Non-crystallographic Symmetry Averaging Research Articles

Structure determination of adeno-associated virus 2: three complete virus particles per asymmetric unit.

The atomic structure of adeno-associated virus 2 (AAV-2) has been determined to 3.0 A resolution. AAV-2 crystallized in space group P1, with unit-cell parameters a = 249.7, b = 249.7, c = 644.8 A, alpha = 90.0, beta = 101.2, gamma = 120.0 degrees. The crystals contained three full virus particles in the asymmetric unit, allowing 180-fold non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The particle orientations were determined using the self-rotation function and found to have similar but resolvably different orientations. Approximate alignment of icosahedral and interparticle threefold screw symmetry led to a native Patterson that was interpretable in terms of approximate particle positions. Accurate positions required a Patterson correlation search that was constrained to be consistent with non-crystallographic threefold projection symmetry evident in the diffraction intensities. Initial phases to 15.0 A resolution were calculated by molecular replacement using the known structure of a distantly related homolog (23% sequence identity). Real-space averaging was performed and phases were extended from 15.0 to 3.0 A. An atomic model was fitted and refined using a simulated-annealing real-space procedure.

Crystal Structure of Decameric Fructose-6-Phosphate Aldolase from Escherichia coli Reveals Inter-subunit Helix Swapping as a Structural Basis for Assembly Differences in the Transaldolase Family

Fructose-6-phosphate aldolase from Escherichia coli is a member of a small enzyme subfamily (MipB/TalC family) that belongs to the class I aldolases. The three-dimensional structure of this enzyme has been determined at 1.93 Å resolution by single isomorphous replacement and tenfold non-crystallographic symmetry averaging and refined to an R-factor of 19.9% ( R free 21.3%). The subunit folds into an α/β barrel, with the catalytic lysine residue on barrel strand β4. It is very similar in overall structure to that of bacterial and mammalian transaldolases, although more compact due to extensive deletions of additional secondary structural elements. The enzyme forms a decamer of identical subunits with point group symmetry 52. Five subunits are arranged as a pentamer, and two ring-like pentamers pack like a doughnut to form the decamer. A major interaction within the pentamer is through the C-terminal helix from one monomer, which runs across the active site of the neighbouring subunit. In classical transaldolases, this helix folds back and covers the active site of the same subunit and is involved in dimer formation. The inter-subunit helix swapping appears to be a major determinant for the formation of pentamers rather than dimers while at the same time preserving importing interactions of this helix with the active site of the enzyme. The active site lysine residue is covalently modified, by forming a carbinolamine with glyceraldehyde from the crystallisation mixture. The catalytic machinery is very similar to that of transaldolase, which together with the overall structural similarity suggests that enzymes of the MipB/TALC subfamily are evolutionary related to the transaldolase family.

Structure determination of the constitutive 20S proteasome from bovine liver at 2.75 A resolution.

The crystal structure of the 20S proteasome from bovine liver was determined by the molecular replacement method using the structure of the 20S proteasome from the yeast Sacccharomyces cerevisiae. The initial phases were refined by density modification coupled with non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The structural model was refined with the program CNS. The final R-factor and R(free) were 0.25 and 0.29, respectively. The constitutive proteasome without any contamination by the immunoproteasome was identified in the crystal structure.

Structure determination of the head-tail connector of bacteriophage phi29.

The head-tail connector of bacteriophage phi29 is composed of 12 36 kDa subunits with 12-fold symmetry. It is the central component of a rotary motor that packages the genomic dsDNA into preformed proheads. This motor consists of the head-tail connector, surrounded by a phi29-encoded, 174-base, RNA and a viral ATPase protein, both of which have fivefold symmetry in three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy reconstructions. DNA is translocated into the prohead through a 36 A diameter pore in the center of the connector, where the DNA takes the role of a motor spindle. The helical nature of the DNA allows the rotational action of the connector to be transformed into a linear translation of the DNA. The crystal structure determination of connector crystals in space group C2 was initiated by molecular replacement, using an approximately 20 A resolution model derived from cryo-electron microscopy. The model phases were extended to 3.5 A resolution using 12-fold non-crystallographic symmetry averaging and solvent flattening. Although this electron density was not interpretable, the phases were adequate to locate the position of 24 mercury sites of a thimerosal heavy-atom derivative. The resultant 3.2 A single isomorphous replacement phases were improved using density modification, producing an interpretable electron-density map. The crystallographically refined structure was used as a molecular-replacement model to solve the structures of two other crystal forms of the connector molecule. One of these was in the same space group and almost isomorphous, whereas the other was in space group P2(1)2(1)2. The structural differences between the oligomeric connector molecules in the three crystal forms and between different monomers within each crystal show that the structure is relatively flexible, particularly in the protruding domain at the wide end of the connector. This domain probably acts as a bearing, allowing the connector to rotate within the pentagonal portal of the prohead during DNA packaging.

Structure analysis of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase at 2.8 A resolution.

The crystal structure of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase has been determined at 2.8 A resolution by the multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) method with three heavy-atom derivatives. An asymmetric unit of the crystal has a molecular weight of 422 kDa. Eight heavy atoms as main sites of a CH3HgCl derivative were clearly located by solving the difference Patterson function. The electron density obtained by the MIR method was refined by density modification, consisting of solvent flattening, histogram matching and non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The enzyme exhibits a dimeric structure in the crystal. Out of 3606 amino-acid residues in 26 subunits in the dimer, 3560 residues were located in the electron-density map. The structure was refined by X-PLOR. The final R factor and the free R factor were 0.199 and 0.252 at 2.8 A resolution, respectively. One monomer in the dimeric structure with a stronger packing interaction has a lower averaged temperature factor than the other, by 16 A2. The region +/-12 A from the centre of the transmembrane part is almost 100% alpha-helix, despite the glycine residue content being as high as 7.1% in the transmembrane region. The residues around haem a of animals have evolved away from those of bacteria in contrast with the residues of the haem a3. The hierarchy of the structural organization of the enzyme complex has been proposed on the basis of intersubunit interactions.

A low-resolution structure of rice dwarf virus determined by ab initio phasing.

Rice dwarf virus crystals belong to space group I222 with cell parameters a = 770 (2), b = 795 (5), c = 814 (5) A and alpha = beta = gamma = 90 degrees. The unit cell of the crystal contains two viruses at the origin and body-centred positions. Using data synthesized from a rice dwarf virus model crystal in the space group I222, the possibility of ab initio phasing was thoroughly examined. The centric nature of the initial phases was unexpectedly broken by extensive iteration of the non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The structure of rice dwarf virus was then solved with ab initio phasing up to 20 A resolution. The triangulation number determined by the present study is T = 13, which is different from the triangulation number, T = 9, previously determined by electron microscopy [Uyeda & Shikata (1982). Ann. Phytopathol. Soc. Jpn, 48, 295-300].

Structure determination of echovirus 1.

The atomic structure of echovirus 1 (a member of the enterovirus genus of the picornavirus family) has been determined using cryo-crystallography and refined to 3.55 A resolution. Echovirus 1 crystallizes in space group P22121 with a = 352.45, b = 472.15 and c = 483.20 A. The crystals contain one full virus particle in the asymmetric unit allowing for 60-fold noncrystallographic symmetry averaging. The diffraction pattern shows strong pseudo-B-centering with reflections with h + l = 2n + 1 being systematically weak or absent below about 6 A resolution. The size of the unit cell and presence of pseudo-B-centering placed strong constraints on the allowed packing of the icosahedral particle in the crystal lattice. These constraints greatly facilitated the determination of the orientation and position of the virus by reducing the dimensionality of the search, but interactions between the crystallographic and noncrystallographic symmetries rendered the choice of space group ambiguous until very late in the structure determination. This structure determination provides a striking example of the power of packing analysis in molecular replacement and illustrates how subtle interactions between crystallographic and noncrystallographic symmetries can be resolved.

Crystal structure of the lysozyme from bacteriophage lambda and its relationship with V and C-type lysozymes

Like other lysozymes, the bacteriophage lambda lysozyme is involved in the digestion of bacterial walls. This enzyme is remarkable in that its mechanism of action is different from the classical lysozyme’s mechanism. From the point of view of protein evolution, it shows features of lysozymes from different classes. The crystal structure of the enzyme in which all tryptophan residues have been replaced by aza-tryptophan has been solved by X-ray crystallography at 2.3 Å using a combination of multiple isomorphous replacement, non-crystallographic symmetry averaging and density modification techniques. There are three molecules in the asymmetric unit. The characteristic structural elements of lysozymes are conserved: each molecule is organized in two domains connected by a helix and the essential catalytic residue (Glu19) is located in the depth of a cleft between the two domains. This cleft shows an open conformation in two of the independent molecules, while access to the cavity is much more restricted in the last one. A structural alignment with T4 lysozyme and hen egg white lysozyme allows us to superpose about 60 C α atoms with a rms distance close to 2 Å. The best alignments concern the helix preceding the catalytic residue, some parts of the β sheets and the helix joining the two domains. The results of sequence alignments with the V and C lysozymes, in which weak local similarities had been detected, are compared with the structural results.

Experiences from the structure determination of human cytomegalovirus protease.

Several obstacles were encountered and overcome during the structure determination of human cytomegalovirus protease. Dehydration of crystals, by exposing them to higher concentrations of the precipitant, reduced the mosaicity of the crystals and may have also resolved their microscopic twinning. The initial phase information was obtained with the selenomethionyl multiple-wavelength anomalous diffraction technique. However, site-specific mutagenesis was required to introduce extra Met residues into the protease. The phase information had to be improved by non-crystallographic symmetry averaging, initially among three 'crystal forms'. A change in the composition of the artificial mother liquor led to a significant improvement, from 3.0 and 2.0 A resolution, in the diffraction quality of the crystals. The experiences reported here may prove useful to structure determination of other proteins.

Refined X-ray crystallographic structure of the poliovirus 3C gene product

The X-ray crystallographic structure of the recombinant poliovirus 3C gene product (Mahoney strain) has been determined by single isomorphous replacement and non-crystallographic symmetry averaging and refined at 2.1 Å resolution. Poliovirus 3C is comprised of two six-stranded antiparallel β-barrel domains and is structurally similar to the chymotrypsin-like serine proteinases. The shallow active site cleft is located at the junction of the two β-barrel domains and contains a His40, Glu71, Cys147 catalytic triad. The polypeptide loop preceding Cys147 is flexible and likely undergoes a conformational change upon substrate binding. The specificity pockets for poliovirus 3C are well-defined and modeling studies account for the known substrate specificity of this proteinase. Poliovirus 3C also participates in the formation of the viral replicative initiation complex where it specifically recognizes and binds the RNA stem-loop structure in the 5′ non-translated region of its own genome. The RNA recognition site of 3C is located on the opposite side of the molecule in relation to its proteolytic active site and is centered about the conserved KFRDIR sequence of the domain linker. The recognition site is well-defined and also includes residues from the amino and carboxy-terminal helices. The two molecules in the asymmetric unit are related by an approximate 2-fold, non-crystallographic symmetry and form an intermolecular antiparallel β-sheet at their interface.

The Structure of Cucumber Mosaic Virus: Cryoelectron Microscopy, X-Ray Crystallography, and Sequence Analysis

The three-dimensional structure of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) was analyzed at 23 Å resolution by cryoelectron microscopy and image reconstruction, demonstrating structural similarity to cowpea chlorotic mottle virus (CCMV), another member of theBromoviridaefamily. The CMV structure was determined at 8 Å resolution by X-ray crystallography with phases determined by single isomorphous replacement and refined by fivefold noncrystallographic symmetry averaging. The X-ray structure agreed with the electron microscopy reconstruction; the electron density is consistent with β-barrel subunits arranged withT= 3 quasi-symmetry in an orientation similar to that observed in CCMV. Strong density surrounding the icosahedral threefold axes (quasi sixfold axes in theT= 3 particle) between 80 and 100 Å from the particle center formed a cylinder of radius 11 Å, similar to the density observed in the same region of CCMV. This density corresponds to the β-annulus of CCMV, which differentiates hexamers from pentamers and determines the formation of theT= 3 particles. The CMV and CCMV amino acid sequences were aligned, providing information (based on the CCMV atomic model) about the probable distribution of residues in the three-dimensional structure of CMV.

Phage P22 tailspike protein: crystal structure of the head-binding domain at 2.3 Å, fully refined structure of the endorhamnosidase at 1.56 Å resolution, and the molecular basis of O-antigen recognition and cleavage

The tailspike protein of Salmonella phage P22 is a viral adhesion protein with both receptor binding and destroying activities. It recognises the O-antigenic repeating units of cell surface lipopolysaccharide of serogroup A, B and D1 as receptor, but also inactivates its receptor by endoglycosidase (endorhamnosidase) activity. In the final step of bacteriophage P22 assembly six homotrimeric tailspike molecules are non-covalently attached to the DNA injection apparatus, mediated by their N-terminal, head-binding domains. We report the crystal structure of the head-binding domain of P22 tailspike protein at 2.3 Å resolution, solved with a recombinant telluromethionine derivative and non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The trimeric dome-like structure is formed by two perpendicular β-sheets of five and three strands, respectively in each subunit and caps a three-helix bundle observed in the structure of the C-terminal receptor binding and cleaving fragment, reported here after full refinement at 1.56 Å resolution. In the central part of the receptor binding fragment, three parallel β-helices of 13 complete turns are associated side-by-side, while the three polypeptide strands merge into a single domain towards their C termini, with close interdigitation at the junction to the β-helix part. Complex structures with receptor fragments from S. typhimurium, S. enteritidis and S. typhi253Ty determined at 1.8 Å resolution are described in detail. Insertions into the β-helix form the O-antigen binding groove, which also harbours the active site residues Asp392, Asp395 and Glu359. In the intact structure of the tailspike protein, head-binding and receptor-binding parts are probably linked by a flexible hinge whose function may be either to deal with shearing forces on the exposed, 150 Å long tailspikes or to allow them to bend during the infection process.

Crystal structure of delta9 stearoyl-acyl carrier protein desaturase from castor seed and its relationship to other di-iron proteins.

The three-dimensional structure of recombinant homodimeric delta9 stearoyl-acyl carrier protein desaturase, the archetype of the soluble plant fatty acid desaturases that convert saturated to unsaturated fatty acids, has been determined by protein crystallographic methods to a resolution of 2.4 angstroms. The structure was solved by a combination of single isomorphous replacement, anomalous contribution from the iron atoms to the native diffraction data and 6-fold non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The 363 amino acid monomer consists of a single domain of 11 alpha-helices. Nine of these form an antiparallel helix bundle. The enzyme subunit contains a di-iron centre, with ligands from four of the alpha-helices in the helix bundle. The iron ions are bound in a highly symmetric environment, with one of the irons forming interactions with the side chains of E196 and H232 and the second iron with the side chains of E105 and H146. Two additional glutamic acid side chains, from E143 and E229, are within coordination distance to both iron ions. A water molecule is found within the second coordination sphere from the iron atoms. The lack of electron density corresponding to a mu-oxo bridge, and the long (4.2 angstroms) distance between the iron ions suggests that this probably represents the diferrous form of the enzyme. A deep channel which probably binds the fatty acid extends from the surface into the interior of the enzyme. Modelling of the substrate, stearic acid, into this channel places the delta9 carbon atom in the vicinity of one of the iron ions.

MAGICSQUASH: More Versatile Non-crystallographic Averaging with Mulitple Constraints

The simultaneous application of multiple constraints such as non-crystallographic symmetry averaging, solvent levelling, histogram matching and Sayre's equation has proven to be very effective for phase refinement and extension. An existing program for this purpose, SQUASH, has been altered to increase the flexibility of its non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The modified program, MAGICSQUASH, can handle multiple-domain averaging and multiple space group averaging and has aided in the solution of several structures. Examples are described which include the first simultaneous application of solvent levelling, histogram matching and Sayre's equation in two crystal forms while averaging between them.

Large Structures at High Resolution: The 1.6 Å Crystal Structure of Spinach Ribulose-1,5- Bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase Complexed with 2-Carboxyarabinitol Bisphosphate

Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rubisco) from spinach is a hexadecamer (L8S8, M r=550,000) consisting of eight large (L, 475 residues) and eight small subunits (S, 123 residues). High-resolution data collection on crystals with large unit cells is not a trivial task due to the effect of radiation damage and the large number of overlapping reflections when conventional data collection methods are used. In order to minimise these effects, data on rubisco were collected with a giant Weissenberg camera at long crystal to image-plate distances at the synchrotron of the Photon Factory, Japan. Relative to conventional data sets, this experimental arrangement allowed a 20 to 30-fold reduction of the X-ray dose/exposure time for data collection. This paper describes the refined 1.6 Å crystal structure of activated rubisco complexed with a transition state analogue, 2-carboxyarabinitol-bisphosphate. The crystallographic asymmetric unit contains an L4S4 unit, representing half of the molecule. The structure presented here is currently the highest resolution structure for any protein of comparable size. Refinement of the model was carried out by restrained least squares techniques without non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The results show that all L and S subunits have identical three-dimensional structures, and their arrangement within the hexadecamer has no intrinsic asymmetry. A detailed analysis of the high-resolution maps identified 30 differences in the sequence of the small subunit, indicating a larger than usual heterogeneity for this nuclear encoded protein in spinach. No such differences were found in the sequence of the chloroplast encoded large subunit. The transition state analogue is in the cis conformation at the active site suggesting a key role for the carbamate of Lys201 in catalysis. Analysis of the active site around the catalytically essential magnesium ion further indicates that residues in the second liganding sphere of the metal play a role in fine-tuning the acid-base character and the position of the residues directly liganded to the metal.

X-ray structure of an anti-fungal chitosanase from streptomyces N174.

We report the 2.4 A X-ray crystal structure of a protein with chitosan endo-hydrolase activity isolated from Streptomyces N174. The structure was solved using phases acquired by SIRAS from a two-site methyl mercury derivative combined with solvent flattening and non-crystallographic two-fold symmetry averaging, and refined to an R-factor of 18.5%. The mostly alpha-helical fold reveals a structural core shared with several classes of lysozyme and barley endochitinase, in spite of a lack of shared sequence. Based on this structural similarity we postulate a putative active site, mechanism of action and mode of substrate recognition. It appears that Glu 22 acts as an acid and Asp 40 serves as a general base to activate a water molecule for an SN2 attack on the glycosidic bond. A series of amino-acid side chains and backbone carbonyl groups may bind the polycationic chitosan substrate in a deep electronegative binding cleft.

Three-dimensional structure of meso-diaminopimelic acid dehydrogenase from Corynebacterium glutamicum.

Diaminopimelate dehydrogenase catalyzes the NADPH-dependent reduction of ammonia and L-2-amino-6-ketopimelate to form meso-diaminopimelate, the direct precursor of L-lysine in the bacterial lysine biosynthetic pathway. Since mammals lack this metabolic pathway inhibitors of enzymes in this pathway may be useful as antibiotics or herbicides. Diaminopimelate dehydrogenase catalyzes the only oxidative deamination of an amino acid of D configuration and must additionally distinguish between two chiral amino acid centers on the same symmetric substrate. The Corynebacterium glutamicum enzyme has been cloned, expressed in Escherichia coli, and purified to homogeneity using standard biochemical procedures [Reddy, S. G., Scapin, G., & Blanchard, J. S. (1996) Proteins: Structure, Funct. Genet. 25, 514-516]. The three-dimensional structure of the binary complex of diaminopimelate dehydrogenase with NADP+ has been solved using multiple isomorphous replacement procedures and noncrystallographic symmetry averaging. The resulting model has been refined against 2.2 A diffraction data to a conventional crystallographic R-factor of 17.0%. Diaminopimelate dehydrogenase is a homodimer of structurally not identical subunits. Each subunit is composed of three domains. The N-terminal domain contains a modified dinucleotide binding domain, or Rossman fold (six central beta-strands in a 213456 topology surrounded by five alpha-helices). The second domain contains two alpha-helices and three beta-strands. This domain is referred to as the dimerization domain, since it is involved in forming the monomer--monomer interface of the dimer. The third or C-terminal domain is composed of six beta-strands and five alpha-helices. The relative position of the N- and C-terminal domain in the two monomers is different, defining an open and a closed conformation that may represent the enzyme's binding and active state, respectively. In both monomers the nucleotide is bound in an extended conformation across the C-terminal portion of the beta-sheet of the Rossman fold, with its C4 facing the C-terminal domain. In the closed conformer two molecules of acetate have been refined in this region, and we postulate that they define the DAP binding site. The structure of diaminopimelate dehydrogenase shows interesting similarities to the structure of glutamate dehydrogenase [Baker, P. J., Britton, K. L., Rice, D. W., Rob, A., & Stillmann, T.J. (1992a) J. Mol. Biol. 228, 662-671] and leucine dehydrogenase [Baker, P.J., Turnbull, A.P., Sedelnikova, S.E., Stillman, T. J., & Rice, D. W. (1995) Structure 3, 693-705] and also resembles the structure of dihydrodipicolinate reductase [Scapin, G., Blanchard, J. S., & Sacchettini, J. C. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 3502-3512], the enzyme immediately preceding it in the diaminopimelic acid/lysine biosynthetic pathway.

Crystal structure of glycosomal glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase from Leishmania mexicana: implications for structure-based drug design and a new position for the inorganic phosphate binding site.

The structure of glycosomal glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) from the trypanosomatid parasite Leishmania mexicana has been determined by X-ray crystallography. The protein crystallizes in space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with unit cell parameters a = 99.0 A, b = 126.5 A, and c = 138.9 A. There is one 156,000 Da protein tetramer per asymmetric unit. The model of the protein with bound NAD+s and phosphates has been refined against 86% complete data from 10.0 to 2.8 A to a crystallographic Rfactor of 0.198. Density modification by noncrystallographic symmetry averaging was used during model building. The final model of the L. mexicana GAPDH tetramer shows small deviations of less than 0.5 degrees from ideal 222 molecular symmetry. The structure of L. mexicana GAPDH is very similar to that of glycosomal GAPDH from the related trypanosomatid Trypanosoma brucei. A significant structural difference between L. mexicana GAPDH and most previously determined GAPDH structures occurs in a loop region located at the active site. This unusual loop conformation in L. mexicana GAPDH occludes the inorganic phosphate binding site which has been seen in previous GAPDH structures. A new inorganic phosphate position is observed in the L. mexicana GAPDH structure. Model building studies indicate that this new anion binding site is well situated for nucleophilic attack of the inorganic phosphate on the thioester intermediate in the GAPDH-catalyzed reaction. Since crystals of L. mexicana GAPDH can be grown reproducibly and diffract much better than those of T. brucei GAPDH, L. mexicana GAPDH will be used as a basis for structure-based drug design targeted against trypanosomatid GAPDHs.

The 2.4 Å Crystal Structure of Cholera Toxin B Subunit Pentamer: Choleragenoid

Cholera toxin, a heterohexameric AB 5enterotoxin released by Vibrio choleraeinduces a profuse secretory diarrhea in susceptible hosts. Choleragenoid, the B subunit pentamer of cholera toxin, directs the enzymatic A subunit to its target by binding the GM 1gangliosides exposed on the luminal surface of intestinal epithelial cells. The crystal structure of choleragenoid has been independently solved and refined at 2.4 Å resolution by combining single isomorphous replacement with non-crystallographic symmetry averaging. The structure of the B subunits, and their pentameric arrangement, closely resembles that reported for the intact holotoxin, choleragen, the heat-labile enterotoxin from Escherichia coli, and for a choleragenoid-GM 1pentasaccharide complex. In the absence of the A subunit the central cavity of the B pentamer is a highly solvated channel. The binding of choleragenoid to the A subunit or to its receptor pentasaccharide modestly affects the local stereochemistry without perceptibly altering the subunit interface.

DEMON/ANGEL: a suite of programs to carry out density modification

The DEMON/ANGEL suite of computer programs has been developed to carry out density modification by non-crystallographic symmetry-averaging, solvent-flattening and histogram-mapping techniques. This suite consists of programs that allow molecular envelopes to be defined and modified, non-crystallographic symmetry operators to be refined either within one crystal form or between several crystal forms, and iterative density modification to be carried out, including non-crystallographic symmetry averaging of electron densities within or between crystal forms.