Despite offering multiple ecosystem services, such as their ability to sequester carbon (C), regenerating mixedwood boreal forests are often only managed to increase their coniferous part by controlling their competition, impacting the ecosystem C stocks. The aim of this study was to compare the short-term effect of motor-manual release treatments of variable intensities: broadcast brushing (brushing), release-from-below (RFB) and crop-tree release (CTR) on carbon stocks in soil (SOC) and live biomass (aboveground and root C stocks). The stands treated by brushing had twice as much SOC stocks than in the other stands, at the 5- to 10 cm depth. RFB treatment kept the largest aspen stems in the stands and retained enough total live biomass to compensate for the initial loss. Despite being similar in intensity, stands treated with RFB had more than twice the amount of live biomass than stands treated by brushing. Overall, total C stocks (SOC and live biomass) did not change between the stands but the distribution among the different C pools did, with the live biomass being the most impacted by the treatments. The design of the RFB treatment seemed promising to mitigate C loss during early forest operations while still controlling fast-growing competitors.
Read full abstract