An extensive karyological analysis was carried out on marine and freshwater Bangia from North America (70°N to c. 23°N), including 40 collections from the Pacific, 39 from the Atlantic, 8 from the Laurentian Great Lakes and also 2 freshwater collections from Europe for comparison with the Great Lakes material. Chromosome numbers were determined and linked to gene trees derived from DNA sequence analyses of the chloroplast rbcL and nuclear small-subunit (SSU) rRNA genes. For the first time in one continent, five different chromosomal types were observed among marine populations, viz. monosporic plants with three (n), four (n) or six (2n) chromosomes and sexual plants with three (n)/six (2n) or four (n)/eight (2n) chromosomes. These types were also characterized with respect to seasonality and distribution. Freshwater Bangia filaments were all monosporic, with three chromosomes and a distinctive chromosome morphology: the third chromosome is very much smaller than that in marine three-chromosome collections. Based on these observations and DNA sequence analyses in which freshwater collections of Bangia are positioned on a separate and well-supported branch, we propose resurrecting the name B. atropurpurea to represent this lineage. There also appear to be some distinct entities among the marine Bangia occurring along North American coastlines, judging by chromosome numbers and gene trees. For example, there is a transarctic group of monosporic three-chromosome plants that have identical sequences for rbcL and very similar nuclear SSU rRNA gene sequences. However, populations of Bangia along the mid to southern coasts of North America with the same chromosome number were not always found to cluster together in gene trees, suggesting a mixing of multiple species brought about possibly by vector-assisted transport. At this time, marine populations should continue to be recognized as B. fuscopurpurea until their complex relationships can be resolved.