The concept of a breathing crack and the clapping mechanism, when a crack periodically opens and closes subject to a cyclic or harmonic excitation, are widely utilised in studies concerning contact acoustic nonlinearity (CAN) and nonlinear phenomena. The investigation of these phenomena is particularly important for the development of reliable non-destructive fatigue crack detection techniques. The aim of the current contribution is to demonstrate the characteristic behaviour of a fatigue crack under excitation loading using a simple analytical model that accounts for the wake of plasticity behind the crack tip, which leads to the plasticity-induced fatigue crack closure phenomenon. It is believed that incorporation of these features and more realistic behaviour of fatigue cracks can help to improve the methods for the detection of nonlinear phenomena associated with CAN. The results of the present work indicate that ultrasonic inspections based on the CAN using a bilinear stiffness model may underestimate the length of the detected crack(s) due to the plasticity-induced crack closure phenomenon. Despite many modelling assumptions, the present work can serve as a starting point for the development of accurate models for different crack geometries and load histories. The latter may help to develop effective nondestructive techniques for detection and identification of fatigue cracks and prevention of fatigue failures.