Rosai-Dorfman disease (RDD) is a rare non-Langerhans cell histiocytosis, classically affecting the lymph nodes. Even rarer extranodal disease is diagnostically challenging due to overlapping histologic features with other entities and lack of a universally agreed set of biomarkers. Cyclin D1 immunohistochemistry (IHC) may serve as a useful adjunct in diagnosing extranodal RDD. We present a retrospective case series of patients diagnosed with extranodal RDD between January 2013 and December 2023. IHC staining for cyclin D1 was performed on archived tissue samples. Baseline IHC results for biomarkers supporting the RDD diagnosis were recorded along with patient demographic characteristics, clinical features, and disease outcomes. A total of 25 patients with extranodal RDD were included: 21 women (84 %) and 4 men (16 %). The mean age at diagnosis was 42.6 years. Cutaneous and deep tissue involvement was seen in 5 (20 %) and 20 (80 %) patients, respectively. 11 patients (44 %) had disease localized to the trunk and extremities, and 13 had disease in the head and neck region (52 %), of which 5 occurred in the nose and paranasal tissues. Available follow-up data showed most patients fully recovered (n = 11; 78.6 %). However, 1 patient had disease recurrence, 1 developed blindness, and 1 developed deafness. Cyclin D1 IHC was positive in all samples (100 %), consistent with previous studies. The clinicopathologic findings in this study highlight the spectrum of potential disease sites, possible morbid outcomes related to disease site, and the diagnostic utility of cyclin D1 IHC.