Neurospora Crassa Mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase Research Articles

Evolution of RNA-Protein Interactions: Non-Specific Binding Led to RNA Splicing Activity of Fungal Mitochondrial Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetases

Author SummaryThe acquisition of new modes of post-transcriptional gene regulation played an important role in the evolution of eukaryotes and was achieved by an increase in the number of RNA-binding proteins with new functions. RNA-binding proteins bind directly to double- or single-stranded RNA and regulate many cellular processes. Here, we address how proteins evolve new RNA-binding functions by using as a model system a fungal mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase that evolved to acquire a novel function in splicing group I introns. Group I introns are RNA enzymes (or “ribozymes”) that catalyze their own removal from transcripts, but can become dependent upon proteins to stabilize their active structure. We show that the C-terminal domain of the synthetase is flexibly attached and has high non-specific RNA-binding activity that likely pre-dated the evolution of splicing activity. Our findings suggest an evolutionary scenario in which an initial non-specific interaction between an ancestral synthetase and a self-splicing group I intron was fixed by an intron RNA mutation, thereby making it dependent upon the protein for structural stabilization. The interaction then evolved by the acquisition of adaptive mutations throughout the protein and RNA that increased both the splicing efficiency and its protein-dependence. Our results suggest a general mechanism by which non-specific binding interactions can lead to the evolution of new RNA-binding functions and provide novel insights into splicing and synthetase mechanisms.

Structure of a tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase splicing factor bound to a group I intron RNA

The 'RNA world' hypothesis holds that during evolution the structural and enzymatic functions initially served by RNA were assumed by proteins, leading to the latter's domination of biological catalysis. This progression can still be seen in modern biology, where ribozymes, such as the ribosome and RNase P, have evolved into protein-dependent RNA catalysts ('RNPzymes'). Similarly, group I introns use RNA-catalysed splicing reactions, but many function as RNPzymes bound to proteins that stabilize their catalytically active RNA structure. One such protein, the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS; CYT-18), is bifunctional and both aminoacylates mitochondrial tRNA(Tyr) and promotes the splicing of mitochondrial group I introns. Here we determine a 4.5-A co-crystal structure of the Twort orf142-I2 group I intron ribozyme bound to splicing-active, carboxy-terminally truncated CYT-18. The structure shows that the group I intron binds across the two subunits of the homodimeric protein with a newly evolved RNA-binding surface distinct from that which binds tRNA(Tyr). This RNA binding surface provides an extended scaffold for the phosphodiester backbone of the conserved catalytic core of the intron RNA, allowing the protein to promote the splicing of a wide variety of group I introns. The group I intron-binding surface includes three small insertions and additional structural adaptations relative to non-splicing bacterial TyrRSs, indicating a multistep adaptation for splicing function. The co-crystal structure provides insight into how CYT-18 promotes group I intron splicing, how it evolved to have this function, and how proteins could have incrementally replaced RNA structures during the transition from an RNA world to an RNP world.

A Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase Adapted to Function in Group I Intron Splicing by Acquiring a New RNA Binding Surface

We determined a 1.95 Å X-ray crystal structure of a C-terminally truncated Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) that functions in splicing group I introns. CYT-18's nucleotide binding fold and intermediate α-helical domains superimpose on those of bacterial TyrRSs, except for an N-terminal extension and two small insertions not found in nonsplicing bacterial enzymes. These additions surround the cyt-18-1 mutation site and are sites of suppressor mutations that restore splicing, but not synthetase activity. Highly constrained models based on directed hydroxyl radical cleavage assays show that the group I intron binds at a site formed in part by the three additions on the nucleotide binding fold surface opposite that which binds tRNA Tyr. Our results show how essential proteins can progressively evolve new functions.

The Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein C-terminal RNA-binding domain helps stabilize interdomain tertiary interactions in group I introns

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) promotes the splicing of group I introns by stabilizing the catalytically active RNA structure. To accomplish this, CYT-18 recognizes conserved structural features of group I intron RNAs using regions of the N-terminal nucleotide-binding fold, intermediate alpha-helical, and C-terminal RNA-binding domains that also function in binding tRNA(Tyr). Curiously, whereas the splicing of the N. crassa mitochondrial large subunit rRNA intron is completely dependent on CYT-18's C-terminal RNA-binding domain, all other group I introns tested thus far are spliced efficiently by a truncated protein lacking this domain. To investigate the function of the C-terminal domain, we used an Escherichia coli genetic assay to isolate mutants of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial large subunit rRNA and phage T4 td introns that can be spliced in vivo by the wild-type CYT-18 protein, but not by the C-terminally truncated protein. Mutations that result in dependence on CYT-18's C-terminal domain include those disrupting two long-range GNRA tetraloop/receptor interactions: L2-P8, which helps position the P1 helix containing the 5'-splice site, and L9-P5, which helps establish the correct relative orientation of the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains of the group I intron catalytic core. Our results indicate that different structural mutations in group I intron RNAs can result in dependence on different regions of CYT-18 for RNA splicing.

TRNA-like recognition of group I introns by a tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase.

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active RNA structure. Previous work suggested that CYT-18 recognizes a conserved tRNA-like structure of the group I intron catalytic core. Here, directed hydroxyl-radical cleavage assays show that the nucleotide-binding fold and C-terminal domains of CYT-18 interact with the expected group I intron cognates of the aminoacyl-acceptor stem and D-anticodon arms, respectively. Further, three-dimensional graphic modeling, supported by biochemical data, shows that conserved regions of group I introns can be superimposed over interacting regions of the tRNA in a Thermus thermophilus TyrRS/tRNA(Tyr) cocrystal structure. Our results support the hypothesis that CYT-18 and other aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases interact with group I introns by recognizing conserved tRNA-like structural features of the intron RNAs.

Interaction of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) with the group I intron P4-P6 domain. thermodynamic analysis and the role of metal ions

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron’s catalytic core. Previous studies suggested a model in which the protein binds first to the intron’s P4-P6 domain, and then makes additional contacts with the P3-P9 domain to stabilize the two domains in the correct relative orientation to form the intron’s active site. Here, we analyzed the interaction of CYT-18 with a small RNA (P4-P6 RNA) corresponding to the isolated P4-P6 domain of the N. crassa mitochondrial large subunit ribosomal RNA intron. RNA footprinting and modification-interference experiments showed that CYT-18 binds to this small RNA around the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices on the side opposite the active-site cleft, as it does to the P4-P6 domain in the intact intron. The binding is inhibited by chemical modifications that disrupt base-pairing in P4, P6, and P6a, indicating that a partially folded structure of the P4-P6 domain is required. The temperature-dependence of binding indicates that the interaction is driven by a favorable enthalpy change, but is accompanied by an unfavorable entropy change. The latter may reflect entropically unfavorable conformational changes or decreased conformational flexibility in the complex. CYT-18 binding is inhibited at ⩾125 mM KCl, indicating a strong dependence on phosphodiester-backbone interactions. On the other hand, Mg2+ is absolutely required for CYT-18 binding, with titration experiments showing ∼1.5 magnesium ions bound per complex. Metal ion-cleavage experiments identified a divalent cation-binding site near the boundary of P6 and J6/6a, and chemical modification showed that Mg2+ binding induces RNA conformational changes in this region, as well as elsewhere, particularly in J4/5. Together, these findings suggest a model in which the binding of Mg2+ near J6/6a and possibly at one additional location in the P4-P6 RNA induces formation of a specific phosphodiester-backbone geometry that is required for CYT-18 binding. The binding of CYT-18 may then establish the correct structure at the junction of the P4/P6 stacked helices for assembly of the P3-P9 domain. The interaction of CYT-18 with the P4-P6 domain appears similar to the TyrRS interaction with the D-/anticodon arm stacked helices of tRNATyr.

Function of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase in RNA splicing. Role of the idiosyncratic N-terminal extension and different modes of interaction with different group I introns

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) promotes the splicing of group I introns by helping the intron RNA fold into the catalytically active structure. The regions required for splicing include an idiosyncratic N-terminal extension, the nucleotide-binding fold domain, and the C-terminal RNA-binding domain. Here, we show that the idiosyncratic N-terminal region is in fact comprised of two functionally distinct parts: an upstream region consisting predominantly of a predicted amphipathic α-helix (H0), which is absent from bacterial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases (TyrRSs), and a downstream region, which contains predicted α-helices H1 and H2, corresponding to features in the X-ray crystal structure of the Bacillus stearothermophilus TyrRS. Bacterial genetic assays with libraries of CYT-18 mutants having random mutations in the N-terminal region identified functionally important amino acid residues and supported the predicted structures of the H0 and H1 α-helices. The function of N and C-terminal domains of CYT-18 was investigated by detailed biochemical analysis of deletion mutants. The results confirmed that the N-terminal extension is required only for splicing activity, but surprisingly, at least in the case of the N. crassa mitochondrial (mt) large ribosomal subunit (LSU) intron, it appears to act primarily by stabilizing the structure of another region that interacts directly with the intron RNA. The H1/H2 region is required for splicing activity and TyrRS activity with the N. crassa mt tRNA Tyr, but not for TyrRS activity with Escherichia coli tRNA Tyr, implying a somewhat different mode of recognition of the two tyrosyl-tRNAs. Finally, a CYT-18 mutant lacking the N-terminal H0 region is totally defective in binding or splicing the N. crassa ND1 intron, but retains substantial residual activity with the mt LSU intron, and conversely, a CYT-18 mutant lacking the C-terminal RNA-binding domain is totally defective in binding or splicing the mt LSU intron, but retains substantial residual activity with the ND1 intron. These findings lead to the surprising conclusion that CYT-18 promotes splicing via different sets of interactions with different group I introns. We suggest that these different modes of promoting splicing evolved from an initial interaction based on the recognition of conserved tRNA-like structural features of the group I intron catalytic core.

Function of tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase in splicing group I introns: an induced-fit model for binding to the P4-P6 domain based on analysis of mutations at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices

We used an Escherichia coli genetic assay based on the phage T4 td intron to test the ability of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) to suppress mutations that cause structural defects around its binding site in the P4-P6 domain of the group I intron catalytic core. We analyzed all possible combinations of nucleotides at either P4 bp-1 or P6 bp-1, which together form the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices, and looked for synergistic effects in double mutants. Most mutations at either position inhibit self-splicing, but can be suppressed by CYT-18. CYT-18 can compensate efficiently for mutations that disrupt base-pairing at either P4 bp-1 or P6 bp-1, for mutations at P6 bp-1 that disrupt the base-triple interaction with J3/4-3, and for nucleotide substitutions at either position that are predicted to be suboptimal for base stacking, based on the analysis of DNA four-way junctions. However, CYT-18 has difficulty suppressing combinations of mutations at P4 bp-1 and P6 bp-1 that simultaneously disrupt base-pairing and base stacking. Thermal denaturation and Fe(II)-EDTA analysis showed that mutations at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices lead to grossly impaired tertiary-structure formation centered in the P4-P6 domain. CYT-18-suppressible mutants bind the protein with Kd values up to 79-fold higher than that for the wild-type intron, but in all cases tested, the koff value for the complex remains within twofold of the wild-type value, suggesting that the binding site can be formed properly and that the increased Kd value reflects primarily an increased kon value for the binding of CYT-18 to the misfolded intron. Our results indicate that the P4/P6 junction is a linchpin region, where even small nucleotide substitutions grossly disrupt the catalytically-active group I intron tertiary structure, and that CYT-18 binding induces the formation of the correct structure in this region, leading to folding of the group I intron catalytic core.

A Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase Suppresses Structural Defects in the Two Major Helical Domains of the Group I Intron Catalytic Core

The Neurospora crassamitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase, the CYT-18 protein, functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron RNA. The group I intron catalytic core is thought to consist of two extended helical domains, one formed by coaxial stacking of P5, P4, P6, and P6a (P4-P6 domain) and the other consisting of P8, P3, P7, and P9 (P3-P9 domain). To investigate how CYT-18 stabilizes the active RNA structure, we used an Escherichia coligenetic assay based on the phage T4 tdintron to systematically test the ability of CYT-18 to compensate for structural defects in three key regions of the catalytic core: J3/4 and J6/7, connecting regions that form parts of the triple-helical-scaffold structure with the P4-P6 domain, and P7, a long- range base-pairing interaction that forms the guanosine-binding site and is part of the P3-P9 domain. Our results show that CYT-18 can suppress numerous mutations that disrupt the J3/4 and J6/7 nucleotide-triple interactions, as well as mutations that disrupt base-pairing in P7. CYT-18 suppressed mutations of phylogenetically conserved nucleotide residues at all positions tested, except for the universally conserved G-residue at the guanosine-binding site. Structure mapping experiments with selected mutant introns showed that the CYT-18-suppressible J3/4 mutations primarily impaired folding of the P4-P6 domain, while the J6/7 mutations impaired folding of both the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains to various degrees. The P7 mutations impaired the formation of both P7 and P3, thereby grossly disrupting the P3-P9 domain. The finding that the P7 mutations also impaired formation of P3 provides evidence that the formation of these two long-range pairings is interdependent in the tdintron. Considered together with previous work, the nature of mutations suppressed by CYT-18 supports a model in which CYT-18 helps assemble the P4-P6 domain and then stabilizes the two major helical domains of the catalytic core in the correct relative orientation to form the intron's active site.

Analysis of the CYT-18 Protein Binding Site at the Junction of Stacked Helices in a Group I Intron RNA by Quantitative Binding Assays and in vitroSelection

The Neurospora crassamitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron RNA. Previous studies showed that CYT-18 binds with high affinity to the P4-P6 domain of the catalytic core and that there is some additional contribution to binding from the P3-P9 domain. Here, quantitative binding assays with deletion derivatives of the N. crassamitochondrial large rRNA intron showed that at least 70% of the binding energy can be accounted for by the interaction of CYT-18 with the P4-P6 domain. Within this domain, P4 and P6 are required for high affinity CYT-18 binding, while the distal elements P5 and P6a may contribute indirectly by stabilizing the correct structure of the binding site in P4 and P6. CYT-18 binds to a small RNA corresponding to the isolated P4-P6 domain, but not to a permuted version of this RNA in which P4-P6 is a continuous rather than a stacked helix. Iterative in vitroselection experiments with the isolated P4-P6 domain showed a requirement for base-pairing to maintain helices P4, P6 and P6a, but indicate that P5 is subject to fewer constraints. The most strongly conserved nucleotides in the selections were clustered around the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helix, with ten nucleotides (J3/4-2,3, P4 bp -1 and 3, and P6 bp -1 and 2) found invariant in the context of the wild-type RNA structure. In vitromutagenesis confirmed that replacement of the wild-type nucleotides at J3/4-2 and 3 or P4 bp-3 markedly decreased CYT-18 binding, reflecting either base specific contacts or indirect readout of RNA structure by the protein. Our results suggest that a major function of CYT-18 is to promote assembly of the P4-P6 domain by stabilizing the correct geometry at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helix. The relatively large number of conserved nucleotides at the binding site suggests that the interaction of CYT-18 with group I introns is unlikely to have arisen by chance and could reflect either an evolutionary relationship between group I introns and tRNAs or interaction with a common stacked-helical structural motif that evolved separately in these RNAs.

A Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase Protein Induces Tertiary Folding of the Group I Intron Catalytic Core

The Neurospora crassamitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns. We have used chemical-structure mapping and footprinting to investigate the interaction of the CYT-18 protein with the N. crassamitochondrial large subunit ribosomal RNA (mt LSU) and ND1introns, which are not detectably self-splicing in vitro. Our results show that both these non-self-splicing introns form most of the short range pairings of the conserved group I intron secondary structure in the absence of CYT-18, but otherwise remain largely unfolded, even at high Mg 2 +concentrations. The binding of CYT-18 promotes the formation of the extended helical domains P6a-P6-P4-P5 (P4-P6 domain) and P8-P3-P7-P9 (P3-P9 domain) and their interaction to form the catalytic core. In iodine-footprinting experiments, CYT-18 binding results in the protection of regions of the phosphodiester backbone expected for tertiary folding of the catalytic core, as well as additional protections that may reflect proximity of the protein. In both introns, most of the putative CYT-18 protection sites are in the P4-P6 domain, the region of the SU intron previously shown to bind CYT-18 as a separate RNA molecule, but additional sites are found in the other major helical domain in P8 and P9 in both introns and in L9 and P7.1/P7.1a in the mt LSU intron. Protease digestion of the CYT-18/intron RNA complexes results in the loss of CYT-18-induced RNA tertiary structure and splicing activity. Considered together with previous studies, our results suggest that CYT-18 binds initially to the P4-P6 region of group I introns to form a scaffold for the assembly of the P3-P9 domain, which may contain additional binding sites for the protein. A three-dimensional model structure of the CYT-18-binding site in group I introns indicates that CYT-18 interacts with the surface of the catalytic core on the side opposite the active-site cleft and may primarily recognize a specific three-dimensional geometry of the phosphodiester backbone of group I introns.

The mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase of Podospora anserina is a bifunctional enzyme active in protein synthesis and RNA splicing.

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (mt tyrRS), which is encoded by the nuclear gene cyt-18, functions not only in aminoacylation but also in the splicing of group I introns. Here, we isolated the cognate Podospora anserina mt tyrRS gene, designated yts1, by using the N. crassa cyt-18 gene as a hybridization probe. DNA sequencing of the P. anserina gene revealed an open reading frame (ORF) of 641 amino acids which has significant similarity to other tyrRSs. The yts1 ORF is interrupted by two introns, one near its N terminus at the same position as the single intron in the cyt-18 gene and the other downstream in a region corresponding to the nucleotide-binding fold. The P. anserina yts1+ gene transformed the N. crassa cyt-18-2 mutant at a high frequency and rescued both the splicing and protein synthesis defects. Furthermore, the YTS1 protein synthesized in Escherichia coli was capable of splicing the N. crassa mt large rRNA intron in vitro. Together, these results indicate that YTS1 is a bifunctional protein active in both splicing and protein synthesis. The P. anserina YTS1 and N. crassa CYT-18 proteins share three blocks of amino acids that are not conserved in bacterial or yeast mt tyrRSs which do not function in splicing. One of these blocks corresponds to the idiosyncratic N-terminal domain shown previously to be required for splicing activity of the CYT-18 protein. The other two are located in the putative tRNA-binding domain toward the C terminus of the protein and also appear to be required for splicing. Since the E. coli and yeast mt tyrRSs do not function in splicing, the adaptation of the Neurospora and Podospora spp. mt tyrRSs to function in splicing most likely occurred after the divergence of their common ancestor from yeast.

The mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase of Podospora anserina is a bifunctional enzyme active in protein synthesis and RNA splicing.

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (mt tyrRS), which is encoded by the nuclear gene cyt-18, functions not only in aminoacylation but also in the splicing of group I introns. Here, we isolated the cognate Podospora anserina mt tyrRS gene, designated yts1, by using the N. crassa cyt-18 gene as a hybridization probe. DNA sequencing of the P. anserina gene revealed an open reading frame (ORF) of 641 amino acids which has significant similarity to other tyrRSs. The yts1 ORF is interrupted by two introns, one near its N terminus at the same position as the single intron in the cyt-18 gene and the other downstream in a region corresponding to the nucleotide-binding fold. The P. anserina yts1+ gene transformed the N. crassa cyt-18-2 mutant at a high frequency and rescued both the splicing and protein synthesis defects. Furthermore, the YTS1 protein synthesized in Escherichia coli was capable of splicing the N. crassa mt large rRNA intron in vitro. Together, these results indicate that YTS1 is a bifunctional protein active in both splicing and protein synthesis. The P. anserina YTS1 and N. crassa CYT-18 proteins share three blocks of amino acids that are not conserved in bacterial or yeast mt tyrRSs which do not function in splicing. One of these blocks corresponds to the idiosyncratic N-terminal domain shown previously to be required for splicing activity of the CYT-18 protein. The other two are located in the putative tRNA-binding domain toward the C terminus of the protein and also appear to be required for splicing. Since the E. coli and yeast mt tyrRSs do not function in splicing, the adaptation of the Neurospora and Podospora spp. mt tyrRSs to function in splicing most likely occurred after the divergence of their common ancestor from yeast.