Recent studies suggest that reef soundscapes may serve as long-distance navigational cues for settlement-stage larval fishes. To understand the role of acoustic signals during larval settlement, we investigated temporal and spatial patterns in coral reef soundscapes in the Florida Keys, USA. We used 14-month simultaneous acoustic recordings from two nearby reefs, coupled with environmental data, to describe temporal variability in the soundscape on scales of hours to months, and to understand abiotic and biological components. We also recorded acoustic pressure and particle acceleration (which fish larvae likely perceive) with increasing distance from the reef. High acoustic frequencies typically varied on daily cycles, while low frequencies were primarily driven by lunar cycles. Some of these patterns were explained by environmental conditions, while others were attributed to biological sounds. At both reefs, the highest sound levels (~130 dB re:1μPa) occurred during new moons of the wet season, when many larval organisms settle on the reefs. Acoustic particle acceleration did not propagate as far as predicted from the plane-wave equation. The patterns uncovered here provide valuable insights into underwater acoustic scenes, and this study represents an example of novel acoustic instruments and analysis techniques that can be applied to any ecosystem.