First demonstrated in 1846, general anesthesia remains a singular advance of modern medicine. Anesthesia for children has dramatically alleviated pain and stress in pediatric patients, and now permits surgical care of even the youngest and smallest infants. By the mid-20th century, however, it was first suggested adverse postoperative behaviors in children might be due, at least in part, to general anesthesia [1]. Subsequent studies demonstrated abnormal neuropathology and adverse behavioral changes in rodents following in utero exposure to volatile agents, and in 1999, data demonstrating widespread neuronal apoptosis in rat pups following postnatal exposure to anesthetics were first published [2]. The resultant debate in the medical literature regarding human relevance of such findings has been extensive, and dissemination of alarm over potential deleterious effects of pediatric anesthesia in the general media has been widespread. What do we know, and what should we do? Neuronal apoptosis, or programmed cell death, is a normal part of neurodevelopment. Up to 1% of neurons in a developing mammalian brain normally will be pruned via apoptosis after failing to meet anatomic or functional milestones. Numerous factors may dramatically increase this percentage, potentially inducing abnormal neuropathology and adverse clinical outcomes [3]. Untreated neonatal pain in animals is associated with increased neuronal apoptosis and sustained behavioral disturbances [4, 5], and even seemingly minor procedures in human infants such as neonatal circumcision are associated with increased subsequent pain behaviors if performed without anesthesia [6]. Provision of adequate analgesia during painful interventions attenuates abnormal neuropathology and adverse clinical outcomes [7, 8]: anesthetic exposure to treat pain is neuroprotective, not neurotoxic. Anesthetic agents are thought to induce apoptosis through γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA)–receptor agonism, N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)–receptor antagonism, or both [9]. Such apoptosis is characterized histopathologically by breakdown of nuclear membranes and condensation of nuclear contents, and functionally by marked disruption of synaptogenesis [10]. All currently available general anesthetics possess some combination of GABA agonism and/or NMDA antagonism, and virtually all have been shown to cause enhanced apoptosis and subsequent behavioral disturbances in animals [11]. Most animal data to date derive from rodents, primarily rats, although available data from nonhuman primates are concordant. Immature animals of all species studied demonstrate increased neuronal apoptosis and subsequent abnormal behaviors following exposure to anesthetics. Anesthetic neurotoxicity, however, appears limited to a critical neurodevelopmental window, and to demonstrate threshold doses and durations [11–13]. Anesthetic exposure outside this critical neurodevelopmental window, or below threshold doses and durations, is not neurotoxic. Further, and of critical relevance to human surgical practice, neurotoxicity in S. R. Hays (*) Departments of Anesthesiology & Pediatrics, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine; Pediatric Anesthesia, Monroe Carell Jr. Children’s Hospital at Vanderbilt, 2200 Children’s Way, Suite 3115, Nashville, TN 37232-9070, USA e-mail: stephen.hays@Vanderbilt.Edu