The immune system plays a crucial role in tissue repair and regeneration. Macrophages have been identified as master regulators of the early immune response and healing outcome, by orchestrating the temporal nature of the initial inflammation phase and coordinating the fate of stem/progenitor cells involved in regeneration. However, traditional in-vitro models for the study of macrophages often fail to fully replicate the complexity of the in-vivo microenvironment, therefore generating models which do not fully capture the extensive spectrum of macrophage behaviour seen in native tissues. To this end, we used a hematoma-mimetic 3D fibrin matrix characteristic of early injured tissues to generate a 3D in-vitro model mirroring the local macrophage microenvironment. Leveraging this framework, we demonstrated significant effects of extracellular matrix and dimensionality on macrophage basal signalling and polarisation, achieving more pronounced regenerative phenotypes upon stimulation with the M2a polarisation factors compared to traditional 2D tissue culture conditions. Moreover, this enhanced physiological macrophage behaviour corresponded to increased coordination of angiogenesis and osteogenesis, better mirroring the healing processes seen in-vivo. Taken together, this study demonstrates the critical importance of integrating tissue composition and 3D architecture when investigating the macrophage behaviour in-vitro, establishing a powerful tool that overcomes known limitations associated with traditional 2D culture on plastic, and can be used to identify and validate novel immunomodulation strategies to enhance tissue regeneration.