Fire exclusion in forests across the western United States has resulted in widespread vegetation change, often with notable increases in density and cover of fire-sensitive species. In California oak woodlands, encroachment by the more shade-tolerant native Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) is particularly common, and results in the piercing and eventual overtopping of crowns of shade-intolerant trees. We investigated canopy competition, paired tree ages, and post-fire effects in a recently burned, encroached California black oak (Quercus kelloggii) woodland. Pre-fire woodland overstory was heavily dominated by Douglas-fir, which commonly pierced and overtopped California black oak crowns. Trees that pierced overstory oak crowns were younger (mean difference=43.6years, p<0.001) than their paired oaks. Fire effects were variable, leaving some areas unchanged and others with complete above-ground stem mortality. Although above-ground stem-kill was often high for California black oak, the majority (82%) re-sprouted from the root collar. Logistic modeling revealed a significant relationship between California black oak mortality and neighboring Douglas-fir height and plot heat load index. The probability of California black oak mortality increased as neighboring Douglas-fir height increased and decreased with increasing heat load index. Probability of mortality for Douglas-fir decreased with increasing tree size, while the probability of California black oak top-kill was much higher than that for 20–30cmdbh Douglas-fir across a continuous measure of char height. Results indicate that competitive pressure from encroaching trees may compromise California black oak’s ability to survive fire while resilience of encroaching Douglas-fir improves with greater size. Caution should be taken when planning and implementing restoration activities in California black oak woodlands to minimize loss of compromised, remnant oaks while still achieving adequate removal of encroaching conifers.
Read full abstract