To the Editor: Geographical foci of two kinds of spastic paraparesis have been described in Zaire in the last few years: HTLV-I-associated myelopathy/tropical spastic paraparesis (HAM/TSP) (1-3) and konzo (4-7). The HTLV-I-associated myelopathy is characterized by gradual onset and progressive course, whereas konzo is clinically different with a sudden onset and a nonprogressive course. Konzo mainly affects women of child-bearing age and children. Epidemiological studies in four African countries show an association to exclusive consumption of insufficiently processed cassava. This leads to a high dietary cyanide intake combined with low intake of sulfur amino acids that provide the sulfur substrate necessary for detoxification of cyanide to thiocyanate (7). An etiological role of retroviral infection in konzo has also been suggested (4), and one report suggests that cyanide exposure may trigger the myelopathic effects of HTLV-I infection (3). We have investigated possible associations between konzo and retroviral infection in two previously described konzo foci in Zaire, situated 300- and 400 km east of the capital Kinshasa in the Bandundu region (5,6). The diagnostic criteria for konzo were (a) a visible symmetric spastic abnormality of gait while walking or running, (b) a history of onset in <1 week followed by a nonprogressive course in a formerly healthy person, and (c) bilaterally exaggerated knee or ankle jerks without signs of disease of the spine (5). Lathyrism (8) was excluded because grass pea (Lathyrus sativus) was not consumed in the areas. With informed consent, blood was obtained from 30 of 35 konzo cases in one village and from 93 eligible healthy controls from 39 randomly selected households in two villages in the first area, and from 3 of 7 konzo cases and 16 eligible healthy controls from 8 randomly selected households in one village in the second area. In total, 13 male and 20 female patients aged 10 to 56 years (median 19) and 109 healthy controls (53 males and 56 females) aged 4 to 68 years (median 30) were included in the study. Serum samples were tested for the presence of HIV-1 antibodies with two different ELISA kits: Wellcozyme HIV-1 (Wellcome Diagnostics, Dartford, England) and Abbott anti-HIV-1 (North Chicago, IL, U.S.A.) (first area) or Enzygnost anti-HIV-1 + 2 (Behring, Marburg, Germany) (second area). All samples were further tested by HIV-1 Western blot kit (Dupont, Wilmington, DE, U.S.A.). We used the WHO criteria for HIV-1 Western blot seropositivity requiring reactivity with at least two envelope bands (9). Screening for antibodies to HTLV-I was performed with Abbott/Anti-HTLV-I ELISA, and reactive sera were further tested by an HTLV-I Western blot assay including recombinant glycoproteins, rgp46, and rgp21 (Diagnostics Biotechnology, Singapore). Reactivity with one envelope protein and one gag-encoded protein was required for HTLV-I Western blot seropositivity. All 142 sera tested were negative for HIV-1 antibodies on ELISA. None of the sera fulfilled the criteria for a positive HIV-1 Western blot reaction because there was no reactivity with the HIV-1 envelope glycoproteins. However, reactivity against the HIV-1 gag-encoded proteins p17 and p24 was seen in 41 of the 142 tested subjects, but there was no difference in frequency between konzo patients and controls (Table 1). None of the subjects had antibodies to HTLV, but three sera from subjects in the control group showed indeterminate reactions on HTLV-I Western blot. Of the 3,700 konzo cases reported from Africa in the literature (10), 128 patients from five foci have been tested to date (4,11-13), and all were found negative for retroviral antibodies (110 were tested for HTLV-I, 13 for HTLV-II, 128 for HIV-1, and 77 for HIV-2). In addition, we found no relation between konzo and gag-encoded protein reactivity. It is therefore unlikely that any human retrovirus should be important in the etiology of konzo. We conclude that human retroviruses are not involved in the causation of konzo. T. Tylleskär; *M. Banea; †B. Böttiger; †R. Thorstensson; †G. Biberfeld; H. Rosling Unit for International Child Health; Department of Pediatrics; Uppsala University; Uppsala, Sweden *CEPLANUT (Centre National de Planification de Nutrition Humaine); Ministry of Health; Kinshasa, Zaire †Department of Immunology; Swedish Institute for Infectious Disease Control; Stockholm, Sweden
Read full abstract