Nagata Technique Research Articles

Brent Technique of Repair Versus Nagata Auricular Reconstruction for Microtia Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

Up to 17.4 in every 10,000 births are affected by microtia, but no consensus exists on a gold standard technique for autogenous repair. In this study, the authors compare 2 common methods-the Brent and Nagata autogenous costal cartilage ear reconstruction techniques. A systematic review of the literature and a quantitative meta-analysis to compare the outcomes of these 2 approaches were performed. The outcomes analyzed included rates of infection, necrosis, cartilage exposure, cartilage resorption, hematoma, wire extrusion, and hypertrophic scar. A MEDLINE database systematic review with the following keywords: microtia, Brent, and Nagata was performed. Case reports and articles without original data or patient outcomes were excluded. Inclusion methods for study selection are outlined in Supplemental Digital Content 1, http://links.lww.com/SCS/F461 , below. The prevalence of outcomes for each study was analyzed through meta-analysis of proportions using Stata. A total of 536 potential studies were retrieved for review. Twelve of these studies met inclusion criteria. Four studies utilized the Brent method of repair with the inclusion of 563 ear reconstructions. Nine studies implemented the Nagata technique in 2304 reconstructions. Two studies directly compared the Brent (327 ears) and Nagata (471 ears) techniques. The calculated rate and 95% confidence intervals are summarized in Supplemental Digital Content 2, http://links.lww.com/SCS/F461 . There were no statistically significant differences in complication rates between the Brent and Nagata microtic reconstruction techniques identified in this study. The Brent and Nagata microtia reconstruction techniques have no difference in the risk of infection, necrosis, cartilage exposure, cartilage resorption, hematoma, wire extrusion, or hypertrophic scars.

A Hybrid Auricular Framework of Autologous Rib Cartilage and a Porous Polyethylene Implant for Reconstruction of Congenital Microtia: A Modification of Nagata's Technique.

Background: An implant (porous polyethylene) is an alternative to rib cartilage for microtia reconstruction but carries a risk of extrusion. Objective: To evaluate the outcome of a hybrid framework of implant with rib cartilage for microtia reconstruction. Methods: Patients who underwent Nagata's technique for microtia reconstruction were reviewed for complications and aesthetic score. In stage 1, a rib cartilage framework or a hybrid framework of implant with rib cartilage was used. In stage 2, the framework was elevated and supported by an implant for projection. Postoperative outcomes were reported for both groups. Results: Forty-four ears of 40 patients underwent surgery. Eleven ears received a rib auricular framework and 33 ears a hybrid auricular framework. The mean postoperative follow-up for the rib and hybrid groups was 76.3 and 43.1 months, respectively. No supporting postauricular implant extruded, whereas stainless-steel wires extruded in seven ears (15.9%). Five (15.2%) hybrid frameworks were removed due to infection or extrusion. Mean operating time was 2 h shorter in the hybrid group. Aesthetic outcomes were similar for both groups. Conclusion: A hybrid framework of rib and implant that requires less harvested cartilage is feasible for microtia reconstruction, but caution should be used due to its higher explantation rate.

A Two-Flap Combination for Auricular Elevation in Microtia Reconstruction.

The aims of this study were to describe and evaluate the effectiveness of combined flaps, a modification of the Nagata technique, for providing a reasonable projection for reconstructed auricles. The authors modified the Nagata method for covering the cartilage block by introducing a new combined flap technique, including the temporoparietal skin flap and retroauricular flap. The authors compared the shape, size, and position of the reconstructed ear to the opposite ear, and we evaluated postoperative complications and patient satisfaction levels. They verified the effectiveness of the combined flap by assessing flap necrosis, skin color, thickness, hair in the auricular area, and scars. A total of 38 consecutive patients (39 ears) with microtia, aged 6 to 34 years, underwent reconstruction using the modified method and were followed up for 33.6 months on average. The reconstructed auricle's shape was well defined, with 41.0% having good and 15.4% having excellent results. Most cases achieved good and acceptable levels in size, position, medial longitudinal axis angle, and auriculocephalic angles, and 79.9% of patients/their families were satisfied. The authors observed no cases of flap necrosis or hypertrophic scarring, and there were low rates of flap complications, such as unmatched skin color (7.7%), unacceptable thickness (5.1%), or hair and stretch marks (10.3%). The modified method's reconstructed ear achieved stable projection, symmetric appearance, and obvious anatomical landmarks with high patient satisfaction. The combined flap method showed certain advantages: high survival rate, less skin contrast, no hypertrophic scars, and fewer complications. Therapeutic, IV.

Reconstruction of congenital microtia after ear canaloplasty using V-Y advancement of a temporal triangular flap.

BackgroundReconstruction of congenital microtia remains challenging, particularly in patients with a history of ear canaloplasty due to insufficient regional soft tissue. The insertion of a tissue expander prior to implantation of the cartilage framework has traditionally been employed. However, this procedure could induce additional morbidity. Herein, we present a method using V-Y advancement of a temporal triangular flap to gain additional soft tissue in these challenging cases.MethodsCongenital microtia patients with a history of ear canaloplasty who underwent auricular reconstruction using the Nagata technique between 2016 and 2020 were reviewed. To obtain additional soft tissue, V-Y advancement of a temporal triangular flap was performed concurrently with implantation of the costal cartilage framework, without prior insertion of a tissue expander. The outcomes of these patients with respect to postoperative complications and esthetics were evaluated.ResultsEight patients with bilateral lesions were included. No specific complications developed after the first-stage surgery. However, one patient experienced complications after the second stage (auricular elevation). An analysis of the esthetic results showed most patients had excellent outcomes, achieving a satisfactory convolution. The median number of operations needed to complete reconstruction was 2, which was fewer than required using the conventional method with prior insertion of a tissue expander.ConclusionsIn patients with a history of previous canaloplasty, V-Y advancement of a temporal triangular flap could serve as an alternative to tissue expansion for microtia reconstruction. This technique provided reliable and satisfactory results with a reduced number of surgical stages.

Satisfaction and health-related quality of life of patients with microtia following reconstructive surgery using the Nagata technique.

This study aimed to investigate the functional outcomes, satisfaction, and quality of life of patients with microtia following reconstructive surgery. This cross-sectional study was conducted using retrospective data of patients with microtia following reconstructive surgery using the Nagata technique. Data were obtained from the medical records of patients who underwent reconstructive surgery at the Division of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Dr. Cipto Mangunkusumo Hospital between 2014 and 2018. All eligible patients were referred to participate in this study between November 2018 and March 2019. The hearing function was assessed by a professional audiologist after surgery. Patient satisfaction was evaluated by interview using a previously developed questionnaire, while quality of life was assessed using the EuroQol-5D-Young questionnaire. Thirty-one eligible subjects were included in the study. Pain and discomfort were the most commonly reported factors related to the quality of life following surgery. Approximately 67.7% of the patients were satisfied; 19.4% were very satisfied, and 12.9% reported acceptance of their surgical outcomes. The most common complication was infection (n = 8). Most patients did not experience any problems in their lives after microtia surgery. The highest rate of satisfactory outcomes was observed for the lobule subunit, which was assumed to be associated with the use of the Z-plasty technique. The most common complication was infection, as environmental hygiene was the most important factor. Thus, further concern for maintaining good hygiene is necessary to improve the quality of reconstructive surgery. The level of satisfaction with microtia reconstructive surgery was adequate. Most patients had a good health-related quality of life without experiencing any problems.

Multiscale sterilizable 3D printed auricular templates to guide cartilaginous framework sizing and sculpture during autologous microtia reconstruction

SummaryMicrotia reconstruction using autologous costal cartilage can be one of the most challenging tasks in reconstructive surgery. An intraoperative guide using 2-dimentional drawing of the contralateral ear on an x-ray film remains the current standard of care. In this paper, we present the use of computer-aided design and desktop 3D printing to fabricate low cost, sterilizable auricular carving templates to serve as a peri-operative reference for microtia reconstruction. The design was made as a single component which incorporated the usual anatomic reference points of the ear based on Nagata technique as a Stereo-lithography file format (. STL) for 3D printing. The templates were created in sizes ranging from 55 mm to 70 mm with a 2 mm increment with an average production cost of 0.26 US dollars per material per template and about 4.5 US dollars for the whole set. Individual templates were then 3D-printed using a thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU 95A) semiflexible filament on a desktop fused deposition modeling, Ultimaker 2 + 3D printer. The produced template tolerated the sterilization process with no structural changes as compared to its pre-sterilization condition. In conclusion, we present cost-effective, sterilizable, multiscale auricular templates to guide the pre- and intra-operative carving of the cartilaginous framework during microtia reconstruction with more accuracy in a time efficient manner, thereby overcoming the drawbacks of using the traditional x-ray film. The templates are readily accessible and sharable for free through open-source software and can be directly 3D-printed using an affordable desktop 3D printer.

A Rare Case of Infantile Hemangioma Requiring Ear Reconstruction

A Rare Case of Infantile Hemangioma Requiring Ear Reconstruction

A novel two-stage strategy combing tissue expansion and Nagata`s technique for total auricular reconstruction

This study was performed to explore the clinical application of the Nagata's technique for combing tissue expansion in auricular reconstruction. The auricular reconstruction was performed in two surgical stages. At the first stage, an 80 ml expander was inserted in the mastoid region after preoperative evaluation. After a gradual expansion period and nearly 2-month rest time, the flap achieved the appropriate area and thickness. At the second stage, the expander was removed and a three-layer cartilage framework was inserted into the pocket through a Y-shaped lobule incision, and the earlobe and tragus were rebuild simultaneously. From 2012 to 2016, 104 microtia patients underwent auricular reconstruction with this method in our hospital. Patients were followed up for between 6 months and 2 years. Ninety-six patients and their families were satisfied with the results, especially the clear outline, appropriate color, good projection, and the symmetry of bilateral ears. Complications of ischemic necrosis of the distal earlobe and skin of the concha cavity occurred in two cases, hematoma after the first stage occurred in two cases, and four patients needed further restorations. A novel two-stage strategy combing tissue expansion and Nagata's technique is an effective and efficient technique for auricular reconstruction with satisfying medium-term results.

The testing of an artificial modified bacterial cellulose auricle skeleton in an animal model.

The auricle is a part of the external ear. It consists of skin, cartilage, muscles and adipose tissue. The cartilage gives shape to the structure. There are several indications for reconstruction, such as congenital anomalies, mechanical injuries, and burns, and a range of methods have been proposed for the complete reconstruction of the auricle. A bacterial cellulose membrane, at least 25 mm in thickness, was produced in vitro by Acetobacter xylinum culture. The entire artificial human auricle skeleton was made to scale to allow its implantation into an animal model - Wistar rats. Forty rats were divided into four groups of 10 animals. Each group was assigned a different resection time: 14 days, 30 days, 90 days or 720 days. After each resection, an examination of the artificial skeleton and the tissues surrounding it was conducted. The surgical procedure was based on the Nagata technique. Resection after 14, 30, 90 and 720 days shows the progression of the healing process and integration of the artificial skeleton into the animal body. There are no signs of change in the shape or structure of the skeleton. Several surgical techniques and biotechnological methods have been developed over the past few years to improve the results of facial reconstruction. Other approaches can be used to create auricle cartilage, based on scaffolds and chondrocytes. My findings indicate that modified bacterial cellulose can be used to form an effective artificial auricle which appears to maintain its shape and elasticity, with no signs of degradation.

Autologous cartilage microtia reconstruction: Complications and risk factors

BackgroundThe Brent or Nagata techniques of microtia reconstruction and their modifications involve complicated frameworks; therefore, complications are inevitable. The authors aimed to provide comprehensive knowledge regarding the occurrence, development, prognosis, risk factors, and treatment of complications. MethodsThis study was a retrospective review of patients who underwent autologous cartilage microtia reconstruction at a single auricular plastic and reconstructive center between March 2005 and June 2016. Custom database software was used to process data from patients with microtia. Details of postoperative complications were collected during follow-up for analysis. ResultsA total of 470 procedures (stage I) were performed on 429 patients. The mean (±SD) age at surgery was 12.27 ± 5.01 years (range, 6–32 years). The mean time to follow-up was 3.67 ± 2.45 years (range, 1–11 years). The complication rate was 2.98% (4/134) with the Brent technique and 12.2% (38/311) with the Nagata technique. A multivariate logistic regression analysis of complications of microtia reconstruction revealed that age, sex, and laterality were not associated with postoperative complications (p > 0.05). Surgical technique affected the incidence of complications. The Nagata technique resulted in a higher risk for complications (OR 6.14 [95% CI 1.63–23.19]; p < 0.01). ConclusionThe development of complications was a dynamic process. There was a learning curve associated with autologous cartilage microtia reconstruction. Orthopedists or otologists aspiring to master microtia reconstruction should have a fundamental understanding of the procedure and be aware of possible complications.

Predictors for Unfavorable Projection of the Constructed Auricle following Ear Elevation Surgery in Microtia Reconstruction

Nagata's two-stage technique for microtia reconstruction using autologous costal cartilage consists of the implantation of a fabricated cartilage framework and the elevation of the constructed auricle. Achieving long-lasting, sufficient projection of the auricle is a goal of second-stage surgery; however, unfavorable outcomes have been seen in some patients, with suboptimal long-term elevation. The present study aimed to investigate prognostic factors that might contribute to adverse outcomes following the ear elevation operation. Outcomes of patients with congenital microtia who underwent auricular reconstruction with a modified Nagata technique between January of 2007 and June of 2015 were reviewed. Unfavorable elevation was defined as cases with an auriculocephalic angle less than 20 degrees or with a shallow auricular sulcus requiring revision operations. Univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted to identify independent predictors for the unfavorable elevation. A total of 309 patients representing 323 cases were analyzed with a median follow-up period of 26 months. The mean age of the patients was 15.1 years. The majority of cases had lobule-type microtia. Hemifacial microsomia was present in 114 cases. Canalplasty was performed in 117 cases before the auricular elevation. Unfavorable elevation was observed in 72 cases (22.3 percent). Multivariate analyses showed that the presence of hemifacial microsomia and performance of canalplasty less than or equal to 12 months before the ear elevation operation were independent risk factors for the unfavorable elevation. Several preoperative factors, including combined anomalies and operative timing and sequences, might influence the outcomes of the ear elevation operation. Risk, III.

Firm Elevation of Reconstructed Auricle Using Polydactyly Digit in Microtia.

Total ear reconstruction for microtia is usually accomplished in 2 stages which is known as Nagata technique. After framework fabrication and implantation, the elevation procedure is required as a second step surgery. The authors are introducing a novel material for augmenting projection of rib cartilage framework in microtia treatment.

The Nagata technique for microtia reconstruction

Multiple techniques for auricular reconstruction for microtia have been described. Reconstruction using autologous costal cartilage continues to be the most widely implemented technique for repair. Recreation of a three-dimensional framework mimicking the curves and contours of a normal ear, while also maximizing stability, is crucial in reconstructing the auricle. Additionally, soft tissue management, although generalized in approach, is specific to each patient and greatly influences surgical outcomes. In the present article, we discuss the Nagata technique for auricular reconstruction, a 2-staged technique using costal cartilage grafts to rebuild the auricle.

Fabrication of three-dimensional scan-to-print ear model for microtia reconstruction

BackgroundMicrotia is a congenital deformity of the external ear that occurs in 1 of every 5000 births. Microtia reconstruction using traditional two-dimensional templates does not provide highly detailed ear shapes. Here, we describe the feasibility of using a three-dimensional (3D) ear model as a reference. Materials and methodsSeven children aged from 11 to 16 (6 grade III and 1 grade II microtia) were recruited from Seoul National University Children's Hospital, Korea. We generated 3D–computer-aided design models of each patient's ear by performing 3D laser scanning for a mirror-transformed cast of their normal ear. The 3D-printed ear model was used in microtia reconstruction surgery following the Nagata technique, and its shape was compared with the casted ear model. ResultsOne patient experienced irritation caused by accidently pouring resin into the external auditory meatus, and another had minor skin necrosis; both complications were successfully treated. The average percentage differences of the superior, inferior, anterior, posterior, and lateral views between the casted and 3D-printed ear models were 1.17%, 1.48%, 1.64%, 1.80%, and 5.44%, respectively (average: 2.31%), where the difference between the casted ear models and traditional two-dimensional templates were 16.03% in average. ConclusionsOur results show that simple microtia reconstruction can be performed using 3D ear models. The 3D-printed ear models of each patient were consistent and accurately represented the thickness, depth, and height of the normal ear. The availability of the 3D-printed ear model in the operating room reduced the amount of unnecessary work during surgery.

Single-Stage Autologous Ear Reconstruction for Microtia

The authors have been using the Nagata technique since 2002. In this review of 100 consecutive ear reconstructions, the authors present technique modifications that have evolved over this period that have contributed to improved auricular contour and that now allow for auricular reconstruction in a single stage. This study is a retrospective review of a prospectively acquired database. The series is restricted to primary reconstructions performed for congenital microtia. Photographs of 10 consecutive patients are presented to demonstrate the results of the technique. Surgical complication rates are discussed. One hundred ear reconstructions were performed in 96 patients. There were 75 primary cases of congenital microtia. Twenty-four ears underwent a two-stage reconstruction, and 51 ears were reconstructed with a Nagata stage I procedure or a single-stage reconstruction. There was a gradual shift in technique, with a trend to perform fewer Nagata stage II outsetting procedures and more single-stage reconstructions. In patients who underwent an ear reconstruction in two stages, the surgical complication rate was 22 percent. In the last 40 consecutive ear reconstructions since abandoning the two-stage approach, the surgical complication rate is now 15 percent. A modification of Nagata's technique of autologous ear reconstruction for microtia is described. Modifications of the three-dimensional framework address the contour of the inferior crus and control tragal projection and position. Inclusion of a projection block and recruitment of retroauricular skin allow for symmetric projection of the ear in a single stage. Therapeutic, IV.

Reconstruction of Segmental Acquired Auricular Defects

The 2-stage Nagata method for auricular reconstruction in patients with microtia is a widely accepted technique. We have modified this technique into a single-stage procedure for the reconstruction of acquired segmental auricular defects. A prospective analysis was made of the senior author's first 20 consecutive cases over a 4-year period (February 2004 to February 2008). The mean age of patients in our series was 34 years (range, 17-59 years). There were 15 males and 5 females; 13 were right-sided and 7 were left-sided segmental auricular defects. Five patients had had previous auricular reconstruction including local flaps and grafts. Costal cartilage harvest was ipsilateral to the defect in all cases. All 20 patients underwent a single-stage modification of the Nagata technique. Mean duration of surgery was 8.56 hours (range, 5.5-11.5 hours). Mean hospital stay was 7.6 days (range, 4-19 days). Mean time from initial surgery to a satisfactory completion of treatment was 21 months. Overall, a low complication rate and high patient satisfaction were observed in this series. We believe the single-stage modified Nagata technique offers consistent high-quality results in the treatment of acquired segmental auricular defects. All patients undergoing autologus ear reconstruction need to be assessed in a multidisciplinary setting and should be offered all other options for treatment.

Negative pressure manoeuvre in microtia reconstruction with autologous rib cartilage

In microtia reconstruction, maintaining a healthy contact between the skin and the fabricated cartilage framework is essential to attaining a smooth and accentuated contour of the reconstructed auricle. Conventional means to achieve this include bolster sutures and continuous suction drains, both of which have associated shortcomings. A new dressing method was developed and applied in 10 consecutive patients who underwent the first of a two-stage microtia reconstruction using the Nagata technique. A small catheter was introduced into the space between the skin and the cartilage framework. Negative pressure was applied through the catheter, drawing the skin onto the cartilage framework. This evens out the skin, accentuates the contour of the framework and concurrently eliminates potential dead space. Skin contact on the framework is maintained whilst the catheter is removed and an occlusive transparent dressing is applied to the ear. Of the 10 cases in which this manoeuvre was performed, one had to be converted to the bolster suture technique due to a persistent air leak from the wound. Overall results of the nine cases in which this technique was carried out successfully demonstrate smooth skin contour and excellent definition of the fabricated framework. This negative pressure manoeuvre provides a simple, safe and consistent approach to achieving a smooth and accentuated contour in auricular reconstruction.

Framework Changes Using Costal Cartilage for Microtia Reconstruction

Since a known growth-of-cartilage framework is used for reconstruction of microtia under the Brent technique, we set out to address the behavior of the framework under the Nagata technique. A retrospective analysis of costal cartilage auricular reconstruction procedures. A total of 28 patients who underwent costal cartilage auricular reconstruction between 1998 and 2005. Reconstruction of microtia using the 2-stage Nagata technique. The parameters checked were patient age at the time of reconstruction, follow-up time, and measurements of the auricular framework height and width both at the time of implantation (represented by the template size) and at final follow-up. A significant change in auricular height and width was observed. The height decreased by 3.1%, while the width increased by 4.0%. This change was not influenced by follow-up time. Auricular reconstruction with the Nagata technique was undertaken when the patients were aged 9 to 10 years, when the auricle had reached nearly its final size. According to our patient sample, it is our opinion that a policy change is unjustifiable.

Burned ear: the use of a staged Nagata technique for ear reconstruction

Four features, manifested in various combinations, characterise deformity in the burned ear: (i) the presence of scarred skin at the site of and surrounding the ear, with dramatic loss of skin elasticity; (ii) the presence of longitudinal scars of the pinna due to previous drainage of the perichondritis as an initial trial for saving the ear; (iii) absence of different components of the framework of the ear, mostly the helix/antihelix complex (the cartilage-containing part) with or without the ear lobule; (iv) scarred chest wall due to associated burns of the skin of the chest. In the face of these deformities, the surgical goals for auricular reconstruction include the following: (i) removal of the remaining cartilage of the burned ear, part or the whole of it in severe cases, because it may be a source of infection; (ii) wide exposure of the cartilage of the ribs through sufficient chest wall incision to overcome the severe fibrosis of the burned chest wall skin; (iii) creation of delicate smooth cartilage framework, free of sharp edges; (iv) creation of a skin pocket of sufficient size. Eight patients with a unilateral or bilateral deformity of the ear following burns were operated on during the period from May 2006 to July 2007, with a median age of 23.25 years. There was a good colour match between the reconstructed auricle and the surrounding skin. Patient satisfaction was high and the results were well accepted.

Modification of the second stage of auricular elevation in Nagata's technique for treating microtia

The ultimate goal in treating congenital microtia is the reconstruction of an auricle with a natural appearance as close as possible to the healthy one in terms of shape, contour, size, texture, position, and projection. Here we present another option to the second stage of raising the ear in Nagata's technique for treating microtia. The first step includes implantation of a cartilaginous framework and transposition of the ear lobe. Raising the cartilage leaves a skin defect behind the auricle. Instead of using a superficial temporoparietal fascia flap as described by Nagata, we raise a simple rotation flap from the mastoid and neck to close the defect with a minimal scar. The advantages of this technique include firm elevation, good frontal projection, and a natural appearance of the auriculo-cephalic sulcus with a normal retroauricular hairline. In addition, the procedure fast and practical, creates no additional scars on the scalp, and preserves the superficial temporoparietal fascia.