The first thing to note about this new volume about the history of Jerusalem is its claim to being the only comprehensive volume that documents the full 3,000-year history of Jerusalem in the English or French language (2).1 Although this claim, at first, seems preposterous—given the number of books written about Jerusalem—the authors suggest that no “real” single-volume scientific history with a single narrative voice (English or French) has seen publication in recent years. On the one hand are the many scholarly books covering various aspects of the 3,000-year history, often as anthologies comprising chapters with multiple authors—for example, the Routledge Handbook on Jerusalem, which boasts thirty-five chapters by thirty-five different authors!2 On the other hand are the abundant single-authored books that purport to cover the history of Jerusalem, but not even their own authors consider them to be “real” history books—for example, Simon Sebag Montefiore’s Jerusalem: The Biography (New York, 2011), largely an interconnected narrative of individuals’ personal stories, and Karen Armstrong’s A History of Jerusalem: One City, Three Faiths (London, 1996), primarily concerned with religious myth.None of these volumes are history in the way that the authors of Jerusalem: History of a Global City present it. They do not cover, in one narrative arc, the social-scientific history and geography of the urban space known as Jerusalem and its environment. This volume is an urban history of Jerusalem that focuses as much on the materiality of the city as on its political, social, and civic history. It deviates from many previous histories in its abandonment of religious history. According to the authors, constructing Jerusalem’s narrative only or primarily through the eyes of religion distorts the city’s actual history, that is, its history as a city. Religion obviously plays a huge role, but it need not be the centerpiece.The authors’ urban-studies approach is closely tied to their other methodology, which is to look for the continuities and bridges between the traditionally labeled and segmented eras within this long history (the “biblical,” “Byzantine,” or “Muslim” eras). By pushing the religious concerns and lenses aside in favor of the urban, civic, political, and material ones, the book demonstrates how Jerusalem persisted as one Middle Eastern city among many others, despite changes in regime, imperial situation, or religious community. The early Israelite settlers differed little materially from the Canaanites who lived in Jerusalem before them, and Saladin built his renewed Muslim city, to a great extent, on the infrastructure—both material and civic—left in place by the Franks. By examining, sometimes minutely, local conditions while being attentive to the larger international framework, the book effectively conveys how the continuities of this global city emerged. Regardless of external powers and constituencies, Jerusalem has remained extraordinarily important to people throughout the world, even as a city with its own distinct quirks of topography and local history.As a scholarly narrative covering 3,000 years in 264 pages, this volume offers an excellent comprehensive history, demonstrating complexity without getting bogged down in details. It is even-handed and relatively unjudgmental. That said, however, readers expecting a fine-grained exposition will have to look elsewhere. Moreover, the book is largely silent about its collaborative methodology; it provides no clue about who wrote what part. Collaboration between humanists and historians—a methodological approach in its relative infancy—deserves greater transparency. Educators will rightly applaud the product, but research scholars might like to know more about the process.
Read full abstract