the malolactic fermentation whereby improving taste, aroma, and the microbial stability of wine. However, spontaneous fermentation is sometimes delayed, prolonged or incomplete. In order to better control its timing and quality, O. oeni strains are selected and developed to be used as malolactic starters. They are prepared under proprietary manufacturing processes to survive direct inoculation and are predominantly provided as freeze-dried preparations. In this study, we have investigated the physiological and molecular alterations occurring in O. oeni cells prepared by an industrial process that consists of preconditioning protocols and freeze-drying, and compared them to the same strain grown in a grape juice medium. We found that compared to cultured cells, the industrial production process improved survival under extreme conditions, i. e. at low pH or high tannin concentrations. In contrast, cultured cells resumed active growth more quickly and strongly than freeze-dried preparations in standard pH wines. A proteomic analysis showed that during the industrial production most non-essential metabolic processes are shut down and components of the general and the stringent stress response are upregulated. The presence of major components of the stress response facilitates protein homeostasis and physiological changes that further ensure the integrity of cells.

L-Malate (-2) Protonation State is Required for Efficient Decarboxylation to l-Lactate by the Malolactic Enzyme of Oenococcus oeni.

Malolactic fermentation (MLF) is responsible for the decarboxylation of l-malic into lactic acid in most red wines and some white wines. It reduces the acidity of wine, improves flavor complexity and microbiological stability. Despite its industrial interest, the MLF mechanism is not fully understood. The objective of this study was to provide new insights into the role of pH on the binding of malic acid to the malolactic enzyme (MLE) of Oenococcus oeni. To this end, sequence similarity networks and phylogenetic analysis were used to generate an MLE homology model, which was further refined by molecular dynamics simulations. The resulting model, together with quantum polarized ligand docking (QPLD), was used to describe the MLE binding pocket and pose of l-malic acid (MAL) and its l-malate (−1) and (−2) protonation states (MAL− and MAL2−, respectively). MAL2− has the lowest ∆Gbinding, followed by MAL− and MAL, with values of −23.8, −19.6, and −14.6 kJ/mol, respectively, consistent with those obtained by isothermal calorimetry thermodynamic (ITC) assays. Furthermore, molecular dynamics and MM/GBSA results suggest that only MAL2− displays an extended open conformation at the binding pocket, satisfying the geometrical requirements for Mn2+ coordination, a critical component of MLE activity. These results are consistent with the intracellular pH conditions of O. oeni cells—ranging from pH 5.8 to 6.1—where the enzymatic decarboxylation of malate occurs.

Direct and Rapid Detection and Quantification of Oenococcus oeni Cells in Wine by Cells-LAMP and Cells-qLAMP.

Fast detection and enumeration of Oenococcus oeni in winemaking are necessary to determine whether malolactic fermentation (MLF) is likely to be performed or not and to decide if the use of a commercial starter is needed. In other wines, however, performing MLF can be detrimental for wine and should be avoided. The traditional identification and quantification of this bacteria using culture-dependent techniques in wine-related matrices require up to 14 days to yield results, which can be a very long time to perform possible enological operations. Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) is a novel culture-independent technique that amplifies nucleic acid sequences under isothermal conditions with high specificity and efficiency in less than 1 h with inexpensive equipment. We designed LAMP primers for the specific detection and quantification of O. oeni cells. The developed LAMP method allows O. oeni to be detected directly from both grape musts and wines within 1 h from the time that the LAMP reaction begins, and without DNA extraction and purification requirements. The high sensitivity of LAMP methodology is achieved by previous mechanical cells lysis with no further purification by detecting one single cell per reaction in culture media, and in white/red grape musts and wines by avoiding reaction inhibition by ethanol, polyphenols, and other wine inhibitors. Cells can be concentrated prior to the LAMP reaction to further increase this sensitivity. Moreover, the LAMP method does not require expensive equipment and can be easily operated. The developed method is both economic and fast and offers high sensitivity and specificity.

Cell surface damage and morphological changes in Oenococcus oeni after freeze-drying and incubation in synthetic wine

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effects of freeze-drying in the presence of trehalose as a cryoprotectant, followed by incubation in synthetic wine, on surface damage, viability and l-malic acid consumption of the oenological strain Oenococcus oeni UNQOe 73.2. After freeze-drying, no significant differences were observed in the number of viable cells (for both acclimated and non-acclimated cultures) respect to the fresh culture. In contrast, loss of viability was observed after wine incubation for 24 h, being acclimated freeze-dried cells the best conditions for this. After the preservation process, small changes in cell morphology were observed by Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). The Zeta potential and AFM showed that 24 h of wine incubation was enough to induce several cell surface modifications. Plate count data allowed us to establish that surface damage is an important factor for loss of viability, regardless of the acclimation treatment. Although the number of surviving O. oeni cells decreased dramatically after incubation in synthetic wine for 15 days, the consumption of l-malic acid was higher than 70%, with freeze-dried cells showing a better performance than fresh cultures. These results demonstrate that O. oeni freeze-dried cultures could be applied to direct wine inoculation, to conduct malolactic fermentation, maintaining its technological properties and reducing the time and costs of the winemaking process.

Ethanol stress in Oenococcus oeni: transcriptional response and complex physiological mechanisms.

Oenococcus oeni is the dominant species able to cope with a hostile environment of wines, comprising cumulative effects of low pH, high ethanol and SO2 content, nonoptimal growth temperatures and growth inhibitory compounds. Ethanol tolerance is a crucial feature for the activity of O. oeni cells in wine because ethanol acts as a disordering agent of its cell membrane and negatively affects metabolic activity; it damages the membrane integrity, decreases cell viability and, as other stress conditions, delays the start of malolactic fermentation with a consequent alteration of wine quality. The cell wall, cytoplasmic membrane and metabolic pathways are the main sites involved in physiological changes aimed to ensure an adequate adaptive response to ethanol stress and to face the oxidative damage caused by increasing production of reactive oxygen species. Improving our understanding of the cellular impact of ethanol toxicity and how the cell responds to ethanol stress can facilitate the development of strategies to enhance microbial ethanol tolerance; this allows to perform a multidisciplinary endeavour requiring not only an ecological study of the spontaneous process but also the characterization of useful technological and physiological features of the predominant strains in order to select those with the highest potential for industrial applications.

Simultaneous Alcoholic and Malolactic Fermentations by Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Oenococcus oeni Cells Co-immobilized in Alginate Beads.

Malolactic fermentation (MLF) usually takes place after the end of alcoholic fermentation (AF). However, the inoculation of lactic acid bacteria together with yeast starter cultures is a promising system to enhance the quality and safety of wine. In recent years, the use of immobilized cell systems has been investigated, with interesting results, for the production of different fermented foods and beverages. In this study we have carried out the simultaneous immobilization of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Oenococcus oeni in alginate beads and used them in microvinifications tests to produce Negroamaro wine. The process was monitored by chemical and sensorial analyses and dominance of starters and cell leaking from beads were also checked. Co-immobilization of S. cerevisiae and O. oeni allowed to perform an efficient fermentation process, producing low volatile acidity levels and ethanol and glycerol concentrations comparable with those obtained by cell sequential inoculum and co-inoculum of yeast and bacteria cells in free form. More importantly, co-immobilization strategy produced a significant decrease of the time requested to complete AF and MLF. The immobilized cells could be efficiently reused for the wine fermentation at least three times without any apparent loss of cell metabolic activities. This integrated biocatalytic system is able to perform simultaneously AF and MLF, producing wines similar in organoleptic traits in comparison with wines fermented following traditional sequential AF and MLF with free cell starters. The immobilized-cell system, that we here describe for the first time in our knowledge, offers many advantages over conventional free cell fermentations, including: (i) elimination of non-productive cell growth phases; (ii) feasibility of continuous processing; (iii) re-use of the biocatalyst.

A novel culture medium for Oenococcus oeni malolactic starter production

Malolactic fermentation is essential in wine quality. One of the strategies used to control this fermentation involves the inoculation of selected lactic acid bacteria, mainly Oenococcus oeni. Laboratory media usually produce large amounts of biomass, but with little or no adaptability to wine. We propose a culture medium to grow and pre-adapt O. oeni cells, and the steps to scale-up production. To achieve this objective, 27 different media were tested. All contained grape must and wine, and nutritional supplements in order to benefit bacterial growth. Those media contained different ethanol levels, pH values, and grape must concentrations. The optimized culture medium named Oenococcus Production Medium (OPM) contained diluted commercial 4X concentrate white must (1:6), ASv = 4%, and a pH of 3.8. The total time to obtain 80 L of an O. oeni liquid starter culture from the stock culture at the laboratory, with a final population of CFU = 1 × 109 mL−1, was 22 d. The starter culture was efficiently scaled-up, and preserved at 4 °C, −20 °C, or freeze-dried. This new culture medium also allowed adaptation of bacteria to the wine conditions, consuming all malic acid (3 g/L) in 7 d with an inoculum of CFU = 1 × 106 mL−1.

Rapid assessment of Oenococcus oeni activity by measuring intracellular pH and membrane potential by flow cytometry, and its application to the more effective control of malolactic fermentation

The aim of this study is to highlight the changes in the physiological cellular state of Oenococcus oeni during malolactic fermentation (MLF), and to use its cellular parameters to improve existing knowledge of O. oeni behaviour and to more effectively control the performance of the bacteria during MLF in wine.To do this, measurements of intracellular pH, transmembrane potential and vitality were performed using flow cytometry with different fluorescent probes: CFDA-SE and CDCF, DiBAC and CFDA, respectively. The kinetics of the cellular changes in these parameters were determined during MLF in FT80 synthetic medium and in white wine, as were the kinetics of malic acid consumption.pHin measurement throughout the entire growth shows that the pH was equal to the pH of the culture medium during the early stage, increased to pH6 in the exponential phase, and then decreased to equilibrate with the pH of the medium in the late stationary phase. Membrane potential increased in early MLF and then decreased. The decrease in pHin and membrane potential occurred when all of the malic acid was consumed. Finally, we showed that the higher the ΔpH (pHin−pHex) in O. oeni cells was, the shorter the lag phase of the MLF was. To better manage the initiation of MLF in wines, the physiological state of O. oeni cells must be taken into account. These results allow us to understand the sometimes random initiation of MLF in wines inoculated with O. oeni and to suggest ways to improve this control.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Oenococcus oeni immobilized in different layers of a cellulose/starch gel composite for simultaneous alcoholic and malolactic wine fermentations

The production of a two-layer composite biocatalyst for immobilization of two different microorganisms for simultaneous alcoholic and malolactic fermentation (MLF) of wine in the same bioreactor is reported. The biocatalyst consisted of a tubular delignified cellulosic material (DCM) with entrapped Oenococcus oeni cells, covered with starch gel containing the alcohol resistant and cryotolerant strain Saccharomyces cerevisiae AXAZ-1. The biocatalyst was found effective for simultaneous low temperature alcoholic fermentation resulting to conversion of malic acid to lactic acid in 5 days at 10°C. Improvement of wine quality compared with wine fermented with S. cerevisiae AXAZ-1 immobilized on DCM was attributed to MLF as well as to increased ester formation and lower higher alcohols produced at low fermentation temperatures (10°C) as shown by GC and headspace SPME GC/MS analysis. Scanning electron microscopy showed that the preparation of a three-layer composite biocatalyst is also possible. The significance of such composite biocatalysts is the feasibility of two or three bioprocesses in the same bioreactor, thus reducing production cost in the food industry

Rapid enumeration of Oenococcus oeni during malolactic fermentation by flow cytometry

The aim of this study was to provide a method to rapidly enumerate Oenococcus oeni cells during malolactic fermentation (MLF). To keep MLF under control, it is important to monitor the growth of the bacteria O. oeni. However, the enumeration of O. oeni using the plate count technique requires a very long incubation time of about 10 days or more, which is not adapted to monitoring MLF in real time. Flow cytometry (FCM), in combination with several fluorescent probes, is a rapid method for counting large numbers of bacterial cells. However, probes based on fluorescein [FDA, carboxyfluorescein diacetate (cFDA)] did not give good results for O. oeni. For the first time, we propose using the BacLight™ kit for enumeration of O. oeni, and we compare the results with three methods: plate count and FCM, in combination with either fluorescein probes or the BacLight™kit. The last method provides a perfect correlation with the plate count method. FCM coupled with the Baclight™ kit makes it possible to count O. oeni cells during MLF with a perfect correlation with the plate count method. The result is obtained in 20 min vs 10 days with the reference method which will be very useful for wine microbiologists. Moreover, it should be emphasized that FDA/cFDA staining is not recommended because it can lead to an erroneous count during the latency period or at the end of growth due to the variation of intracellular pH in the O. oeni cells during growth.

Malolactic fermentation of wines with immobilised lactic acid bacteria – Influence of concentration, type of support material and storage conditions

Corn cobs, grape skins and grape stems were evaluated as support materials for immobilization of the lactic acid bacteria Oenococcus oeni. The support materials with immobilized cells were further used in malolactic fermentation (MLF) of white wine. Viability of using the immobilized supports was evaluated in consecutive batch fermentations under different conditions of temperature, ethanol and SO2. Additionally, the possibility of storage and operational stability of the immobilized supports was also studied. All the three supports presented large potential for immobilization of O. oeni cells. The consecutive batches of MLF were successfully conducted for a total period of around 5months with the possibility of storage of the biocatalyst for 30d in wine at 25°C.

Activity of ethanol-stressedOenococcus oenicells: a flow cytometric approach

To study the effect of ethanol on Oenococcus oeni activity at the single cell level. The active extrusion of the fluorescent probe carboxy fluorescein (cF) was used to assess the metabolic activity of ethanol-stressed O. oeni cells. Subsequent flow cytometric analysis revealed that O. oeni cells extrude the accumulated cF upon energizing with l-malic acid. However, O. oeni cells exposed to 12% (v/v) ethanol for 1 h showed a decreased capacity for active extrusion of cF. Moreover, two subpopulations could be distinguished, one of which being able to extrude cF and the other one remaining cF fluorescent. Growing cells in the presence of 8% (v/v) ethanol resulted in robust cells that maintained the capacity to actively extrude cF after being exposed to 12% (v/v) ethanol, which in turn correlated with the high levels of ATP observed in these ethanol stressed, malolactic fermentation (MLF) performing cells. From our results, it becomes evident that active extrusion of cF can be used to assess malolactic activity in O. oeni. The present study provides information for the development of a rapid method to assess the malolactic activity of individual O. oeni cells performing MLF during wine production.

Changes in membrane lipid composition in ethanol- and acid-adapted Oenococcus oeni cells: characterization of the cfa gene by heterologous complementation

Cyclopropane fatty acid (CFA) synthesis was investigated in Oenococcus oeni. The data obtained demonstrated that acid-grown cells or cells harvested in the stationary growth phase showed changes in fatty acid composition similar to those of ethanol-grown cells. An increase of the CFA content and a decrease of the oleic acid content were observed. The biosynthesis of CFAs from unsaturated fatty acid phospholipids is catalysed by CFA synthases. Quantitative real-time-PCR experiments were performed on the cfa gene of O. oeni, which encodes a putative CFA synthase. The level of cfa transcripts increased when cells were harvested in stationary phase and when cells were grown in the presence of ethanol or at low pH, suggesting transcriptional regulation of the cfa gene under different stress conditions. In contrast to Escherichia coli, only one functional promoter was identified upstream of the cfa gene of O. oeni. The function of the cfa gene was confirmed by complementation of a cfa-deficient E. coli strain. Nevertheless, the complementation remained partial because the conversion percentage of unsaturated fatty acids into CFA of the complemented strain was much lower than that of the wild-type strain. Moreover, a prevalence of cycC19 : 0 was observed in the membrane of the complemented strain. This could be due to a specific affinity of the CFA synthase from O. oeni. In spite of this partial complementation, the complemented strain of E. coli totally recovered its viability after ethanol shock (10 %, v/v) whereas its viability was only partly recovered after an acid shock at pH 3.0.

Influence of culture pH on freeze-drying viability of Oenococcus oeni and its relationship with fatty acid composition

To achieve successful malolactic fermentation in wine making, expanding interest in ready-to-use concentrated Oenococcus oeni starter culture has placed greater emphasis on developing starter production and preservation methods. The effect of growth factors on the survival of the O. oeni cells after lyophilization and its relationship with the membrane fatty acid composition were investigated. O. oeni cells in the early stationary phase survived better after freeze-drying than those in the mid-exponential phase, and those early stationary phase O. oeni cells cultured in designed ATB, FMATB and MATB growth media with different pH buffering capabilities exhibited different freeze-drying viabilities. Results concerning both membrane fatty acid composition and freeze-drying viability of O. oeni cells grown in those three media at initial culture pH 4.8, 4.0, 3.5, 3.2 were subjected to correlation analysis, indicating a decrease of the growth pH improved the freeze-drying survival of O. oeni cells, which was correlated with the enrichment of C19cyc11 and the decrease of C16:0 in the membrane lipids. A better understanding of the mechanisms of O. oeni resistance to lyophilization could rationalize their exploitation to prepare commercial starter cultures.

Oenococcus oeni cells immobilized on delignified cellulosic material for malolactic fermentation of wine

Oenococcus oeni ATCC 23279 cells immobilized on delignified cellulosic material (DCM) were used for malolactic fermentation (MLF). In first, eleven repeated alcoholic fermentation batches of white must of 11–12 °Be initial density were performed by Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells immobilized on delignified cellulosic material at 20 °C. Subsequently, the induction of MLF in the eleven taken wine batches by O. oeni cells immobilized on DCM took place at 27 °C. From the 3rd MLF batch up to 10th, the malic acid degradation was 53.1 up to 67.4% and the cfu of the immobilized cells/g of biocatalyst remained stable. The produced lactic acid was less than the stoichiometric yield and acetic acid content was significantly reduced after MLF not contributing in an important increase of the volatile acidity of wine. Ethanol, higher alcohols acetaldehyde and diacetyl contents in wines after MLF were in acceptable levels.

A small HSP, Lo18, interacts with the cell membrane and modulates lipid physical state under heat shock conditions in a lactic acid bacterium

The small heat shock proteins (sHSP) are characterized by a chaperone activity to prevent irreversible protein denaturation. This study deals with the sHSP Lo18 induced by multiple stresses in Oenococcus oeni, a lactic acid bacterium. Using in situ immunocytochemistry and cellular fractionation experiments, we demonstrated the association of Lo18 with the membrane in O. oeni cells submitted to heat shock. The same result was obtained after exposure of cells to ethanol or benzyl alcohol, agents known to have an influence on membranes. For the different stresses, the protein was located on the periphery of the cell at membrane level and was also found within the cytoplasm. In order to determine if Lo18 could interact with the phospholipids, we used model membranes made of lipids extracted from O. oeni cells. Using fluorescence anisotropy of diphenylhexatriene (DPH) and generalized polarization of Laurdan, we showed that purified Lo18 interacts with these liposomes, and increases the molecular order of the lipid bilayer in these membranes when the temperature reaches 33.8 °C. All these data suggest that Lo18 could be involved in an adaptive response allowing the maintenance of membrane integrity during stress conditions in O. oeni cells.

Combined cold, acid, ethanol shocks in Oenococcus oeni: Effects on membrane fluidity and cell viability

The effects of combined cold, acid and ethanol on the membrane physical state and on the survival of Oenococcus oeni were investigated. Membrane fluidity was monitored on intact whole O. oeni cells subjected to single and combined cold, acid and ethanol shocks by using fluorescence anisotropy with 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) as a probe. Results showed that cold shocks (14 and 8 °C) strongly rigidified plasma membrane but did not affect cell survival. In contrast, ethanol shocks (10–14% v/v) induced instantaneous membrane fluidisation followed by rigidification and resulted in low viability. Acid shocks (pH 4.0 and pH 3.0) exerted a rigidifying effect on membrane without affecting cell viability. Whatever the shock orders, combined cold (14 °C) and ethanol (14% v/v) shocks resulted in strong membrane rigidification. Interestingly, O. oeni survived combined cold and ethanol shocks more efficiently than single ethanol shock. Membrane rigidification was induced by ethanol-and-acid (10% v/v - pH 3.5) shock and correlated with total cell death. In contrast, O. oeni recovered its viability when subjected to cold (8 °C)-then-ethanol-and-acid shock which strongly rigidified the membrane. Our results suggested a positive short-term effect of combined cold, acid and ethanol shocks on membrane fluidity and viability of O. oeni.

Effect of adaptation to ethanol on cytoplasmic and membrane protein profiles of Oenococcus oeni.

The practical application of commercial malolactic starter cultures of Oenococcus oeni surviving direct inoculation in wine requires insight into mechanisms of ethanol toxicity and of acquired ethanol tolerance in this organism. Therefore, the site-specific location of proteins involved in ethanol adaptation, including cytoplasmic, membrane-associated, and integral membrane proteins, was investigated. Ethanol triggers alterations in protein patterns of O. oeni cells stressed with 12% ethanol for 1 h and those of cells grown in the presence of 8% ethanol. Levels of inosine-5'-monophosphate dehydrogenase and phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, which generate reduced nicotinamide nucleotides, were decreased during growth in the presence of ethanol, while glutathione reductase, which consumes NADPH, was induced, suggesting that maintenance of the redox balance plays an important role in ethanol adaptation. Phosphoenolpyruvate:mannose phosphotransferase system (PTS) components of mannose PTS, including the phosphocarrier protein HPr and EII(Man), were lacking in ethanol-adapted cells, providing strong evidence that mannose PTS is absent in ethanol-adapted cells, and this represents a metabolic advantage to O. oeni cells during malolactic fermentation. In cells grown in the presence of ethanol, a large increase in the number of membrane-associated proteins was observed. Interestingly, two of these proteins, dTDT-glucose-4,6-dehydratase and D-alanine:D-alanine ligase, are known to be involved in cell wall biosynthesis. Using a proteomic approach, we provide evidence for an active ethanol adaptation response of O. oeni at the cytoplasmic and membrane protein levels.

The potential of positively-charged cellulose sponge for malolactic fermentation of wine, using Oenococcus oeni.

Malolactic fermentation (MLF) is a secondary bioconversion developed in some wines involving malic acid decarboxylation. The induction of MLF in wine by cultures of free and immobilized Oenococcus oeni cells was investigated. This work reports on the effect of surface charges in the immobilization material, a recently described fibrous sponge, as well as the pH and the composition of the media where cells are suspended. A chemical treatment provided positive charge to the sponges (DE or DEAE) and gave the highest cell loadings and subsequent resistance to removal. Preculture media to grow the malolactic bacteria before the immobilization procedure were also evaluated. We have established favorable conditions for growth (Medium of Preculture), suspension solution (Tartrate-Phosphate Buffer), suspension pH (3.5-5.5) and immobilization matrix (DE or DEAE cellulose sponge) to induce MLF in red wine. The use of a semi-continuous system permitted a high-efficiency malic acid conversion by 2 x 10(9) cfu sponge(-)(1) in at least four subsequent batch fermentations.