(ProQuest: ... denotes non-US-ASCII text omitted.)In 2003, the Aichi Senmon Nisodo ... celebrated the onehundredth anniversary of its founding as a training convent for Soto Zen nuns. To commemorate the occasion, the nuns performed the Anan koshiki ..., a chanted lecture commemorating the Buddha's disciple, Ananda, and recorded the event on film. Abbess Aoyama Shundo (b. 1933) wrote the companion volume (2003), which includes a reproduction of a 1829 printing of the Anan koshiki, as well as the abbess's commentary on the ritual and its historical background. The Aichi Senmon Nisodo is probably the only Buddhist institution in Japan at which the Anan koshiki is still performed. Even here this elaborate ritual is staged only for special occasions-approximately every six to eight years-and its performance requires at least twelve nuns who have undergone training in Soto-style koshiki ... and the idiosyncrasies of the Anan koshiki (Arai 2000, 123; Aoyama 2003, 118, 124, 130-31; Kawaguchi 2004, 79).In this article, I trace the history of the Anan koshiki from its precursors in ancient India, China, and Japan, to its compilation in the medieval period and revitalization in the late Edo period. Subsequently, I examine the ritual's contents and assess how the rite depicts women in Buddhist monasticism. I argue that the ritual has functioned polysemously, affirming nuns' marginalization and their lesser status vis-a-vis the male clergy, while also serving as a means for nuns to celebrate their gender difference. Most strikingly, Aoyama's commentary feminizes Ananda, a patriarch of her Zen lineage, as a paragon of female virtues. Thus she symbolically turns Ananda into a great heroine rather than a great hero, thereby completing an inversion of a common medieval rhetorical tactic employed by Zen masters who masculinized exceptional women as great heroes.1 The Anan koshiki, its performance, and Aoyama's commentary contain oblique strategies of inversion and self-affirmation that allow the nuns to employ androcentric concepts to suit their own interests and agendas, to borrow Saba Mahmood's language (Mahmood 2005, 6).Precursors of the Anan koshikiRituals in praise of Ananda have a long history within the female monastic order of Buddhism. Early Indian Buddhist women-nuns in particular-were said to have an affinity with Ananda, who not only convinced the Buddha to admit women to the monastic order but was also extraordinarily popular with female Buddhist devotees who flocked to his sermons. He is described as having a fiercely loyal following within the Buddhist nuns' order. For instance, the nun Thullatissa purportedly defended Ananda when he was criticized and belittled by Mahakasyapa. Thullatissa upbraided Mahakasyapa in obvious violation of the Eight Heavy Rules that forbade nuns to chastise male monastics. In a similar story, the nun Sthulananda disrobed herself in front of Mahakasyapa in order to chastise Mahakasyapa and support Ananda. In that case, Ananda is said to have responded apologetically by describing himself as stupid, crazy, and feminine (Wilson 1996, 108-109, 229). In other words, Ananda characterized himself with qualities that Buddhist texts often stereotypically associate with women. From a male perspective, Ananda's close relationships with nuns and women were generally depicted as reprehensible and signs of weakness. Yet for women, Ananda's concern for and compassion toward them were not grounds for criticism but instead elicited veneration.Katsuura Noriko (2008, 104-107) has traced the first evidence of nuns' devotional rituals for Ananda to the travelogues of Chinese monks Faxian ... (337-422) and Xuanzang ... (602-664), who depict their journeys to the Indian subcontinent. Both monks document such rituals at Mathura, a site at which nuns had a strong presence and were highly involved in the emerging cult of images (Schopen 1997, 238-57). In his Foguoji ... (Record of Buddhist countries), Faxian reports that, in about 405, he witnessed Buddhist nuns (bhiksu? …
Read full abstract