Abstract. The German repository site selection procedure calls for a radioactive waste containment zone with a low-permeability host rock (kf<10-10 m s−1, StandAG §23, 5) and long-term sealing by barrier materials (EndlSiAnfV, 2020; ESK, 2019). The potential host rocks, clay and rock salt, as well as the considered barrier materials, bentonite and compacted crushed salt, show permeability in the range of kf∼10-16 m s−1 (K∼10-21 m2). These low values suggest that advective flow is as slow as diffusive mass flux. Measuring such low permeability with adequate accuracy challenges measurement setups and respective error evaluation. Methodologies. Several low-permeability measurements are carried out by transient tests, e.g. by monitoring controlled fluid pressure changes in: (1) pressure decay and (2) oscillating pulse tests. The first method (1) deviates permeability from the time needed to compensate pressure differences through the sample. The latter (2) monitors phase shift and amplitude attenuation of controlled pressure pulses passing through the sample. Any permeability measurement needs to be post-processed, e.g. for: (1) material-intrinsic controls (saturation state, storativity, the fluids' compressibility, etc.), (2) environmental controls (temperature, confining pressures, etc.) and (3) theoretical considerations (Klinkenberg correction, multi-phase wetting angles, etc.). Salts. A porosity-permeability relation was found down to K=10-19 m2 (e.g., Popp et al., 2007). Testing fluids were NaCl brine, oils, He and N2 as a fluid. As a matter of current research, a critical, low-permeability value might be associated with the so-called “percolation threshold” that defines the minimal requirements for an interconnected pore system (e.g., DAEF, 2016). Clays. A major challenge is the long duration of sample saturation (up to several months) and pressure equilibration (often days), as well as precise, temperature-compensated measuring and the determination of the samples' storativity (e.g., Winhausen et al., 2021). Testing fluids are commonly designed mixtures mimicking the rocks' pore waters. Geotechnical barrier materials. The permeability testing performed is similar to that of salt and clays mentioned above. However, both barrier materials, crushed salt and bentonite, have significant permeability early after emplacement. This is beneficial, as it allows the outflow of unwanted canister corrosion gases. Eventually, the permeability drops by orders of magnitude and the barriers become tight seals in the long-term. Here, identifying the gas entry/breakthrough pressure has been valuable (e.g., Rothfuchs et al., 2007). Figure 1 shows a preliminary sensitivity analysis as an example of pressure decay measurements. It suggests that the pressure equilibration term (c), and hence the test duration, is most sensitive to the calculation of low permeability. However, the large variation of (representative) material and environmental controls make permeability measurements complex. This workshop aims to encourage discussions on uncertainty and sensitivity of the influencing controls, such that it may lead to a “best-practice” guide for permeability measurements.
Read full abstract