Let $${\mathscr {C}}\! om $$ denote the variety of all commutative semigroups. For $$n\ge 1$$ let $${{\mathscr {N}}\! il }_n$$ (respectively $${\mathscr {N}}_n$$ ) denote the variety of all nil (respectively nilpotent) semigroups of index n, and let $${\mathscr {N}}\! il $$ (respectively $${\mathscr {N}}$$ ) denote the generalized variety of all nil (respectively nilpotent) semigroups. For a class $${\mathscr {W}}$$ of semigroups let $${\mathscr {L}}({\mathscr {W}})$$ denote the lattice of all varieties contained in $${\mathscr {W}}$$ , and let $${\mathscr {G}}({\mathscr {W}})$$ denote the lattice of all generalized varieties contained in $${\mathscr {W}}$$ . Almeida has proved that the map $$\alpha :{\mathscr {L}}({\mathscr {N}}\! il \cap {\mathscr {C}}\! om )\cup \{{\mathscr {N}}\! il \cap {\mathscr {C}}\! om \}\rightarrow {\mathscr {G}}({\mathscr {N}}\cap {\mathscr {C}}\! om )$$ given by $${\mathscr {W}}\alpha = {\mathscr {W}}\cap {\mathscr {N}}$$ is an isomorphism, and asked whether the extension $${\alpha }': {\mathscr {L}}({\mathscr {N}}\! il ) \cup \{{\mathscr {N}}\! il \}\rightarrow {\mathscr {G}}({\mathscr {N}})$$ of this map is also an isomorphism. The author has previously shown that $${\alpha }'$$ is not injective, using varieties of nil index 5, and noted that the corresponding map $${\alpha }_n : {\mathscr {L}}({{\mathscr {N}}\! il }_n) \rightarrow {\mathscr {G}}({\mathscr {N}} \cap {{\mathscr {N}}\! il }_n)$$ given by $${\mathscr {W}} {\alpha }_n ={\mathscr {W}}\cap {\mathscr {N}}$$ is therefore not injective for $$n\ge 5$$ . The question of smaller values of n was left open, and in this article it is shown that $${\alpha }_n$$ is not injective for $$n\ge 2$$ , using Leech’s square-free words.
Read full abstract