Non-enzymatic RNA Replication Research Articles

Effect of Co-solutes on Template-Directed Nonenzymatic Replication of Nucleic Acids.

The widely acknowledged 'RNA world' theory pertains to how life might have chemically originated on early Earth. It presumes the existence of catalytic RNAs, which were also capable of storing and propagating genetic information. Substantial research has gone into understanding how enzyme-free reactions of nucleic acids might have led to the formation of such catalytic RNA polymers. However, most of these studies involved reactions that were performed in aqueous systems devoid of any "background" molecules. This scenario is not a true representation of the complex chemical environment that might have been prevalent on prebiotic Earth. In the present study, we analyzed the effect of co-solutes ("background" molecules) on the rate and accuracy of template-directed nonenzymatic replication of RNA, in a putative RNA world. Our results suggest that presence of co-solutes in the reaction affects the addition of purine monomers across their cognate template base. Reduction in the rate of these 'fast' cognate addition reactions resulted in an apparent increase in the frequency of mismatches in the presence of co-solutes. However, reactions that involved the addition of a mismatched base were not notably affected. Such a scenario could have led to an accrual of mutations during the propagation of functional sequences on early Earth, unless the relevant sequences were separated from the bulk reaction milieu by some limiting boundary structure (e.g., a membrane). In general, our results suggest that the presence of co-solutes could have affected certain prebiotic reaction rates to a larger extent than others. Even modest changes in nonenzymatic replication reaction rates could have eventually resulted in the accumulation of greater variation in RNA sequences over prolonged time periods. It, therefore, is pertinent to account for the chemical complexity intrinsic to prebiotic environments while studying relevant nonenzymatic reactions.

Uncovering the thermodynamics of monomer binding for RNA replication.

The nonenzymatic replication of primordial RNA is thought to have been a critical step in the origin of life. However, despite decades of effort, the poor rate and fidelity of model template copying reactions have thus far prevented an experimental demonstration of nonenzymatic RNA replication. The overall rate and fidelity of template copying depend, in part, on the affinity of free ribonucleotides to the RNA primer–template complex. We have now used 1H NMR spectroscopy to directly measure the thermodynamic association constants, Kas, of the standard ribonucleotide monophosphates (rNMPs) to native RNA primer–template complexes. The binding affinities of rNMPs to duplexes with a complementary single-nucleotide overhang follow the order C > G > A > U. Notably, these monomers bind more strongly to RNA primer–template complexes than to the analogous DNA complexes. The relative binding affinities of the rNMPs for complementary RNA primer–template complexes are in good quantitative agreement with the predictions of a nearest-neighbor analysis. With respect to G:U wobble base-pairing, we find that the binding of rGMP to a primer–template complex with a 5′-U overhang is approximately 10-fold weaker than to the complementary 5′-C overhang. We also find that the binding of rGMP is only about 2-fold weaker than the binding of rAMP to 5′-U, consistent with the poor fidelity observed in the nonenzymatic copying of U residues in RNA templates. The accurate Ka measurements for ribonucleotides obtained in this study will be useful for designing higher fidelity, more effective RNA replication systems.

Structural insights into the effects of 2′-5′ linkages on the RNA duplex

The mixture of 2'-5' and 3'-5' linkages generated during the nonenzymatic replication of RNA has long been regarded as a central problem for the origin of the RNA world. However, we recently observed that both a ribozyme and an RNA aptamer retain considerable functionality in the presence of prebiotically plausible levels of linkage heterogeneity. To better understand the RNA structure and function in the presence of backbone linkage heterogeneity, we obtained high-resolution X-ray crystal structures of a native 10-mer RNA duplex (1.32 Å) and two variants: one containing one 2'-5' linkage per strand (1.55 Å) and one containing three such linkages per strand (1.20 Å). We found that RNA duplexes adjust their local structures to accommodate the perturbation caused by 2'-5' linkages, with the flanking nucleotides buffering the disruptive effects of the isomeric linkage and resulting in a minimally altered global structure. Although most 2'-linked sugars were in the expected 2'-endo conformation, some were partially or fully in the 3'-endo conformation, suggesting that the energy difference between these conformations was relatively small. Our structural and molecular dynamic studies also provide insight into the diminished thermal and chemical stability of the duplex state associated with the presence of 2'-5' linkages. Our results contribute to the view that a low level of 2'-5' substitution would not have been fatal in an early RNA world and may in contrast have been helpful for both the emergence of nonenzymatic RNA replication and the early evolution of functional RNAs.

Functional RNAs exhibit tolerance for non-heritable 2'-5' versus 3'-5' backbone heterogeneity.

A plausible process for non-enzymatic RNA replication would greatly simplify models of the transition from prebiotic chemistry to simple biology. However, all known conditions for the chemical copying of an RNA template result in the synthesis of a complementary strand that contains a mixture of 2'-5' and 3'-5' linkages, rather than the selective synthesis of only 3'-5' linkages as found in contemporary RNA. Here we show that such backbone heterogeneity is compatible with RNA folding into defined three-dimensional structures that retain molecular recognition and catalytic properties and, therefore, would not prevent the evolution of functional RNAs such as ribozymes. Moreover, the same backbone heterogeneity lowers the melting temperature of RNA duplexes that would otherwise be too stable for thermal strand separation. By allowing copied strands to dissociate, this heterogeneity may have been one of the essential features that allowed RNA to emerge as the first biopolymer.

Synthesis of N3′-P5′-linked Phosphoramidate DNA by Nonenzymatic Template-Directed Primer Extension

A fast and accurate pathway for nonenzymatic RNA replication would simplify models for the emergence of the RNA world from the prebiotic chemistry of the early earth. However, numerous difficulties stand in the way of an experimental demonstration of effective nonenzymatic RNA replication. To gain insight into the necessary properties of potentially self-replicating informational polymers, we have studied several model systems based on amino–sugar nucleotides. Here we describe the synthesis of N3′–P5′-linked phosphoramidate DNA (3′-NP-DNA) by the template-directed polymerization of activated 3′-amino-2′,3′-dideoxyribonucleotides. 3′-NP-DNA is an interesting model because of its very RNA-like A-type duplex conformation and because activated 3′-amino-2′,3′-dideoxyribonucleotides are much more reactive than the corresponding activated ribonucleotides. In contrast to our previous studies with 2′-amino-2′,3′-dideoxyribonucleotides (for which G and C but not A and T exhibit efficient template copying), we have found that all four canonical 3′-amino-2′,3′-dideoxyribonucleotides (G, C, A, and T) polymerize efficiently on RNA templates. RNA templates are generally superior to DNA templates, and oligo-ribo-T templates are superior to oligo-ribo-U templates, which are the least efficient of the RNA homopolymer templates. We have also found that activation of 3′-aminonucleotides with 2-methylimidazole results in a ca. 10-fold higher polymerization rate relative to activation with imidazole, an observation that parallels earlier findings with ribonucleotides. We discuss the implications of our experiments for the possibility of self-replication in the 3′-NP-DNA and RNA systems.

6 Crystal structure studies of RNA molecules containing 2′–5′-linkages

RNA can play dual roles as a carrier of genetic information and as a catalyst of specific reactions, and it may have been the first biopolymer to have emerged on the early earth. The non-enzymatic replication of RNA was likely a key step in the evolution of simple cellular life from prebiotic chemistry. In the current model of template-directed polymerization of activated monomers, the chemical copying of RNA always generates a mixture of 3′–5′ and 2′–5′ backbone linkages due to the similar nucleophilicity and orientation of the 2′ and 3′ hydroxyl groups on the ribose. This lack of regiospecificity has been regarded as a central problem for the evolution of functional RNAs, since the resulting backbone heterogeneity was expected to disrupt their folding, molecular recognition and catalytic properties of functional RNAs such as ribozymes. However, a recent study from our lab has demonstrated that RNAs with a certain percentage of 2′–5′ linkages can still retain RNA functions, for example, in a FMN-binding aptamer and a hammerhead ribozyme system. More interestingly, it has been known for a long time that 2′–5′ linkages can reduce the melting temperature of RNA duplexes, making it easier to separate the strands. Although the detailed mechanism is still not clear, considering that strand separation is another unsolved big problem for non-enzymatic RNA replication, this feature may actually afford a selective advantage to duplexes exhibiting backbone heterogeneity. In addition, previous studies have revealed that 2′–5′ linkages in a RNA duplex are more easily hydrolyzed compared to normal 3′–5′ linkages. Thus, there is a selective advantage for the evolution of homogeneous RNA systems with more accurate replication. Altogether, the coexistence of 2′–5′ and 3′–5′ linkages may be a central feature that allowed RNA to play a central role in the original stage of life. In this work, we will present several X-ray crystal structures of RNA duplexes and an aptamer that contain 2′–5′ linkages. These structures help us to understand how RNA can adjust its structure to accommodate the backbone heterogeneity.

4 Towards non-enzymatic RNA replication

The direct path from prebiotic chemistry to the RNA World requires a plausible route for the synthesis of activated ribonucleotides and RNA templates, along with a means for the complete replication of potentially useful RNA sequences. However, many apparent roadblocks make non-enzymatic RNA replication look quite difficult, if not impossible. These problems include the slow rate, low accuracy and poor regioselectivity of non-enzymatic template copying, the hydrolysis of activated monomers and absence of good re-activation chemistry, the difficulty of strand separation after template copying, the rapidity of strand reannealing, the absence of primers in any realistic replication scenario, and the apparent incompatibly of RNA copying chemistry (which requires a high Mg2+ concentration) with fatty acid-based protocell membranes, which are destroyed by low Mg2+ concentrations. I will discuss recent progress from my laboratory on four of these issues. We have found that functional RNAs such as aptamers and ribozymes can tolerate moderate levels of 2′–5′ linkages without great loss of activity. It therefore appears that the presence of 10–25% of such linkages in the products of non-enzymatic copying would not prevent the evolution of functional RNAs. Furthermore, 2′–5′ linkages can be helpful, as they decrease the melting temperature of RNA duplexes enough to allow strand separation to occur under geophysically plausible conditions. Recently, we have found that small chemical changes to the nucleobases can greatly increase the fidelity of non-enzymatic template copying, and we have found conditions that render RNA copying chemistry compatible with vesicle integrity, thereby allowing RNA copying to occur inside fatty acid-based model protocell membranes. I will discuss potential approaches to solving the remaining issues that stand in the way of complete RNA replication. If all of the problems with RNA replication can be overcome, it should be possible to construct functioning protocells in the laboratory.

5 Efficient and high-fidelity copying of an RNA-like model prebiotic system

Nonenzymatic RNA replication would provide an important bridge to the RNA world. However, the demonstration of efficient and high-fidelity copying chemistry remains a great experimental challenge. It requires an efficient mechanism that can lead to both a high rate of polymerization and a high degree of fidelity in the copying chemistry. Previous experiments concerning nonenzymatic template-directed synthesis of RNA with activated monomers have led to the copying of short RNA templates, but these reactions are generally slow (taking days to weeks) and highly error-prone. Therefore, the ability to efficiently and accurately copy arbitrary template sequences remains frustratingly out of reach. N3′-P5′-linked phosphoramidate DNA is a highly reactive model for self-replicating genetic materials and has been used for studies of nonenzymatic RNA self-replication. It is also an excellent RNA mimic, due to its similar overall duplex structure, rigidity, and level of hydration (Tereshko, Gryaznov, & Egli, 1998). Our experiments show that the high reactivity imparted by the presence of an amino nucleophile allows rapid and efficient copying of all four nucleobases on both homopolymeric and mixed templates. On the other hand, G:T wobble pairing leads to a high error rate. We have, therefore, investigated the use of the modified nucleobase, 2-thio T (Ts) (Sintim & Kool, 2006), to suppress formation of the G:T wobble base-pair. Our results illustrate that the 2-thio modification can both increase polymerization rate and enhance fidelity in this self-replicating N3′-P5′-DNA system. These results suggest that this simple nucleobase modification may have played a role in primordial RNA (or proto-RNA) replication. In addition to suppressing the G:T mismatch, an additional benefit gained from its stronger base-pairing with A is that it also reduces A:C mismatch formation. Thus, simple modifications of nucleobases might provide a means of suppressing mismatches to yield better fidelity. Taken together, our results show that a high rate of polymerization and a high degree of fidelity are not mutually exclusive, but can be achieved simultaneously in nonenzymatic copying of N3′-P5′-linked phosphoramidate DNA. The structural similarity of NP-DNA to RNA suggests that these results could be translated to an RNA-only system.

A Polymer Reaction Engineering Approach to Polynucleotide Replication

AbstractIt is often interesting to look at specific scientific questions from the perspective of other, related technologies. The problem of nonenzymatic RNA replication can be viewed from the perspective of classical polymer science and with some interesting insights. This communication will show that current mechanism of stalling, which is used to account for the fact that the rate of insertion errors in nonenzymatic RNA replication are much lower than would be expected, can be modeled by using the Mayo–Lewis equation for calculating copolymer composition in copolymerizations of synthetic polymers. Using kinetic parameters from the literature, it is possible to independently predict the error threshold for RNA replication. Agreement with the accepted model for nonenzymatic replication is surprisingly good. magnified image

The eightfold path to non-enzymatic RNA replication

The first RNA World models were based on the concept of an RNA replicase - a ribozyme that was a good enough RNA polymerase that it could catalyze its own replication. Although several RNA polymerase ribozymes have been evolved in vitro, the creation of a true replicase remains a great experimental challenge. At first glance the alternative, in which RNA replication is driven purely by chemical and physical processes, seems even more challenging, given that so many unsolved problems appear to stand in the way of repeated cycles of non-enzymatic RNA replication. Nevertheless the idea of non-enzymatic RNA replication is attractive, because it implies that the first heritable functional RNA need not have improved replication, but could have been a metabolic ribozyme or structural RNA that conferred any function that enhanced protocell reproduction or survival. In this review, I discuss recent findings that suggest that chemically driven RNA replication may not be completely impossible.

Activated ribonucleotides undergo a sugar pucker switch upon binding to a single-stranded RNA template.

Template-directed polymerization of chemically activated ribonucleotide monomers, such as nucleotide 5′-phosphorimidazolides, has been studied as a model for nonenzymatic RNA replication during the origin of life. Kinetic studies of the polymerization of various nucleotide monomers on oligonucleotide templates have suggested that the A-form (C3′-endo sugar pucker) conformation is optimal for both monomers and templates for efficient copying. However, RNA monomers are predominantly in the C2′-endo conformation when free in solution, except for cytidine, which is approximately equally distributed between the C2′-endo and C3′-endo conformations. We hypothesized that ribonucleotides undergo a switch in sugar pucker upon binding to an A-type template and that this conformational switch allows or enhances subsequent polymerization. We used transferred nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (TrNOESY), which can be used for specific detection of the bound conformation of small-molecule ligands with relatively weak affinity to receptors, to study the interactions between nucleotide 5′-phosphorimidazolides and single-stranded oligonucleotide templates. We found that the sugar pucker of activated ribonucleotides switches from C2′-endo in the free state to C3′-endo upon binding to an RNA template. This switch occurs only on RNA and not on DNA templates. Furthermore, activated 2′-deoxyribonucleotides maintain a C2′-endo sugar pucker in both the free and template-bound states. Our results provide a structural explanation for the observations that activated ribonucleotides are superior to activated deoxyribonucleotides and that RNA templates are superior to DNA templates in template-directed nonenzymatic primer-extension reactions.

Primordial soup or vinaigrette: did the RNA world evolve at acidic pH?

BackgroundThe RNA world concept has wide, though certainly not unanimous, support within the origin-of-life scientific community. One view is that life may have emerged as early as the Hadean Eon 4.3-3.8 billion years ago with an atmosphere of high CO2 producing an acidic ocean of the order of pH 3.5-6. Compatible with this scenario is the intriguing proposal that life arose within alkaline (pH 9-11) deep-sea hydrothermal vents like those of the 'Lost City', with the interface with the acidic ocean creating a proton gradient sufficient to drive the first metabolism. However, RNA is most stable at pH 4-5 and is unstable at alkaline pH, raising the possibility that RNA may have first arisen in the acidic ocean itself (possibly near an acidic hydrothermal vent), acidic volcanic lake or comet pond. As the Hadean Eon progressed, the ocean pH is inferred to have gradually risen to near neutral as atmospheric CO2 levels decreased.Presentation of the hypothesisWe propose that RNA is well suited for a world evolving at acidic pH. This is supported by the enhanced stability at acidic pH of not only the RNA phosphodiester bond but also of the aminoacyl-(t)RNA and peptide bonds. Examples of in vitro-selected ribozymes with activities at acid pH have recently been documented. The subsequent transition to a DNA genome could have been partly driven by the gradual rise in ocean pH, since DNA has greater stability than RNA at alkaline pH, but not at acidic pH.Testing the hypothesisWe have proposed mechanisms for two key RNA world activities that are compatible with an acidic milieu: (i) non-enzymatic RNA replication of a hemi-protonated cytosine-rich oligonucleotide, and (ii) specific aminoacylation of tRNA/hairpins through triple helix interactions between the helical aminoacyl stem and a single-stranded aminoacylating ribozyme.Implications of the hypothesisOur hypothesis casts doubt on the hypothesis that RNA evolved in the vicinity of alkaline hydrothermal vents. The ability of RNA to form protonated base pairs and triples at acidic pH suggests that standard base pairing may not have been a dominant requirement of the early RNA world.ReviewersThis article was reviewed by Eugene Koonin, Anthony Poole and Charles Carter (nominated by David Ardell).

Nonenzymatic Oligomerization of Ribonucleotides on Guanosine‐Rich Templates: Suppression of the Self‐Pairing of Guanosine

Acridine-labeled primers have been shown to be a very valuable tool for the study of the template-directed oligomerization of RNA (shown schematically below). Conditions for the efficient incorporation of cytidine have been established by using such compounds. The aggregation of guanosine-rich templates, which has long been considered a major obstacle for nonenzymatic replication of RNA, can thus be reduced to a minimum.

Isolation of a ribozyme with 5′-5′ ligase activity

Background: Many new ribozymes, including sequence-specific nucleases, ligases and kinases, have been isolated by in vitro selection from large pools of random-sequence RNAs. We are attempting to use in vitro selection to isolate new ribozymes that have, or can be evolved to have, RNA polymerase-like activities. As phosphorimidazolide-activated nucleosides are extensively used to study non-enzymatic RNA replication, we wished to select for a ribozyme that would accelerate the template-directed ligation of 5′-phosphorimidazolide-activated oligonucleotides. Results: Ribozymes selected to perform the desired template-directed ligation reaction instead ligated themselves to the activated substrate oligonucleotide via their 5′-triphosphate, generating a 5′-5′ P 1,P 4-tetraphosphate linkage. Deletion analysis of one of the selected sequences revealed that a 54-nucleotide RNA retained activity; this small ribozyme folds into a pseudoknot secondary structure with an internal binding site for the substrate oligonucleotide. The ribozyme can also synthesize 5′-5′ triphosphate and 5′-5′ pyrophosphate linkages. Conclusions: The emergence of ribozymes that accelerate an unexpected 5′-5′ ligation reaction from a selection designed to yield template-dependent 3′-5′ ligases suggests that it may be much easier for RNA to catalyze the synthesis of 5′-5′ linkages than 3′-5′ linkages. 5′-5′ linkages are found in a variety of contexts in present-day biology. The ribozyme-catalyzed synthesis of such linkages raises the possibility that these 5′-5′ linkages originated in the biochemistry of the RNA world.