We report a tremendous structural evolution of carbon nanosheets (CNSs) through the graphenization of isotropic pitches prepared by reforming commercially available naphtha cracking bottom oil. CNSs with thicknesses of 2–13 nm were prepared by spin-coating on quartz substrates directly without a catalytic material, followed by two successive thermal treatments consisting of stabilization at 270 °C in air and carbonization at up to 1200 °C in H2/Ar. The development of well-ordered graphene layers around pebble-like structures with increasing carbonization temperature was observed in only the 13-nm thick CNSs by transmission electron microscopy, whereas thin CNSs did not reveal well-developed fringe growth. In addition, Raman, UV–vis, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopies along with mass spectrometry unanimously showed clear evidence indicating that unusually well-developed crystalline structure was formed in the thick CNSs. It should be noted that isotropic pitches, which are intrinsically non-graphitizable carbon sources, evolved into highly ordered structures at a relatively low carbonization temperature (1200 °C). We believe that the graphenization of spin-coated films of pitch molecules resulted from the condensation of small pitch molecules and their self-assembled structure during carbonization under the anisotropic pressure induced by significant shrinkage in the vertical axis.