We examine the onset of classical topological order in a nearest neighbour kagome icemodel. Using Monte Carlo simulations, we characterize the topological sectors of theground state using a nonlocal cut measure which circumscribes the toroidal geometry of thesimulation cell. We demonstrate that simulations which employ global loop updates thatare allowed to wind around the periodic boundaries cause the topological sector tofluctuate, while restricted local loop updates freeze the simulation into one topologicalsector. The freezing into one topological sector can also be observed in the susceptibility ofthe real magnetic spin vectors projected onto the kagome plane. The ability of thesusceptibility to distinguish between fluctuating and non-fluctuating topological sectorsshould motivate its use as a local probe of topological order in a variety of related systems.