A Nutrient Cycling Spreadsheet (NuCSS) model was developed to simulate nutrient cycling in forest ecosystems. This model is intended to provide a tool for nutrient management and is intermediate in complexity between simple budget calculations and complex, process-based ecosystem models. NuCSS simulates biomass production, organic matter decomposition, N mineralization, cation adsorption, weathering and leaching (hydrology not included) using empirical relationships and simple mechanistic process descriptions. The model calculates a target biomass production and associated nutrient uptake. By reviewing soil nutrient pools the user can assess whether available soil nutrients can sustain the targeted biomass production. NuCSS was calibrated to a Norway spruce site in the Solling Mountains, Germany. The model performance was evaluated using long-term data on deposition, vegetation, water quality and soil nutrient inventories. Long-term predictions were made using a ‘business as usual’ and two reduced deposition scenarios. Results from NuCSS were compared with simulations from other biogeochemical models. The element distribution over soil, forest floor and vegetation closely matched measurements both after one and 15 years. Forest floor nutrients were underestimated but data on forest floor accumulation proved to be unreliable. NuCSS overestimated N uptake, N mineralization and leaching but not enough data on these fluxes were available to determine whether NuCSS was wrong. Simulated base cation leaching agreed well with the measurements but K leaching was overestimated most likely due to an underestimation of the selectivity coefficient for K adsorption. The reduced deposition scenarios caused N and base cation leaching to decrease with time. When N deposition was reduced by 95%, a N deficit occurred and N mineralization and deposition could not sustain the (fixed) uptake. For most simulated parameters NuCSS agreed well with more detailed, process-based, biogeochemical models. In general, NuCSS simulated a higher N leaching and N mineralization than most other models. Trends in base saturation and base cation leaching simulated by NuCSS agreed well with other models. The model proved to be helpful in addressing some of the uncertainties in nutrient cycling regarding vegetation uptake, weathering rates and N mineralization. Given the uncertainties in description of certain processes, a quantitative use of NuCSS may not be justified. These uncertainties also apply to more complex nutrient cycling models, however.
Read full abstract