Normal Neutrino Mass Hierarchy Research Articles

Are neutrino oscillation mixings linked to the smallness of solar neutrino scale?

Observed reactor and atmospheric neutrino oscillation mixing values appear to be related to the neutrino scale ratio p ∆m2 sol/∆2 ATM in a way that suggest that the neutrino mass matrix can be expanded as a power series by using this ratio as the smallness parameter. This approach provides a simple and natural way to expose the inner hierarchies among neutrino mass terms, which amounts to also explain the solar oscillation mixing as well as solar oscillation scale. We explore a class of mass matrix textures that realize this scenario, for both normal and inverted neutrino mass hierarchies, as well as CP violation and their stability under renormalization scaling.

B − L model with D 4 × Z 4 × Z 2 symmetry for fermion mass hierarchies and mixings* *This research was funded by Tay Nguyen University under grant number T2023-45CBTÐ

We constructed a gauge model with symmetry to explain the quark and lepton mass hierarchies and their mixings with realistic CP phases via the type-I seesaw mechanism. Six quark mases, three quark mixing angles, and the CP phase in the quark sector take the central values whereas Yukawa couplings in the quark sector are diluted in a range of difference of three orders of magnitude by the perturbation theory at the first order. Concerning the neutrino sector, a small neutrino mass is achieved by the type-I seesaw mechanism. Both inverted and normal neutrino mass hierarchies are consistent with the experimental data. The predicted sum of neutrino masses for normal and inverted hierarchies, the effective neutrino masses, and the Dirac CP phase are also consistent with recently reported limits.

A minimal inverse seesaw model with S4 flavour symmetry

We construct an S4 flavour symmetric minimal inverse seesaw model where the standard model is extended by adding two right-handed and two standard model gauge singlet neutrinos to explain the origin of tiny neutrino masses. The resulting model describes the lepton mass spectra and flavour mixing quite well for the case of the normal hierarchy of neutrino masses. The prediction of the model on the Dirac CP-violating phase is centered around 370.087°. Furthermore, using the allowed region for the model parameters, we have calculated the value of the effective Majorana neutrino mass, |〈mee〉|, which characterizes neutrinoless double beta decay.

Flavored leptogenesis and Dirac CP violation

In this work, we pay special attention to establish the crucial role of the Casas-Ibarra parameterization in the presence of two different orthogonal matrices, R = O eiA and R = O e A in order to investigate the role of Dirac CP violation in flavored leptogenesis. By considering these two choices of the R matrix we examine the connection between the low-energy and high-energy CP violations together with certain interesting predictions on the low-energy parameters, namely, the lightest neutrino mass and the Dirac CP phase (δ). By considering the right-handed neutrino (RHN) mass window to be 108 GeV, we show that Dirac-phase leptogenesis is possible with the choices of these two orthogonal matrices. The above forms of R matrices allow us to choose a nearly degenerate spectrum for the RHN masses. The complex R matrix predicts a maximal Dirac CP violation (δ = π/2) for leptogenesis, which can be verified by the ongoing and upcoming searches for a precise δ measurement at the neutrino factories. We also discuss the phenomenological implications of these two case studies within the context of lepton flavor violation (LFV) by considering the μ → e γ decay process, in terms of an indirect probe of the R matrix parameter space. We report an upper bound on the lightest neutrino mass (m 1) of around 0.015 eV from the baryon asymmetry criteria for normal hierarchy of neutrino masses.

Neutrino mixing matrix and masses from a particular two-zero texture based on A 4 symmetry

The current study aims to investigate the particular case of two zeros in a Majorana neutrino mass matrix based on A 4 symmetry, where charged lepton mass matrix is diagonal. The texture is with (μ, μ) and (τ, τ) vanishing element of the neutrino mass matrix. The texture has magic and μ − τ symmetry, with a tribimaximal form of the mixing matrix, which leads to θ 13 = 0 that it is not consistent with experimental data and at first, does not seem to be allowed. Since θ 13 a small mixing angle compared to others neutrino mixing angles justifies the use of perturbation theory. We propose that, θ 13, and the Dirac phase δ, and two Majorana phases ρ and σ could be generated by using a complex symmetric perturbation mass matrix in the mass basis and find that affect to the atmospheric mixing angle. We show that only the predictions of the case I, with Δ < 0 and , are consistent with the experimental data. Furthermore, the allowed range of our parameter space and complex elements of perturbation mass matrix are found, which led to finding the allowed region of the neutrino masses, the Majorana phases, the effective neutrino mass for the neutrinoless double beta decay, the allowed deviation of θ 23 from 45°, and to predict the normal neutrino mass hierarchy. The predicted region of and θ 23 are in line with the current experimental data which indicate the accuracy of our model and its results. The results of the case II, with Δ > 0 and , are ruled out.

Connecting low-energy CP violation, resonant leptogenesis and neutrinoless double beta decay in a radiative seesaw model

We present a study of resonant leptogenesis in a radiative seesaw model. We consider the case where two quasi-degenerate right-handed neutrinos realize resonant leptogenesis, and the CP violation necessary to achieve leptogenesis occurs through the CP phases present in the neutrino mixing matrix. A numerical analysis is performed by taking the best-fit values from the current global data for three neutrino mixing angles and two mass-squared differences. We have shown how the predicted value of baryon asymmetry depends on the Dirac and Majorana CP phases. With the particular choice for the mass parameters, this model prefers a normal hierarchy of neutrino masses based on the value of baryon asymmetry predicted. Using the constrained CP phases, we evaluate the effective neutrino mass, which is relevant to the neutrinoless double beta decay.

Two-Zero Textures Based on A4 Symmetry and Unimodular Mixing Matrix

We propose a phenomenological model of two-zeros Majorana neutrino mass matrix based on the A4 symmetry, where the structure of mixing matrix is a unimodular second scheme of trimaximal TM2, and the charged lepton mass matrix is diagonal. We show that, among seven possible two-zero textures with A4 symmetry, only two textures, namely the texture with Mee=0 and Meμ=0 and its permutation, are acceptable in the non-perturbation method, since the results associated with these two textures are consistent with the experimental data. We obtain a unique relation between our phases, namely ρ+σ=ϕ±π, and an effective equation sin2θ13=23Rν where Rν=δm2Δm2. Then, only by using the experimental ranges of Rν, we obtain the allowable range of the unknown parameter ϕ as the phase of TM2 mixing matrix, which leads to obtaining not only the ranges of all neutrino oscillation parameters of the model (which agree well with experimental data) but also with the masses of neutrinos, the Dirac and Majorana phases and the Jarlskog parameter, and to predict the normal neutrino mass hierarchy. Finally, we show that all the predictions regarding our two specific textures agree with the corresponding data reported from neutrino oscillation, cosmic microwave background and neutrinoless double beta decay.

Neutrino masses and mass hierarchy: evidence for the normal hierarchy

The latest cosmological constraints on the sum of neutrino masses, in combination with the latest laboratory measurements on oscillations, provide “decisive” Bayesian evidence for the normal neutrino mass hierarchy. We show that this result holds across very different prior alternatives by exploring two extremes on the range of prior choices. In fact, while the specific numerical value for the Evidence depends on the choice of prior, the Bayesian odds remain greater than 140:1 across very different prior choices. For Majorana neutrinos this has important implications for the upper limit of the neutrino-less double beta decay half life and thus for the technology and resources needed for future double beta decay experiments.

Determining the Neutrino Mass Eigenstates and the Effective Majorana Mass

This paper aims at solving several open questions in current neutrino physics: the neutrino mass hierarchy, the Dirac CP violating phase, the absolute mass of neutrinos, the nature of neutrinos (Dirac or Majorana), the Majorana matrix and the absolute value of the effective Majorana neutrino mass. In the research presented in this paper, we have shown that the precise definition of the mass splittings between neutrino mass eigenstates, done in the latest analysis of experimental data, can be of crucial importance for defining the nature of neutrino mass hierarchy. The Standard Model has three generations of fundamental matter particles. Three generations of the charged lepton mass show a hierarchical structure: mτ > mμ > me. Owing to that, there is a belief and it is considered that neutrinos may follow such hierarchical structure. In our calculations, we have also included the latest data obtained, based on the processing of measurement results, which showed that even with such data, obtained results favor the normal neutrino mass hierarchy. As for the individual neutrino mass calculated in this paper, in today’s neutrino physics it is only known that neutrino mass scale is bounded only from above, and both the Dirac and the Majorana character of neutrinos are compatible with all observations. Among some of the questions resolved in this paper, which are related to the properties of neutrinos, a positive answer was also given to the question of whether light neutrinos are self-conjugate particles or not.

Neutrino and doubly charged Higgs boson phenomenology in flavored-TNMSSM

We develop a neutrino mass model based on A4×Z3 flavor symmetry in the context of the NMSSM extended by supersymmetric type II seesaw mechanism (flavored-TNMSSM). We show that the NMSSM-singlet contributes significantly to the light neutrino masses, leading to the trimaximal neutrino mixing and providing a source for CP violation. The model favors normal hierarchy for neutrino masses, and offers testable predictions for upcoming experiments aimed at developing the measurements of the parameters mνe, |mee|. We also show that the decay of the doubly charged Higgs boson (DCHB) into dilepton of the same sign is dominant; and that the muon-tau (μτ) channel is the most relevant, thus giving rise to a collider signature. We prove that the model allows LFV processes, such as τ±→e±μ∓e± and τ±→μ±e∓μ±. We find further that when the triplet VEV exceeds 0.5 eV, a discovery of the DCHB would be possible at the current run of the LHC; whereas for a broad part of the parameter space when the triplet VEV is less than about 0.5 eV, the DCHB can acquire mass up to few TeVs, which can be probed at HL-LHC, HE-LHC, and future 100 TeV hadron colliders.

Resonant leptogenesis and TM_1 mixing in minimal type-I seesaw model with S_4 symmetry

We present an S_4 flavour symmetric model within a minimal seesaw framework resulting in mass matrices that leads to TM_1 mixing. Minimal seesaw is realized by adding two right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model. The model predicts Normal Hierarchy (NH) for neutrino masses. Using the constrained six-dimensional parameter space of the model, we have evaluated the effective Majorana neutrino mass, which is the parameter of interest in neutrinoless double beta decay experiments. The possibility of explaining baryogenesis via resonant leptogenesis is also examined within the model. A non-zero, resonantly enhanced CP asymmetry generated from the decay of right-handed neutrinos at the TeV scale is studied, considering flavour effects. The evolution of lepton asymmetry is discussed by solving the set of Boltzmann equations numerically and obtain the value of baryon asymmetry to be |eta _B| = 6.3 times 10^{-10} with the choice of right-handed neutrino mass, M_1 = 10 TeV and mass splitting, d simeq 10^{-8}.

Modulus \u03c4 linking leptonic CP violation to baryon asymmetry in A4 modular invariant flavor model

We propose an A4 modular invariant flavor model of leptons, in which both CP and modular symmetries are broken spontaneously by the vacuum expectation value of the modulus τ. The value of the modulus τ is restricted by the observed lepton mixing angles and lepton masses for the normal hierarchy of neutrino masses. The predictive Dirac CP phase δCP is in the ranges [0°, 50°], [170°, 175°] and [280°, 360°] for Re [τ] < 0, and [0°, 80°], [185°, 190°] and [310°, 360°] for Re [τ] > 0. The sum of three neutrino masses is predicted in [60, 84] meV, and the effective mass for the 0νββ decay is in [0.003, 3] meV. The modulus τ links the Dirac CP phase to the cosmological baryon asymmetry (BAU) via the leptogenesis. Due to the strong wash-out effect, the predictive baryon asymmetry YB can be at most the same order of the observed value. Then, the lightest right-handed neutrino mass is restricted in the range of M1 = [1.5, 6.5] × 1013 GeV. We find the correlation between the predictive YB and the Dirac CP phase δCP. Only two predictive δCP ranges, [5°, 40°] (Re [τ] > 0) and [320°, 355°] (Re [τ] < 0) are consistent with the BAU.

Controlled fermion mixing and FCNCs in a \u2206(27) 3+1 Higgs Doublet Model

We propose a 3+1 Higgs Doublet Model based on the ∆(27) family symmetry supplemented by several auxiliary cyclic symmetries leading to viable Yukawa textures for the Standard Model fermions, consistent with the observed pattern of fermion masses and mixings. The charged fermion mass hierarchy and the quark mixing pattern is generated by the spontaneous breaking of the discrete symmetries due to flavons that act as Froggatt-Nielsen fields. The tiny neutrino masses arise from a radiative seesaw mechanism at one loop level, thanks to a preserved {Z}_2^{(1)} discrete symmetry, which also leads to stable scalar and fermionic dark matter candidates. The leptonic sector features the predictive cobimaximal mixing pattern, consistent with the experimental data from neutrino oscillations. For the scenario of normal neutrino mass hierarchy, the model predicts an effective Majorana neutrino mass parameter in the range 3 meV ≲ mββ ≲ 18 meV, which is within the declared range of sensitivity of modern experiments. The model predicts Flavour Changing Neutral Currents which constrain the model, for instance, μ→e nuclear conversion processes and Kaon mixing are found to be within the reach of the forthcoming experiments.

Electric dipole moments in the extended scotogenic models

Electric dipole moments (EDMs) of charged leptons arise from a new source of CP violation in the lepton sector. In this paper, we calculate the EDMs of the charged leptons in the minimal scotogenic model with two singlet fermions, and the models extended with one or two triplet fermions instead of the singlet fermions, taking into account the constraints of the neutrino oscillation data, the charged lepton flavor violation and perturbative unitarity bound for the Yukawa couplings. We show that the hybrid model with one singlet and one triplet fermions predicts an electron EDM larger than the other models in both normal and inverted neutrino mass hierarchy. We find some parameter space has already been ruled out by the current upper bound of the electron EDM and further parameter space can be explored by future experiments.

Bounds on the triplet fermions in type-III seesaw and implications for collider searches

Type-III seesaw is a simple extension of the Standard Model (SM) with the SU(2)L triplet fermion with zero hypercharge. It can explain the origin of the tiny neutrino mass and flavor mixing. After the electroweak symmetry breaking the light neutrino mass is generated by the seesaw mechanism which further ensures the mixings between the light neutrino and heavy neutral lepton mass eigenstates. If the triplet fermions are around the electroweak scale having sizable mixings with the SM sector allowed by the correct gauge symmetry, they can be produced at the high energy colliders leaving a variety of characteristic signatures. Based on a simple and concrete realizations of the model we employ a general parametrization for the neutrino Dirac mass matrix and perform a parameter scan to identify the allowed regions satisfying the experimental constraints from the neutrino oscillation data, the electroweak precision measurements and the lepton-flavor violating processes, respectively considering the normal and inverted neutrino mass hierarchies. These parameter regions can be probed at the different collider experiments.

Towards unification of quark and lepton flavors in A_4 modular invariance

We study quark and lepton mass matrices in the A_4 modular symmetry towards the unification of the quark and lepton flavors. We adopt modular forms of weights 2 and 6 for quarks and charged leptons, while we use modular forms of weight 4 for the neutrino mass matrix which is generated by the Weinberg operator. We obtain the successful quark mass matrices, in which the down-type quark mass matrix is constructed by modular forms of weight 2, but the up-type quark mass matrix is constructed by modular forms of weight 6. The viable region of tau is close to tau =i. Lepton mass matrices also work well at nearby tau =i, which overlaps with the one of the quark sector, for the normal hierarchy of neutrino masses. In the common tau region for quarks and leptons, the predicted sum of neutrino masses is 87–120 meV taking account of its cosmological bound. Since both the Dirac CP phase delta _{CP}^ell and sin ^2theta _{23} are correlated with the sum of neutrino masses, improving its cosmological bound provides crucial tests for our scheme as well as the precise measurement of sin ^2theta _{23} and delta _{CP}^ell . The effective neutrino mass of the 0nu beta beta decay is langle m_{ee}rangle =15–31 meV. It is remarked that the modulus tau is fixed at nearby tau =i in the fundamental domain of SL(2, Z), which suggests the residual symmetry Z_2 in the quark and lepton mass matrices. The inverted hierarchy of neutrino masses is excluded by the cosmological bound of the sum of neutrino masses.

SU(3)C×SU(3)L×U(1)X model from SU(6)

We propose the $SU(3)_C\times SU(3)_L\times U(1)_X$ model arising from $SU(6)$ breaking. One family of the Standard Model (SM) fermions arises from two $\bar{6}$ representations and one $15$ representation of $SU(6)$ gauge symmetry. To break the $SU(3)_C\times SU(3)_L\times U(1)_X$ gauge symmetry down to the SM, we introduce three $SU(3)_L$ triplet Higgs fields, where two of them come from the $\bar{6}$ representation while the other one from the $15$ representation. We study the gauge boson masses and Higgs boson mass in detail, and find that the vacuum expectation value (VEV) of the Higgs field for $SU(3)_L\times U(1)_X$ gauge symmetry breaking is around 10 TeV. The neutrino masses and mixing can be generated via the littlest inverse seesaw mechanism. In particular, we have normal hierarchy for neutrino masses and the lightest active neutrino is massless. Also, we consider constraints from the charged lepton flavor changing decays as well. Furthermore, introducing two $SU(3)_L$ adjoint fermions, one $SU(3)_C$ adjoint scalar, and one $SU(3)_L$ triplet scalar, we can achieve gauge coupling unification within 1\%. These extra particles can provide a dark matter candidate as well.

String landscape and fermion masses

Besides the string scale, string theory has no parameter except some quantized flux values; and the string theory Landscape is generated by scanning over discrete values of all the flux parameters present. We propose that a typical (normalized) probability distribution $P({\cal Q})$ of a physical quantity $\cal Q$ (with nonnegative dimension) tends to peak (diverge) at ${\cal Q}=0$ as a signature of string theory. In the Racetrack K\"ahler uplift model, where $P(\Lambda)$ of the cosmological constant $\Lambda$ peaks sharply at $\Lambda=0$, the electroweak scale (not the electroweak model) naturally emerges when the median $\Lambda$ is matched to the observed value. We check the robustness of this scenario. In a bottom-up approach, we find that the observed quark and charged lepton masses are consistent with the same probabilistic philosophy, with distribution $P(m)$ that diverges at $m=0$, with the same (or almost the same) degree of divergence. This suggests that the Standard Model has an underlying string theory description, and yields relations among the fermion masses, albeit in a probabilistic approach (very different from the usual sense). Along this line of reasoning, the normal hierarchy of neutrino masses is clearly preferred over the inverted hierarchy, and the sum of the neutrino masses is predicted to be $\sum m_{\nu} \simeq 0.0592$ eV, with an upper bound $\sum m_{\nu} <0.066$ eV. This illustrates a novel way string theory can be applied to particle physics phenomenology.

Higgs Parity grand unification

The vanishing of the Higgs quartic coupling of the Standard Model at high energies may be explained by spontaneous breaking of Higgs Parity. Taking Higgs Parity to originate from the Left-Right symmetry of the SO(10) gauge group, leads to a new scheme for precision gauge coupling unification that is consistent with proton decay. We compute the relevant running of couplings and threshold corrections to allow a precise correlation among Standard Model parameters. The scheme has a built-in solution for obtaining a realistic value for mb/mτ , which further improves the precision from gauge coupling unification, allowing the QCD coupling constant to be predicted to the level of 1% or, alternatively, the top quark mass to 0.2%. Future measurements of these parameters may significantly constrain the detailed structure of the theory. We also study an SO(10) embedding of quark and lepton masses, showing how large neutrino mixing is compatible with small quark mixing, and predict a normal neutrino mass hierarchy. The strong CP problem may be explained by combining Higgs Parity with space-time parity.

First measurement of neutrino oscillation parameters using neutrinos and antineutrinos by NOvA.

The NOvA experiment has seen a 4.4σ signal of ν[over ¯]_{e} appearance in a 2GeV ν[over ¯]_{μ} beam at a distance of 810km. Using 12.33×10^{20} protons on target delivered to the Fermilab NuMI neutrino beamline, the experiment recorded 27 ν[over ¯]_{μ}→ν[over ¯]_{e} candidates with a background of 10.3 and 102 ν[over ¯]_{μ}→ν[over ¯]_{μ} candidates. This new antineutrino data are combined with neutrino data to measure the parameters |Δm_{32}^{2}|=2.48_{-0.06}^{+0.11}×10^{-3} eV^{2}/c^{4} and sin^{2}θ_{23} in the ranges from (0.53-0.60) and (0.45-0.48) in the normal neutrino mass hierarchy. The data exclude most values near δ_{CP}=π/2 for the inverted mass hierarchy by more than 3σ and favor the normal neutrino mass hierarchy by 1.9σ and θ_{23} values in the upper octant by 1.6σ.